A growing number of physicists now suspect that space and time are not the bedrock of the universe but emerge from something deeper — and the question has moved from philosophy into the laboratory. Clues from black hole entropy, holographic theory and quantum computers have spawned laser, atom and diamond experiments designed to test whether space-time has hidden microscopic building blocks.
The idea strikes at a century-old assumption. Both of physics’ most successful theories — Einstein’s general relativity and quantum mechanics — take space-time, the four-dimensional fabric of the universe, as a given, yet neither explains why it has three dimensions of space and one of time, or where it comes from in the first place.
Why does this matter? The theory governing the very large refuses to mesh with the theory governing the very small, and in extreme settings — the interiors of black holes, or the tiniest slivers of time right after the Big Bang — the contradiction cannot be avoided, since gravity turns ferocious at the tiny distances where quantum mechanics holds sway.
“You can build space from a theory without space,” Jeff Forshaw, a professor of particle physics at the University of Manchester, told Live Science.
Space-time in plain English
- Space-time may be like water: it looks smooth and continuous only because we cannot see its individual "bits," just as water seems smooth until you zoom in on its molecules.
- The strongest clue comes from black holes, which behave as if they have temperature and entropy — the hallmarks of a system built from hidden microscopic parts.
- Settling the question may not need a bigger collider. Tabletop lasers, cold atoms, levitated diamonds and quantum computers are the tools now in play.
Why gravity and quantum theory clash
Under Einstein’s general theory of relativity, matter and energy give space-time its shape through curvature, and that curvature is what we sense as gravity. Quantum mechanics, by contrast, describes nature at the scale of atoms and subatomic particles — and still has no adequate description of gravity.
Efforts to merge the two mathematically have so far produced nonsensical results. “They seem not to fit together into a single, consistent framework that we know to be correct,” said Latham Boyle, a theoretical physicist at the University of Edinburgh whose research explores quantum gravity and whether space-time is fundamental or emergent.
An increasingly popular reading is that both theories are perched on the same untested assumption: space-time itself.
If that assumption is wrong, the apparent foundation of reality could be a large-scale approximation of something stranger underneath.

Is space-time like water?
Boyle’s analogy runs like this. Water only appears continuous on large scales because we cannot see its composite bits — the individual molecules. “It seems smooth but only because we can’t view it under a fine enough microscope,” he told Live Science. No one has yet found direct evidence for space-time’s microscopic equivalents.
The clue comes from thermodynamics — the laws governing heat, temperature and entropy. Physicists use entropy to count how many hidden microscopic arrangements can produce the same large-scale behavior, and thermodynamics normally describes the collective behavior of microscopic ingredients. If Einstein’s equations are thermodynamic in nature, their entropy may point to hidden microscopic states of space-time itself.
“General relativity is thermodynamics,” Forshaw told Live Science. “Einstein’s equations are a statement of thermodynamics. They’re a statistically emergent feature of an underlying theory.”
The hint sharpened in the 1970s, when Jacob Bekenstein and Stephen Hawking showed that black holes have entropy and a physical temperature. “Einstein’s equation, which we thought was just a classical equation, nothing to do with quantum mechanics, seems to secretly know — or at some level to have known — about this finite entropy associated with the black hole,” Boyle told Live Science.
A universe stored on its boundary
A second clue comes from a contradiction known as the black hole information paradox. Quantum mechanics says physical information can never be destroyed. But in 1974 Hawking proposed that black holes emit radiation and slowly evaporate — and that radiation is thermal, carrying no obvious record of what fell inside.
The escape route is geometric. A black hole’s entropy scales not with the three-dimensional volume it encloses but with the two-dimensional area of its event horizon, the boundary beyond which nothing, not even light, escapes. That suggests all the information in a region might be stored on its boundary — the holographic principle, named after a hologram, where a 3D image is encoded on a 2D surface.
In 1997, theoretical physicist Juan Maldacena gave the notion a rigorous mathematical footing, proving that a gravitational theory posed in a higher-dimensional space could be recast as a lower-dimensional quantum theory with no gravity at all. Some researchers now go further: the lower-dimensional quantum theory may be the fundamental description, with the space-time we experience emerging when its information is decoded.
“You should think of the lower-dimensional thing as being what’s most real,” Mark Van Raamsdonk, a professor of physics at the University of British Columbia, told Live Science. He compares it to a video game: the 3D world on screen seems spatially real, but the underlying information is stored very differently — as bits in a memory chip.
Entanglement — the quantum link that lets particles share properties across vast distances — may be the decoding key. “If I want to decode what space-time geometry is being stored by the quantum state of this lower-dimensional system, all I need to do is probe this entanglement structure,” Van Raamsdonk told Live Science.
Three dates that shaped the search
- 1974 — Stephen Hawking proposes that black holes emit radiation and slowly evaporate, creating the information paradox.
- 1997 — Juan Maldacena makes the holographic idea mathematically precise.
Laser tables hunting a quantum hum
For decades, testing these ideas directly looked hopeless. Reaching the Planck scale — the energy at which quantum effects become as strong as gravity — would require roughly 900 trillion times more energy than the Large Hadron Collider can produce. Physicists have since found ways around brute force.
