Physician noncompete agreements face mounting challenges across state courts and attorney general offices as federal protections recede, with 18 states currently banning or voiding restrictive covenants for medical professionals.
Federal Oversight Shifts to Case-By-Case Enforcement
- Federal oversight on restrictive medical covenants has shifted primarily to case-by-case enforcement by the Federal Trade Commission, leaving state courts and regulators to drive the legal battles.
Federal Retreat Shifts Noncompete Disputes to State Courts
Health systems are losing much of the federal backstop they once expected on noncompete agreements, and the fight has shifted to state courts and attorneys general, according to Becker’s ASC Review. Eighteen states now generally ban or void noncompete agreements for physicians, based on a September 2026 state-by-state guide from law firm Tucker Arensberg. The Federal Trade Commission, meanwhile, has stated it will address noncompetes only on a case-by-case enforcement basis.
This decentralized regulatory landscape has triggered high-stakes corporate disputes over physician mobility. In Texas, a federal judge threw out Dallas-based Tenet Healthcare’s lawsuit accusing St. Louis-based Ascension of poaching its employees. On Oct. 29, Judge Brantley Starr of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas threw out all of Tenet’s claims and granted Ascension’s summary judgment request, meaning the litigation cannot be filed again.
Tenet brought legal action in March 2024, claiming that Ascension unlawfully hired four of its personnel, beginning with former Tenet executive Sally Hurt-Deitch, MSN, RN, who came to Ascension in 2021.
The remaining claims centered on Paula Phillips, a former Tenet vice president whose agreement barred her from doing similar work for 12 months and from soliciting Tenet employees. The court found both the noncompete and nonsolicitation agreements overbroad under Texas law because the noncompete lacked any geographic limit.
| Legal Dispute | Jurisdiction | Core Issue |
|---|---|---|
| Tenet Healthcare v. Ascension | Texas Federal Court | Overbroad executive noncompete and poaching claims dismissed with prejudice. |
| Washington v. DaVita and Fresenius | Washington State Court | State lawsuit targeting mandatory medical director noncompetes. |
| Ellis Medicine v. St. Peter’s | New York State Court | Dispute over 27 cardiologists and $75 million in annual procedure revenue. |
State Regulators and Health Systems Clash Over Medical Talent
State enforcement actions are intensifying alongside private institutional lawsuits. Washington Attorney General Nick Brown filed a lawsuit Nov. 10 against Denver-based DaVita and Bad Homburg, Germany-based Fresenius Medical Care, alleging the state’s two largest dialysis providers make their medical directors sign illegal noncompete agreements.
DaVita operates 51 dialysis centers in Washington, and Fresenius operates 29. Submitted to the Thurston County Superior Court, the complaint requests that the court invalidate the agreements pursuant to the 2019 Noncompetition Covenants Act of Washington and levy fines for every infraction.
“These giant, for-profit companies require doctors to sign noncompete agreements that violate Washington state law,” Mr. Brown said in a news release covered by Becker’s ASC Review. DaVita stated it is in active discussions with the FTC and will vigorously defend the arrangements’ lawfulness, while Fresenius maintained that its contracts with medical directors comply with the law ahead of Washington’s statewide ban taking effect June 30, 2027.
In New York, Schenectady-based Ellis Medicine signed employment agreements with 22 cardiologists currently affiliated with Albany-based St. Peter’s Health Partners, with the physicians slated to start as Ellis employees Jan. 1, 2027.
Ellis sued St. Peter’s Health Partners Medical Associates Aug. 12, alleging the physician group was using one-year noncompetes to keep 27 cardiologists from joining Ellis once a professional services agreement ended, warning that about $75 million in annual procedure revenue was at risk.
Following a ruling by a Schenectady County judge, a temporary restraining order that previously blocked Ellis from extending contracts was lifted, and St. Peter’s submitted an appeal notice on October 1.
Two cardiologists sued by St. Peter’s, Christopher Dibble, MD, and Stephen Piacentine, MD, filed a counterclaim Oct. 16 seeking to void their noncompete and nonsolicitation provisions. St. Peter’s stated it “denies these allegations and will vigorously defend itself in court,” according to Becker’s ASC Review.
“Twenty-two cardiologists choosing to continue their careers with Ellis sends a powerful message,” Ellis President and CEO Paul Milton told Becker’s ASC Review.
Financial Penalties and Practice Acquisitions Face Restrictive Covenants
Financial clawbacks and ownership stakes continue to fuel separate legal friction. James Joslyn, MD, formerly a physician with State of Franklin Healthcare Associates, is required to pay back $145,110.10 to the Johnson City, Tenn.-headquartered practice following an arbitration ruling that reverses the financial distribution he and other SOFHA doctors obtained when the organization transitioned into an employee stock ownership plan.
A Washington County Chancery Court judge confirmed the award Sept. 28, and SOFHA filed a notice of appeal Oct. 5, while a separate suit filed in February to enforce Dr. Joslyn’s employment noncompete remains pending.
Youngstown-headquartered Southwoods Health initiated legal action in Ohio against orthopedic surgeons David Weimer, MD, and James Jamison, MD—both physician shareholders—claiming their medical practice’s proposed acquisition by Cleveland Clinic violates their ownership contracts.
Initiated on Nov. 1 in the Mahoning County Common Pleas Court, the lawsuit centers upon a restrictive covenant accepted by the physicians during their acquisition of shares in the Surgical Hospital at Southwoods, which prohibits employment with rival entities inside a 30-mile radius for a two-year duration post-departure, a geographic span representing between 90% and 92% of Southwoods’ patient volume.
Dr. Weimer has received $1,291,792 in distributions since 2012, and Dr. Jamison has received $1,685,474. A magistrate issued a temporary injunction that prevents the two doctors from participating in the practice’s letter of intent for as long as they retain their ownership stake in Southwoods. Youngstown Orthopaedic Associates still planned to join Cleveland Clinic Nov. 1 and stated it does not anticipate any interruption in patient care, while Cleveland Clinic declined to comment.
Ascension, the St. Louis-based Catholic health system that won the Tenet case, was formed in 1999 from the merger of the Daughters of Charity National Health System and Sisters of St. Joseph Health System. As of July 1, 2025, it employed 142,000 people and operated 90 hospitals and 40 senior living facilities across 17 states and the District of Columbia, with operating revenue of $27.2 billion at the end of fiscal year 2021.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.
Worth a look
- JMPD Chief Superintendent Reveals Extortion Syndicate Operation, Cites Fear for Past Silence
- Vierendeel Model Shows €62,358 Cost Gap Between PEB D and E Under Wallonia Reform
- Jamestown’s Hannah Attleson Plays Through Illness, Leads Blue Jays Past Fargo Shanley Into State Semis (news-usa.today)
- No. 16 Penn State Women’s Volleyball Defeats No. 18 Indiana 3-1 (newsdirectory3.com)