New Swedish Neuroscience Compendium Receives Positive Review

A new Swedish-language compendium of neuroscience for psychiatry, running to more than 300 pages, has drawn a favorable review in Läkartidningen this week.

The compendium spans 13 chapters in which 17 Swedish researchers from across the country share insights from their specialist fields. Its ambition, according to the review, is to give a broad picture of neuroscience research with relevance for clinical psychiatry. Topics range from molecular neuropsychiatry, heredity and immunological mechanisms to drug treatment, placebo, gut flora and future possibilities for individualized treatment.

Smedler writes that the impression is at times somewhat sprawling, and that the book is not a classic textbook meant to be read from cover to cover. Rather, it consists of a series of pleasant and informative forays into the research of recent years. Despite the breadth, he finds connections between the different parts.

He says he is gladdened by the initiated and balanced descriptions of the state of research on, for example, antidepressant drugs and heredity, as well as by the discussion of the methodological problems in much of the research on the connection between gut flora and behavior.

The book also offers, in his view, a concise but reasonable account of the strengths and weaknesses of psychiatric diagnosis and of the false dichotomy between brain and mind.

The review places the book against the backdrop of an autumn debate about the validity of psychiatric diagnoses and the relationship between brain and mind. In recent years, the effect of SSRI drugs has also been questioned, while alternative treatment methods have sometimes been promoted without sufficient attention to the methodological weaknesses of studies, such as the difficulty of designing suitable control groups.

Against that background, Smedler believes the book would be valuable reading for some of those taking part in the debate. He says that only a few of the authors are psychiatrists or clinically active doctors — though competent researchers — something he suggests says something about how busy clinicians are today.

The book, with current references in several rapidly developing research fields, is recommended to doctors in general and those with an interest in psychiatry in particular, and could also appeal to interested readers without a medical background. For the more experienced researcher, however, much of the content is probably familiar and at a basic level.

Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

Galatasaray to Raise Batrakov’s Release Clause to €100 Million

University of Bern Students Vote for Plant-Based Cafeterias but University Rejects Mandate