One approach searches for a subtle jitter, or static hum, in space-time itself. Experiments such as GQuEST, a collaboration involving Fermilab and Caltech, and QUEST at Cardiff University split laser light along different paths and recombine it. Extraordinarily small changes in the distance light travels could reveal fluctuations from discrete building blocks of space-time, consistent with some holographic models.
QUEST compares measurements from two neighboring interferometers. Some models predict quantum fluctuations that would affect both instruments in a related way, so researchers hunt for matching signals while ruling out shared laboratory noise. Finding nothing would not end the search — it would constrain how strong such fluctuations can be, killing off flawed models.
Atom interferometers extend the hunt by using atoms as probes. When a laser pulse hits an atom, the atom enters superposition — simultaneously in two locations — travels two separate paths, and is recombined by a final pulse. If space-time fluctuates differently along one path than the other, the atom’s interference pattern shifts. MAGIS-100 at Fermilab and the AION project are built on this principle.
Diamond nanocrystals test gravity's quantum nature
A bolder tabletop test goes by the name BMV experiments, after Sougato Bose and his collaborators and Chiara Marletto and Vlatko Vedral, who developed them independently. Diamond nanocrystals weighing around a hundred-billionth of a kilogram are placed into quantum superposition, painstakingly shielded from every electromagnetic and nuclear interaction, and set at different distances from one another.
If the diamonds emerge with their electron states entangled, only gravity could have produced the entanglement — something a classical gravitational field cannot do. And if gravity can exist in superposition, that would be a strong clue that space-time’s geometry is woven out of quantum information. The challenge, so far, is excluding every other effect that might obscure the signal.
On cosmic scales, future observatories — the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna, the Einstein Telescope and the Cosmic Explorer — will scrutinize gravity around black holes. After two black holes merge, the remnant settles down by emitting gravitational waves in a characteristic “ringdown.” Einstein’s theory makes precise predictions for it; discrepancies could hint at the quantum nature of space-time, though they would not reveal a direct picture of its microscopic ingredients.
Quantum computers building toy universes
In holographic models, the underlying units of information are represented as qubits — mathematically identical to those in quantum computers, even if physically different. That equivalence lets quantum processors simulate space-time models, where stronger entanglement between qubits means closer corresponding regions of space, and severed entanglement tears space-time apart.
“The study of many-body, highly entangled systems is where the future of this whole enterprise is,” Forshaw told Live Science.
Precursor tests are underway. In 2022, Google’s Sycamore processor reproduced the behavior of a simple theoretical wormhole — not a real hole in space-time, but nine qubits arranged so their behavior could also be described using gravity.
Earlier this year, researchers used the trapped-ion machine IonQ Forte to test how something resembling gravitational geometry could emerge from patterns of quantum information. When they altered the entanglement — akin to adding mass in the model’s gravitational interpretation — the corresponding geometry changed, as Einstein’s theory would predict.
The result reproduces features of a simplified, static theoretical universe, not the expanding one we live in; a more realistic model might require entangling 100 or 200 qubits, which may be possible in the near future.
| Approach | What it tests | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Laser interferometers (GQuEST, QUEST) | Correlated quantum fluctuations of space-time | Fermilab/Caltech; Cardiff University |
| Atom interferometers (AION, MAGIS-100) | Differential space-time jitter along two atomic paths | Fermilab and partner sites |
| BMV diamond experiments | Whether gravity alone can entangle two masses | Tabletop laboratory setups |
| Gravitational-wave observatories (LISA, Einstein Telescope, Cosmic Explorer) | Discrepancies in black hole “ringdown” signals | Space- and ground-based, future |
| Quantum processors (Sycamore, IonQ Forte) | Whether entanglement patterns mimic emergent geometry | Google; IonQ with a Duke-led team |
What these results cannot prove
None of these experiments, on its own, would establish that space-time emerges from information. Interpreting an unexpected signal would mean distinguishing between competing explanations, and a null result constrains models rather than confirming one. Taken together, though, the results could begin to show which theories of quantum gravity match the real world — and whether emergent space-time is among them.
Forshaw, born in 1968, has spent much of his career studying the behavior of subatomic particles using data from accelerators including the Large Hadron Collider at CERN, and became a professor at the University of Manchester in 2004.
He is also a recipient of the Maxwell Medal and Prize for his contribution to particle physics and the Kelvin Prize from the Institute of Physics for his work on the public understanding of physics. A longtime collaborator of physicist Brian Cox, he co-authored popular science books including “Why Does E=mc²?” and “The Quantum Universe,” and writes as a columnist for The Observer.
A discovery of that kind would raise questions well beyond physics, reaching into what it means for anything, including ourselves, to exist within the universe. “If I tell you that space doesn’t exist, it really questions what it means to be,” Forshaw told Live Science. “How can you actually talk about things when there’s no space to put things in?”
References
- Fermilab, GQuEST collaboration publication (2024): https://lss.fnal.gov/archive/2024/pub/fermilab-pub-24-0412-student.pdf
- MAGIS-100 proposal, arXiv: https://arxiv.org/abs/2104.02835
- Study on emergent geometry from quantum information, arXiv: https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.12047
- Original reporting and interviews: Live Science, “What if space and time don’t exist? Physicists are chasing hints that our reality emerges from something deeper.”