Peer-Supported Online CBT Outperforms Primary Care Referral for Anxiety After Low-Risk Chest Pain in PACER Trial

Adults who came to Indiana emergency departments with chest pain but no heart attack improved more over 12 months with a self-paced, peer-supported online cognitive behavioral therapy program than with a referral back to primary care, according to the PACER randomized clinical trial published in JAMA Internal Medicine on November 1, 2026.

Among patients with severe anxiety at the start, the online program outperformed standard referral by 2.8 points on a standard anxiety scale.

The trial, led by emergency physician and Regenstrief Institute research scientist Paul I. Musey Jr., M.D., M.S., of Indiana University School of Medicine, addressed a familiar pattern: patients discharged after a cardiac workup who return with the same chest pain. Musey’s team asked what an emergency department can offer when the medical emergency is ruled out but clinically significant anxiety is not.

The answer matters beyond Indianapolis. Chest pain is one of the leading reasons for emergency department visits, and most cases are classified as low-risk chest pain once acute coronary syndrome is excluded, according to the study’s abstract. Many of those patients have undiagnosed or undertreated anxiety, and connecting them with a therapist after discharge is difficult where access is limited.

Telehealth Treatment of Anxiety in Patients With Low-Risk Chest Pain in the Emergency Department — JAMA Network

“The emergency department was developed as a place to rule out life threats. But as you continue to experience symptoms, we can also be a place that can help you navigate to where you need to go and the next steps in treatment,” Musey said.

Online therapy with peer support reduces anxiety

  • If you went to an emergency department for chest pain and were told it was not a heart attack, ongoing anxiety may still be driving your symptoms — and it is treatable.
  • A structured online therapy program with peer support reduced anxiety over a year, without requiring a therapist in every session.
  • All three follow-up approaches in the trial helped; the online program simply helped more, especially for people whose anxiety was severe at the start.

Three follow-up paths, tested head to head

The PACER — Patient-Centered Treatment of Anxiety After Low-Risk Chest Pain in the Emergency Room — trial enrolled 375 adults at six Indiana University Health emergency departments between April 2021 and July 2024. To enter, patients had to have low-risk chest pain and at least moderate anxiety, defined on the seven-item Generalized Anxiety Disorder scale (GAD-7) as a score of 8 or higher, or a positive score on a panic screening question.

All participants received brief education about anxiety and chest pain — what researchers call psychoeducation. They were then randomly assigned to one of three groups: a recommended primary care referral, self-paced internet-based CBT with guided peer support, or therapist-delivered CBT by telehealth.

Cognitive behavioral therapy works by helping patients identify and reframe the thought patterns that fuel anxiety — for instance, the catastrophic interpretation of a normal chest sensation. In the online arm, participants progressed through the course modules and had the option to talk with a certified peer support specialist — someone with lived experience of anxiety — about how the lessons applied to their own circumstances.

“We wanted to figure out a different way to provide somebody with that human touch,” Musey said.

Where the numbers moved — and where they did not

Anxiety symptoms improved in all three groups over 12 months, measured at 3, 6, 9, and 12 months.

The trial’s primary endpoint, the GAD-7, showed a mean gain of 1.22 additional points for the peer-supported online CBT group compared with those referred back to primary care, with a 95 percent confidence interval of 0.01 to 2.43 — a statistical way of saying the true difference very likely favored the online program, though possibly by only a sliver. Among patients who began with severe anxiety, the gap widened to 2.8 points (95% CI, 1.0–4.6).

On a separate item that asked participants to rate how much their anxiety had changed overall, members of both CBT groups were likelier to report getting better than those who had been referred to primary care. The study also tracked depression (PHQ-8), somatization — physical symptoms rooted in psychological distress (PHQ-14) — and daily-function impairment (Sheehan Disability Scale) as secondary outcomes.

What the trial leaves open

The authors themselves flag the limits. Participation in treatment varied, and all six trial sites sat within a single health system — Indiana University Health — so it remains unknown how well the approach transfers to other settings, or how much of the benefit comes from the peer support specifically.

Musey hopes to test the digital program against a version delivered without peer support, and to examine how emergency departments might draw on the electronic health record to weave anxiety screening, referral, and follow-up into everyday practice.

For health systems, the practical appeal is structural: a self-paced program delivers structured CBT without a therapist leading every session, easing the workforce bottleneck that keeps many screened-positive patients from ever reaching care. That consideration applies in any system where therapist availability constrains follow-up, whether care is organized through private insurers in the United States or through national services such as the UK’s NHS talking-therapies programs.

When to seek emergency care instead

Online CBT is not a substitute for cardiac evaluation. Any new or worsening chest pain — especially pain with exertion, shortness of breath, sweating, or radiating to the arm or jaw — warrants immediate emergency assessment to rule out acute coronary syndrome. A previous clean workup does not exclude a new cardiac event.

Self-guided digital therapy may not suit patients with severe depression, active suicidal thoughts, psychosis, or substance use disorders, who generally need clinician-led care; the PACER trial enrolled adults with at least moderate anxiety, and its results should not be extended beyond that population. If anxiety symptoms intensify, interfere with daily function, or recur with physical symptoms, consult a physician or licensed mental health professional before relying on any self-paced program.

The trial’s home institution brings considerable scale to the effort. Indiana University School of Medicine, founded in 1908 after the consolidation of IU- and Purdue-affiliated medical schools in Indianapolis, is the largest medical school in the United States, with 1,448 MD students and 1,438 residents and fellows in the 2024–25 academic year across nine campuses statewide.

Its research record includes the development of echocardiography and a curative therapy for testicular cancer, and a 2018 Federation of State Medical Boards survey found it had produced more licensed physicians than any other American medical school — 11,828.

A modest but consequential shift

The effect sizes here are measured in single-digit points on a 21-point scale, not dramatic reversals — and the trial’s own authors frame further research, not immediate practice change, as the next step. But the direction is clear: a randomized trial completed its 12-month follow-up by July 2025, was analyzed between July 2025 and January 2026, and now offers emergency departments a tested option for the patients they too often discharge with reassurance alone.

References

  • Paul I. Musey, Kurt Kroenke, Jill Nault Connors, et al., “Telehealth Treatment of Anxiety in Patients With Low-Risk Chest Pain in the Emergency Department,” JAMA Internal Medicine (2026). DOI: 10.1001/jamainternmed.2026.4225 — https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2026.4225
  • Medical Xpress, “PACER trial evaluates online cognitive behavioral therapy for anxiety after chest pain” (2026).
Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

Brazilian Real Devaluation Sparks 200% Surge in Argentine Tourism Demand for Summer 2027

Gisella Anastasia Closes Detikcom Awards 2026 Evening Session With ‘Rungkad’ Performance