Peter Navarro, senior adviser to U.S. President Donald Trump, publicly accused Ottawa on Thursday of “arrogance and dishonesty” in ongoing trade negotiations, comparing Canada’s negotiators to “a high school team taking on the New York Knicks” as both governments work toward a possible year-end deal.
The attack landed from Shenzhen, where Prime Minister Mark Carney spoke with Trump about trade on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit, alongside Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim and Chinese President Xi Jinping. The two leaders agreed, according to a post-meeting readout, “to continue the work and to stay in close contact.”
Here is why that timing matters. The insults arrived in the same week Trump’s advisers had begun suggesting a deal could be reached before the end of 2026, after the administration softened its tone following November’s midterm elections.
“That doesn’t end well for Canada,” Navarro wrote on X, adding that Canadian negotiators’ “misreading of their position is really something else.”

Navarro accuses Canada of cheating U.S.
Thursday’s posts followed a memo Navarro sent Carney on Tuesday, in response to him suggesting that Canada could seek greater Chinese involvement in the domestic auto sector. Navarro also circulated a short interview clip on X reiterating old grievances.
“Canada cheats us,” he said, citing lumber, dairy, steel and aluminum, and claiming Canada had historically cheated the U.S. by “out-negotiating” the country in NAFTA and by adding clauses that “really hurt” the U.S.
The arrogance and dishonesty of Ottawa on trade and misreading of their position is really something else. They are like a high school team taking on the New York Knicks. That doesn’t end well for Canada. pic.twitter.com/rsb6zdQKBC
How the talks broke down — and reopened
The history here runs deep. During Trump’s first term, he sought to terminate NAFTA over softwood lumber and Canada’s dairy supply management system. In 2020, the three parties replaced it with the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA).
But there is a catch. When the agreement came up for review, Trump’s administration chose not to renew it in July. A month later, trade talks halted entirely after Carney rejected a deal he said threatened Canada’s sovereignty and responded with counter-tariffs on U.S. goods.
The November midterms then changed the political weather. Republicans lost control of both the House of Representatives and the Senate amid voter concern over affordability and the impact of tariffs, and the administration’s tone on trade with Canada shifted.
LeBlanc’s cautious bottom line in Ottawa
Canada-U.S. Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc told MPs in Ottawa on Tuesday that a deal remained possible — while cautioning there is no guarantee Canada can restore the terms of CUSMA. He provided an update on recent progress in the trade talks to an advisory committee on Thursday; that committee has held 10 meetings to develop responses to Trump’s tariffs and discuss the future of CUSMA.
That warning cuts against the optimism. The two positions, stated plainly:
Washington's negotiators, in Navarro's framing, hold overwhelming power and see Canada as misjudging its own position. Ottawa’s position, as Carney’s readout describes it, is a deal that would create good jobs, boost affordability, and “fully respect Canada’s languages, culture, and sovereignty.”
Freeland enters the fight
Navarro also aimed at former deputy prime minister Chrystia Freeland, over an essay she published in The New York Times on Tuesday. “That former trade minister Chrystia Freeland went off on us yesterday in the Gray Lady. It’s like, what is she thinking?” he said.
Her essay, “Welcome Back America! It’s Your Turn to Be Sorry,” encouraged Canada and the world’s other democracies to embrace the U.S. midterm election results, saying it’s an opportunity to renew the global democratic alliance and invite Washington “to rejoin us in a new, more balanced partnership.”
Carney secures trade deals, reduces U.S. reliance
The Carney trip, which included summits in Ireland, the Philippines, Cambodia and China, affirmed Carney’s plans to secure new trade agreements and reduce Canada’s reliance on the U.S. He discussed a free-trade agreement with his Philippine counterpart expected to be signed next year, and met Chinese President Xi Jinping, with the two leaders agreeing to drop trade restrictions on more goods.
For observers watching the spat over Chinese involvement in Canada’s auto sector, the message is part of Carney’s whirlwind trip and broader diplomatic engagement.
| Milestone | Outcome |
|---|---|
| 2020 — CUSMA replaces NAFTA | Signed by Canada, the U.S. and Mexico |
| July 2026 — CUSMA review | Trump administration does not renew |
| August 2026 | Carney rejects deal, imposes counter-tariffs; talks halt |
| November 2026 — midterms | Republicans lose House and Senate; tone softens |
| Nov. 19, 2026 — APEC, Shenzhen | Carney and Trump agree to keep negotiating |
What comes before the end of 2026
Trump’s advisers have suggested in recent weeks that a trade deal could land before the year ends. LeBlanc told MPs in Ottawa on Tuesday that a trade deal remained possible, but cautioned there is no guarantee Canada can restore the terms of CUSMA.
Navarro, born in 1949 in Cambridge, Massachusetts, is an economist by training, holding a PhD in economics from Harvard University. Before joining Trump’s first administration in January 2017 as an advisor on trade, he spent more than 20 years as a professor of economics and public policy at the University of California, Irvine, and ran unsuccessfully for office in San Diego five times.
He is a longtime China hawk, having argued there that the country poses an existential threat to the United States and written books including The Coming China Wars (2006) and Death by China (2011). After leaving his first White House role, he was sanctioned by China. In several of those books, he quoted a fictional economist named “Ron Vara” — an anagram of his own surname — as a source.
So the Knicks line may be theater, or a bargaining chip, or both. The next dated marker on record is the leaders’ own commitment — made in Shenzhen on Nov. 19 — “to continue the work and to stay in close contact.”