Nearly 150,000 Comments Flood Census Bureau, 88% Oppose 2030 Rule Changes

Nearly 150,000 public comments flooded the Census Bureau in the last two months, and 88 percent of them said no.

The opposition targets a proposed rule that would exclude non-permanent foreign residents from the apportionment count, strip race and ethnicity questions from the decennial questionnaire for the first time since 1790, and bar any inquiry into sexual orientation.

The Bureau published the changes in September, opening a comment window that closed November 4. Forbes reported that the consortium Hands Off Our Census tallied 148,850 submissions, with the heaviest volumes from California, New York, Florida and Pennsylvania.

“It is very hard to say what the impact will be in 2030 in terms of who wins and loses seats or federal money, but it’s very easy to say that everyone will lose quality of data,” said Christopher Dick, a data scientist with Hands Off Our Census.

“Everyone will have a less clear picture of who lives in their communities. Every single poll done in this country will be worse.”

Nearly 150,000 Comments Flood Census Bureau, 88% Oppose 2030 Rule Changes
Photo: yahoo.com

The Bureau argues the overhaul ensures constitutionality, protects data integrity and reduces respondent burden. Supporters, including 22 Republican state attorneys general, contend that counting noncitizens dilutes the voting power of U.S. citizens.

Opponents counter that the 14th Amendment requires a count of the “whole number of persons in each State,” and that replacing the traditional April 1 Census Day with a three-month window keyed to tax records will miss millions of low-income non-filers and children.

The Census Bureau’s own Preliminary Regulatory Impact Analysis warns that omitting these questions will degrade the American Community Survey and other federal data streams that drive funding formulas, infrastructure planning and public health metrics.

More than 340 state, local and tribal entities formally opposed the rule, including a coalition of 20 Democratic attorneys general, the National League of Cities, the U.S. Conference of Mayors, major municipalities such as Los Angeles, New York City, Detroit and Milwaukee, and 58 tribal governments. The American Medical Association and the National Education Association also filed objections.

Meeta Anand, senior director for census and data equity at The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, said the proposed changes are “going to render public data unusable by the people who need to use it.”

Once the comment review concludes, the Bureau must respond to major concerns and send a final draft to the White House Office of Management and Budget. After OMB sign-off, the rule publishes in the Federal Register and takes effect within 30 to 60 days.

Congress could overturn it with a two-thirds majority, though Hands Off Our Census calls that unlikely. Litigation is expected; states, cities, tribal governments and civil-rights groups can sue once the rule is final, and federal judges may block it while courts weigh 14th Amendment challenges.

The Census Bureau traces its statutory roots to the 1790 decennial count, conducted by U.S. marshals and published in 1791 at a cost of $44,377.28. A permanent Census Office was created in 1902 under the Department of the Interior, then renamed the Census Bureau in 1903 when it moved to the new Department of Commerce and Labor; it remained in the Department of Commerce after the departments split in 1913.

Today the bureau runs more than 130 surveys annually, including the American Community Survey and the Economic Census, and its data directs the distribution of over $675 billion in federal funds each year.

The proposal marks a break with more than two centuries of precedent. The decennial count has included every resident regardless of citizenship status since the first census in 1790.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Oregon Democrats Deny Speaker Julie Fahey Second Term, Nominate Ben Bowman

Call of Duty Tops October US Sales, Misses 2026 Top 10