OC DA Spitzer Seeks to Block Newsom Commutations for 18 OC Inmates

“There is nothing more sacred than democracy and the rule of law,” Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer said.

On Friday, Spitzer filed a request with the state Supreme Court to block Governor Gavin Newsom’s commutation of death row sentences for 18 prisoners from Orange County, ABC7 Los Angeles reported.

The latest legal action targets inmates who lack prior felony convictions. Because these 18 cases carry no prior felonies, they would bypass the mandatory review of the state’s high court.

Newsom announced on November 5, 2026, that he was commuting the death sentences for all 548 condemned inmates in California to life in prison without the possibility of parole, according to the open letter posted on his office’s website.

The Bottom Line

  • Spitzer’s office filed a writ to stop the commutation of 18 Orange County prisoners who have no prior felony records.
  • Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman released a complete list of all 548 inmates impacted by the governor’s plan.
  • Legal experts and defense attorneys note that the defendants face no risk of release and will remain imprisoned.

Legal Arguments Over Supreme Court Review

Spitzer’s office argued that the governor’s action bypasses statutory requirements. The county’s top prosecutor said that California voters have twice rejected initiatives to abolish the death penalty.

The Orange County filing states that Newsom lacks the authority to set aside established sentencing laws simply due to personal disagreement. The brief maintains that the governor failed to conduct individualized reviews for each inmate.

Attorney Scott Sanders, who represents condemned inmate Daniel Wozniak, questioned the utility of the new filing. “I’m not exactly sure what the goal is in filing the brief,” Sanders told ABC7 Los Angeles.

Sanders added that the legal framework governing a governor’s commutation power appears settled. “Again, I understand the frustration that some victims feel about this decision, but it’s important to point out there is no risk of any of these defendants being released. They are all going to die in prison,” Sanders said.

Why this OC crime victim supports Newsom's death row commutations

District Attorney Opposition Across Southern California

Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman joined Spitzer in opposing the mass clemency initiative. Hochman argued that life sentences do not permanently secure incarceration, citing legislative changes applied to past cases.

“When Erik and Lyle Menendez were sentenced in 1996, a jury gave them life without the possibility of parole, and for 30 years that sentence was in place, until the State Legislature changed the rules, giving them the possibility of parole,” Hochman said in a statement reported by NBC Los Angeles.

The remaining prisoners, including the 18 from Orange County without prior felonies, fall outside that mandatory judicial review threshold. Spitzer’s office is seeking writ relief specifically for those unreviewed cases.

Inmate Category Prisoner Count Supreme Court Review Required
Prior Felony Convictions 382 Yes
Single Felony / No Prior Record 202 No
Total Condemned Inmates 548 Combined

Victims Families Respond to Clemency Push

Family members of murder victims spoke out alongside prosecutors during public briefings in Southern California. Relatives detailed the underlying crimes committed by prisoners now facing commuted sentences.

“They tortured my daughter and made my son watch while they sexually assaulted her. They stomped him and beat him so bad he even had shoe prints on his back,” said Faye Jenkins, whose daughter and Marine son-in-law were murdered by fellow Marines in 2013.

Steve Herr described the impact of the decision regarding his son, Sam Herr, who was murdered and dismembered in 2010. Daniel Wozniak was subsequently convicted of killing Herr and Julie Kibuishi in 2015.

Governor Newsom defended his actions in his November public statement. “I take this action because I firmly believe that state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California’s values,” Newsom said.

Spitzer was born in Whittier in 1960 and earned a master’s in public policy from Berkeley and a law degree from UC Hastings in 1989. He began his career as a deputy district attorney from 1990 to 1996, then won a seat on the Board of Supervisors in the aftermath of the 1994 county bankruptcy.

As an assemblyman from 2002 to 2006, he co-wrote California’s Megan’s Law and later managed the 2008 campaign that passed Marsy’s Law. Elected district attorney in 2018, he negotiated a $125 million civil settlement with GKN Aerospace in 2026, the largest in county history.

Legal challenges from district attorneys across the region remain pending before the state Supreme Court.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Royal Media Services Launches Ksh350 Monthly YouTube Subscription for Citizen, Inooro, Ramogi TV

Liberia Water Crisis: 25% Have Clean Water, 2014 Budget Just 0.4%