Le Monde Analysis: LFI MEPs Approved Fewer Than Half of EU Ukraine Support Texts Since 2024

Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s party backed fewer than half the European Parliament texts on Ukraine put to its lawmakers since 2024, Le Monde reported, challenging the claim that its support for Kyiv has been constant since the Russian invasion.

The findings by Le Monde’s fact-checking desk, Les Décodeurs, land in the middle of a campaign in which Mélenchon, the La France insoumise (LFI) candidate, is under fire over remarks about the occupied Donbass, according to Lemonde. Rivals read both episodes as evidence of ambiguity on Ukraine — a charge his party rejects.

According to Le Monde, the nine LFI members of the European Parliament were called to vote in plenary on 22 texts dealing with the war since the current legislature began in 2024. A majority of the delegation approved only 10. It rejected five outright and abstained on seven.

“[LFI] has systematically supported, notably in the European Parliament, the texts and plans of support to Ukraine to give it the capacity to defend itself, as long as it remains the object of Russia’s illegal aggression,” the party said in a statement, quoted by Le Monde. The party insists its position has been “constant since 2022.”

LFI describes the rejections and abstentions not as a lack of support but as “exceptions” — cases, it says, where the texts in question contradicted its own position on the conflict. Le Monde’s count puts the burden of that argument on the details of each vote, which its analysis sets out at length.

Le Monde Analysis: LFI MEPs Approved Fewer Than Half of EU Ukraine Support Texts Since 2024
Photo: lefigaro.fr

A referendum remark that would not fade

The controversy began on November 7, at a meeting in Le Bourget (Seine-Saint-Denis). There, Mélenchon raised the possibility of a referendum aiming to ask the population of the occupied Donbass “if it wants to be Ukrainian or Russian,” Le Monde reported.

The comment drew immediate criticism from several of his adversaries, who saw in it a confirmation of his ambivalence toward Kyiv. Mélenchon responded by accusing the media of having “truqué” his words, while LFI said he wanted “all the populations concerned” to be consulted, according to Le Monde’s account of the episode.

“Co-belligerent” warning and a minister’s rebuke

The dispute widened on Tuesday, when Mélenchon warned that France could “in no case” become a “cobelligérant” in Ukraine. Writing on X, he cited the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs concerning the presence of French soldiers operating in that country, which Sergei Lavrov had earlier described as a “participation directe” to the conflict.

“We must in no case become co-belligerents in Ukraine. The problem is posed, as the Insoumis parliamentary group said in its statement” on Monday by demanding that Parliament be consulted on this deployment, Mélenchon wrote on X.

Small contingents of French soldiers have been operating in Ukraine for several months to train Ukrainian military personnel and participate in the maintenance of equipment, a source having knowledge of the file told the AFP, confirming information revealed by the radio RFI. Their mission excludes any combat action, a source indicated.

LFI invoked in its communiqué Article 35 of the Constitution which stipulates that the government must inform Parliament “of its decision to make foreign intervention forces intervene, at the latest three days after the start of the intervention.”

“Non : nous ne sommes pas cobelligérants en Ukraine. Il n’y a que M. Lavrov, la propagande du Kremlin et vous qui le dites,” Alice Rufo, the French delegate minister for the Armed Forces, wrote in a message on X, accusing Mélenchon of relaying “la propagande du Kremlin.”

The political stakes in May

Jean-Luc Mélenchon, currently the best-placed with Marine Le Pen to reach the second round of the presidential election in May, is criticized like the candidate RN for positions judged too favorable to Russia by several of his adversaries, according to Lefigaro.

Le Monde’s vote tally remains the party’s problem to explain: of the 22 Ukraine-related texts since 2024, five rejected and seven abstained stand against the 10 its lawmakers approved. LFI maintains the exceptions were principled. Its critics, and the voting record itself, keep the question open.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Pitchfork Selects: Armand Hammer, Matthew Dear, and More (November 17)

Kuwait, Bahrain Intercept Iranian Attacks After US Strike on Qeshm Island