A proposed 10% credit-card rate cap would undercut SoFi Technologies’ core personal-loan product, which carried a 12.9% weighted-average coupon in the second quarter, TIKR reported.
President Donald Trump said Saturday he would work with the incoming Democratic-controlled Congress to cap credit-card interest rates. “I would do it. These credit-card companies have made a lot of money,” he told Fox News on “Saturday in America.” The standard proposal is a 10% ceiling, and attention has focused on card issuers such as JPMorgan Chase and Capital One, according to Tikr. But the cap could matter more for lenders whose loans are used to pay off card balances, including SoFi and Upstart.
SoFi Chief Executive Anthony Noto previously framed the cap as a bullish catalyst. When Trump first raised the idea in January, Noto wrote on X that card issuers “simply will not be able to maintain their profitability with a 10% rate cap,” creating “a massive void” that SoFi’s personal loans “are well-positioned to fill.”
TIKR’s analysis questions that logic. A 10% card would be roughly three percentage points cheaper than SoFi’s flagship loan, and matching that price would cut the company’s estimated 6.1% risk-adjusted loan margin roughly in half.
Prime borrowers stay with card issuers
Noto’s argument assumes issuers restrict credit once they cannot charge more than 10%. Banks say a cap would force them to cancel cards for less-creditworthy customers or cut rewards. But SoFi’s borrowers — average FICO 745, average income $154,000 in the first quarter — are exactly the customers a capped issuer would fight to retain.
JPMorgan held $250.1 billion in average card loans in the third quarter with a 2.91% net charge-off rate, a portfolio healthy enough to keep even at 10%. The borrowers who actually lose card access look more like Upstart’s clientele; Upstart’s unsecured business generated $212 million of contribution profit in the third quarter, up 35%.
Personal loans drive SoFi profit
Personal loans accounted for $10.7 billion of SoFi’s record $14.8 billion in originations in the second quarter and produced 64.0% of segment contribution profit, up from 52.5% a year earlier. In January, Noto wrote the loans “feature rates (10-12%) that are up to half of typical credit-card rates.”
A 10% cap reverses that comparison. Management estimated the risk-adjusted loan margin at roughly 6.1% after 3.1% funding costs and 3.7% losses; pricing at 10% would reduce it by about half. Analysts expect SoFi’s normalized earnings per share to roughly triple between 2025 and 2028.
Legislation still required
The cap is not law. Trump first proposed it in January and the Republican-controlled Congress took little action. That could change when Democrats assume control of both chambers in January.
Investors are not paying a premium for SoFi’s loan growth: the stock trades at 1.7 times tangible book value versus a five-year average of 2.7 times and a peak of 6.4 times in October 2025. “Noto’s ‘void’ is the weakest part of the SoFi bull case on this cap,” TIKR concluded, “because a 10% card beats SoFi’s loans for the prime borrowers it targets.”
SoFi’s fourth-quarter report, expected late January, should indicate how management plans to compete if cards end up cheaper than its loans.