Polish Constitutional Tribunal Lifts President’s Immunity, Rejects Arrest Request

Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal stripped its own president of immunity on Tuesday — but refused to let prosecutors arrest him.

The General Assembly of Judges of the Tribunal voted on November 17 to allow criminal proceedings against chief justice Bogdan Święczkowski in four separate matters and against deputy chief justice Bartłomiej Sochański in one, publishing the decisions in a communiqué on Wednesday, November 18, according to Wyborcza.

Prosecutor General’s requests drove the votes. For Święczkowski, the suspended Tribunal president, the Assembly approved prosecution over four sets of alleged acts — and then declined the request to detain and remand him. Wyborcza.pl reported that in each of the four matters the judges also suspended him from duties and cut his salary by 50 percent. Sochański was suspended too, with a 25 percent pay cut.

Święczkowski rejects all of it. “There was no General Assembly at all and no resolutions were passed, so I am in no way suspended,” he said on Polsat News, according to Wyborcza.pl. He called the judges who voted “people who usurp the role of judges of the Constitutional Tribunal” and said he was relieved they did not cross “the border of classic criminal offences.”

The stakes reach well past one judge. The Assembly acted on requests from the Prosecutor General’s office, and the votes mark the first time the Tribunal’s own judges have lifted immunity from its president — a figure installed during the previous PiS-led government’s restructuring of the court.

Onet said that with six counts facing him and Polish criminal cases moving slowly, proceedings could stretch to 2031, when Święczkowski’s term ends. His suspension, the outlet observed, is now effectively indefinite.

Four charges, one Pegasus thread

Two of the counts concern Święczkowski’s conduct as Tribunal president: prosecutors allege he persistently violated employment law by blocking judges elected by the current Sejm from hearing cases — the same judges to whom President Karol Nawrocki has refused to administer the oath — and that he did so for personal gain, to keep his post, salary and control of the court.

When the new judges tried to enter the building in mid-October, scuffles broke out. A separate count alleges he violated the bodily integrity of judge Maciej Berka during that episode, Wyborcza.pl reported.

The other counts reach back to 2016–2022, when Święczkowski served as national prosecutor, Zbigniew Ziobro’s deputy at the justice ministry. He is to answer for alleged abuses connected to the Pegasus spyware surveillance of opposition figures — specifically the wiretapping of lawyer Roman Giertych, whose clients included leading Civic Platform politicians.

Prosecutors say Święczkowski, ignoring procedure, ordered a prosecutor to compile the intercepts although they contained no evidence of a crime; recordings then leaked to friendly right-wing media in breach of attorney-client privilege. A further count concerns his personnel policy as head of the prosecution service: unlawfully dispatching inconvenient investigators on secondments to distant prosecutor’s offices, without their consent, as harassment.

Korwin-Piotrowska, the judge standing in for the Tribunal president, also issued two orders refusing to accept two further requests against Święczkowski, citing formal deficiencies in the applications, according to WNP.PL.

The arrest request that failed

The Assembly’s refusal to allow Święczkowski’s detention and pre-trial arrest drew instant political reading. Business Insider Polska said that some saw the refusal as evidence the judges act independently — potentially opening a path to defusing the standoff between the Tribunal’s new and old judges, and between the governing coalition and the opposition.

The outlet also reported that had the Assembly consented, an arrest battle in both court instances could have run into December, hinging on whether a court accepts the Assembly as a competent body.

Polish Tribunal Rejects Arrest Requests Against Święczkowski and Sochański — Pulse TV

Święczkowski’s lawyer, Bartosz Lewandowski, argued the whole session was void. “No ‘General Assembly’ of the Tribunal expressed consent to bring President Bogdan Święczkowski and deputy president Bartłomiej Sochański to criminal responsibility,” he said, per Interia Wydarzenia, adding there was “neither a quorum” nor a proper convocation. He warned that detaining his client would amount to “a grave criminal offence.”

Six so-called old judges of the Tribunal signed a statement opposing the immunity vote, saying the assembly was convened by a person without authority, included people who are not sitting Tribunal judges, and lacked the statutory quorum — eight judges instead of ten, Business Insider Polska reported.

Minister sprawiedliwości Waldemar Żurek oraz poseł Przemysław Czarnek przed budynkiem z polską flagą
Photo: Interia Wydarzenia

Sochański: “I’ll manage without immunity”

Sochański faces a single count: failure to perform his duties as vice-president by barring lawfully elected judges from adjudicating and persistently violating employment law. He told Onet he does not accept the decision, legally or factually, calling the assembly “improperly convened,” wrongly composed and short of quorum, with decision-makers who “are not impartial.”

“I have managed all my life without immunity, and I will manage now too,” Sochański told Onet, drawing a comparison to martial law, which he also refused to recognize — yet still collected ration cards for. Of the resolution itself, he said what he saw “on paper” was so absurd he hoped prosecutors would not press the charges.

Politicians pick sides

The governing coalition welcomed the votes. Justice Minister Waldemar Żurek and ruling-party politicians said no one stands above the law. MEP Tomasz Trela of the Left wrote: “The judge ‘on Kaczyński’s phone call’ Święczkowski without immunity. Now charges, a swift indictment and a decision by an independent court.”

The opposition pushed back hard. “Be afraid of responsibility for what you have done!” wrote Przemysław Czarnek of Law and Justice, while still applauding the refusal to detain Święczkowski: “The pressure worked. Praise and thanks to the defenders of the Constitutional Tribunal.” Fellow PiS MP Marcin Warchoł wrote on X: “Now I await Żurek and his somersaults, that the Supreme Court is not the Supreme Court.”

Święczkowski odmówia jawną na wezwania i ostrzega przed apelu

Święczkowski says he will not appear. “I will not show up for any summons,” he told Polsat News, adding that if his immunity stands he cannot go to prosecutors “without contradicting myself,” and that any response would depend on his lawyers. He also flagged a possible appeal, noting the communiqué cited the act on the structure of common courts.

Onet framed the stakes as purely political arithmetic: if the governing camp wins the 2027 elections, Święczkowski faces years of prosecution and possibly conviction; if the right — PiS with the Confederation factions of Mentzen/Bosak and Braun — wins next year, he could return to the Tribunal “in glory and splendour.” Neither Święczkowski nor Sochański recognizes the Assembly’s authority, and nobody yet knows whether a criminal court will.

Constitutional Tribunal reaches decision regarding Bogdan Święczkowski and Bartłomiej Sochański — tvn24

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Suzan & Freek: Freek’s Cancer Stable, Illness Doesn’t Hinder Daily Life

Israeli Lawmakers Elect Matan Kahana as Knesset Speaker 66-52, Stripping Netanyahu Bloc of Control