Nebraska Faces Deficits After Tax Cuts Echoing Kansas Experiment

State budget books sit on legislative desks as policymakers weigh whether Nebraska is repeating the fiscal path blazed by Kansas a decade ago.

In 2012, Kansas Gov. Sam Brownback and a Republican-controlled legislature enacted major tax reductions intended to spur economic expansion and help the state compete with lower-taxing neighbors. Instead, the policy triggered severe revenue shortfalls, budget deficits, credit rating downgrades, and cuts to public services such as education and infrastructure.

Nebraska now faces similar financial pressures following the passage of LB 754 in 2023. Signed by Nebraska Gov. Jim Pillen, the law established a phased-in reduction of the state income tax rate from 6.84% down to 3.99% by the 2027 tax year.

State leaders have since scrambled to patch hundred-million-dollar funding gaps. Pillen ordered state agencies to implement across-the-board spending cuts of 8% and tapped designated reserves, including the State Veterans Aid Fund and the Environmental Trust.

Nebraska Faces Deficits After Tax Cuts Echoing Kansas Experiment
Photo: yahoo.com

Lawmakers Work to Close $300 Million Deficit

Lawmakers are currently working to patch a deficit of approximately $300 million in the current budget, while projections point to a $1.2 billion shortfall for the upcoming two-year state budget cycle. The fiscal strain stems directly from reduced state revenues following the income tax reductions.

Proponents of the tax changes argued they were necessary after state budgets reported a $1 billion surplus in 2021 and 2022, largely driven by one-time federal relief funding during the pandemic. Governor Pillen defended the administration’s fiscal strategy after securing reelection over Democratic candidate Lynn Walz, maintaining that tax relief and spending reductions reflect a clear voter mandate.

Nebraska lawmakers mull tax incentives as state faces $1.2 billion deficit — KETV NewsWatch 7

Pillen contends that capping local government spending, shifting public education operational expenses to the state, and cutting property taxes will resolve structural budget pressures. However, critics question how the state will fund the roughly $3.3 billion spent annually on local property taxes for public education given the ongoing revenue shortfalls.

Historical Parallels in Kansas

The situation draws sharp comparisons to the policy experiment in Kansas under Brownback. The 2012 Kansas legislation reduced the top personal income tax rate from 6.45% to 4.9% and eliminated state income taxes on pass-through business entities. Kansas state revenues dropped by $700 million in the first year alone.

The economic growth promised by proponents failed to materialize at the projected levels, leading to multi-million-dollar budget deficits. The Kansas Supreme Court ultimately ordered the state to increase K-12 public education funding by $293 million across 2017 and 2018 to meet constitutional obligations.

Jim Paloucek
Photo: nptelegraph.com

Public dissatisfaction grew as state services experienced deep cuts, dropping Brownback’s approval rating to 25% and leading to legislative losses for Republicans in the 2016 election. In 2017, the Kansas Legislature ultimately repealed the 2012 tax cuts over the governor’s veto.

Pillen, a veterinarian and chair of Pillen Family Farms, served on the University of Nebraska Board of Regents from 2013 to 2023, including terms as vice-chair and chair. He played defensive back for the Nebraska Cornhuskers from 1975 to 1978 under Tom Osborne and was inducted into the Nebraska Football Hall of Fame in 2004. Born in Columbus, Nebraska, in 1955, he earned a Doctor of Veterinary Medicine from Kansas State University.

Nebraska senators will confront the projected $1.2 billion biennial budget deficit when the upcoming legislative session convenes.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Raiders Owner Mark Davis Hurt by Madden Movie Portrayal of Al Davis