Providence City Council Votes 10-4 to Ban Flock Cameras

PROVIDENCE, R.I. — The Providence City Council voted 10-4 on Thursday to ban the city’s use of automated license plate readers, ordering the immediate shutdown of the Flock camera network that has divided the city since a December mass shooting put the technology in the spotlight.

The ordinance requires the city to “immediately deactivate and discontinue its use” of all automated license plate readers, terminate every agreement with companies that provide the technology, and return the equipment. It also bars the city from acquiring or using license plate reader data from external owners, including data from other states, municipalities or agencies.

The vote lands at a charged moment. The city’s three-year contract with Flock, signed in 2023 and costing roughly $155,000 to $170,000 a year, was not set to expire until May 2027. And the incoming mayor, David Morales, had pledged during his campaign to end the contract — meaning the council moved before a new administration could decide the program’s fate.

“I think we’re being given a false choice between safety and civil liberties,” said Councilor Sue AnderBois, who represents Ward 3 and sponsored the measure along with Council President Rachel Miller and Councilman Miguel Sanchez.

Providence City Council Votes 10-4 to Ban Flock Cameras
Photo: turnto10.com

A data leak report loomed over the vote

The ordinance cites specific concerns: Immigration and Customs Enforcement using Flock data “to kidnap immigrant neighbors,” authorized users stalking partners and ex-partners, and the system’s misidentification of individuals and vehicles. ICE did not respond to a request for comment.

A report presented to the council in May by Rhode Island College students gave those concerns hard numbers. It found that organizations not listed on Providence’s Flock transparency portal accessed data from the city’s cameras more than 3.2 million times between November 2024 and November 2025, across more than 1,400 jurisdictions.

By the time of Thursday’s vote, more than 100 cities nationwide and at least five Rhode Island towns had already terminated their Flock contracts. In October, Gov. Dan McKee placed an indefinite statewide pause on new license plate reader installations while legislators draft formal regulations.

Police chief: a tool that solves serious crimes

Providence Police Chief Oscar Perez, in a statement, acknowledged the council’s consideration while defending the technology his detectives rely on.

“At the same time, ALPR technology has become an important investigative tool for our detectives, helping identify vehicles, develop leads and solve serious crimes,” Perez said. He added that the department remains “committed to working with the City Council and community to address privacy concerns while preserving responsible access to this valuable technology.”

Earlier in the process, Perez had said he was not consulted before the ordinance was drafted. “There is a difference between writing legislation and understanding its operational consequences,” he said in a statement to local reporters. Sanchez disputed that characterization, saying there had been communications with the department.

Flock also pushed back. “Communities should not have to choose between protecting privacy and giving law enforcement the tools they need to solve serious crimes, find missing people and keep people safe,” a Flock spokesperson said in an email.

The cameras that helped catch a shooter

Defenders of the system, including Perez and outgoing Mayor Brett Smiley, point to its role in helping identify the perpetrator of the Dec. 13 mass shooting near Brown University. Smiley had urged councilors to add privacy guardrails rather than scrap the technology entirely, calling it a tool that has “measurably made the city of Providence safer.”

AnderBois pressed that record directly at Thursday’s meeting, asking whether Flock “made us safer” — noting the cameras did not prevent the shooter from carrying out the attack or crossing state lines during his escape. “I have also heard from many members of the Brown community who do not want our contract relationship with Flock to be made in their name,” she said.

Opposition to the cameras has crossed party lines. Sanchez, the Ward 6 councilor who is positioned to become the council’s next president, called it a bipartisan issue and told residents to stay engaged through public hearings. Randall Rose of Rhode Islanders for Personal Privacy, which has fought the cameras across the state, put it more bluntly: “Most of us do not want to be watched all the time.”

How many cameras are actually in Providence?

Even the size of the network is disputed. Flock’s own transparency portal lists 60 cameras in Providence. But the ordinance says more than 100 are reportedly in operation, counting cameras tied to a separate Rhode Island State Police contract. The city and the State Police did not respond to requests for comment on the discrepancy.

The ordinance cleared its path to the floor when the Special Committee on Health, Opportunity, Prosperity and Education recommended adoption. It was introduced at the council’s Oct. 15 meeting and referred to that committee before returning for Thursday’s final vote.

When the cameras could actually come down

The ordinance takes effect upon passage, but the practical timeline for deactivating the cameras, returning equipment and unwinding the contract remains unclear. The contract itself was scheduled to run through May 2027, and how incoming Mayor Morales’ administration handles the termination process will shape what happens on the ground.

Flock Group Inc., doing business as Flock Safety, was founded in 2017 by three Georgia Tech alumni — Garrett Langley, Paige Todd and Matt Feury — who built their first cameras by hand around Langley’s dining room table before joining Y Combinator’s Summer 2017 batch.

The company says it now operates in more than 6,000 communities across all 50 US states and performs over 20 billion vehicle scans every month, having raised $950 million in venture funding at a $7.5 billion valuation.

Its growth has drawn legal scrutiny: in June 2024, a judge in Norfolk, Virginia, ruled that data collected from the city’s 172 Flock cameras constituted a search under the Fourth Amendment and could not be used as evidence without a warrant.

This is a developing story. Details on implementation — including the exact decommissioning schedule and whether the State Police contract cameras are affected — have not yet been confirmed.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Metal Stocks Fall Up to 7% in 5 Days; Analysts Cite Fed, Dollar and AI Capex Fears