Nicalis Removes Undisclosed AI Music From Repentance+

Nicalis stripped AI-generated music from The Binding: Repentance+ on November 21 after players uncovered undisclosed Suno metadata in a GTA 6-themed daily run, triggering a review-bombing campaign that drove recent Steam ratings to “Overwhelmingly Negative.”

Developer Edmund McMillen said he “woke up to a s**t show” and had “obviously I had no idea it featured generated music in the daily run, looking into how that happened and getting it removed, stay tuned.” Hours later, Nicalis released a PC patch confirming the “removal of generated music files” and said it had submitted the fix to Microsoft, Nintendo, and Sony, though no console release date has been given.

The update also coincided with Repentance+ launching on Nintendo Switch 2, PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X/S. The game drew over 150,000 current daily players on PC in 2026, signaling sustained interest in the title. The Repentance+ package adds more than 700 collectible items, 34 playable characters, and 120+ bosses and mini-bosses. Cross-saves and crossplay are not active at launch and will arrive in a later update.

Nicalis is a video game publisher and developer founded in 2007 that has released The Binding series. Repentance+ supports online co-op for up to four players in every mode and includes four-player local support. The Nintendo Switch 2 physical release comes on a Game Card with a reversible cover sheet insert, an instruction manual, and a PVC Isaac and Guppy strap.

The binding of isaac repentance ai
Photo: IGN

Valve requires developers to disclose pre-generated AI assets that ship with a game and are consumed by players. The Repentance+ Steam page had not been updated to reflect the music’s origin.

Within hours, recent reviews plummeted to 8 percent positive; players wrote “Thanks, Nicalis, for breaking everything and adding AI slop to an already-existing game!” and “I’m starting to think that adding AI to a game should be valid grounds to refunds to people who have already paid for and played a game. Shameful they would do this to an Indie gem. Shameful.”

Players complain about performance issues and a “high risk” of losing saves. Prior to this, multiplayer had been available as part of a beta, and after the release it completely stopped working for some users. Nicalis had 2 years to release this in proper shape.

Instead of the fixed online play that everyone wanted, we got a seemingly “funny” cameo with GTA 6. They failed to resurrect the game. With the DLC leaving beta, multiplayer stopped working, nothing helps, great developers this game has.

Repentance+ arrived on consoles November 19 as a $9.99 DLC upgrade for existing Repentance owners, while a standalone Switch 2 version sells for $59.99 digital and $69.99 physical. The PC update was free. Cross-save and cross-play are slated for a later patch.

Edmund McMillen, who designed The Binding of Isaac and its Rebirth remake, first drew attention with Adobe Flash games such as Gish and Aether before co-founding Team Meat to release Super Meat Boy in 2010. His 2011 roguelike was built during a week-long game jam with Florian Himsl and grew into a series that now includes the 2026 turn-based roguelite Mewgenics.

The AI-music removal patch is live on Steam. Nicalis says it is “working on the game and will continue to address new and old bugs” but has not explained how the undisclosed tracks entered the build. Console players await the submitted update with no estimated arrival date.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

México Captures Sinaloa Cartel Leader El Chapo Isidro in Guasave; 4 Soldiers, 7 Gunmen Dead Friday