Psychologist Warns Sick Leave Caps Ignore Root Mental Health Crisis

Nguyen is co-founder of Empreinte Humaine, an independent consultancy created in 2012 with Jean-Pierre Brun, a management professor at Université Laval in Quebec, specializing in quality of life at work and the prevention of psychosocial risks, Sud Ouest reported.

The stakes are measurable. Nguyen traces the rise to psychological distress, not malingering.

“Half of employees in France now show a sign of psychological distress — a historic level,” he said, citing the 16th barometer his firm produced with Ipsos-BVA. That survey, he told Sud Ouest, shows the trend “has not stopped since the Covid crisis.”

Prevention Must Begin in Schools with Psychologists and Nurses

  • Prevention works earlier than the workplace: screening for family and personal crises should start at school, Nguyen argues, with psychologists and nurses present.

Why the Numbers Keep Climbing

The mechanism Nguyen describes is straightforward clinical logic. Loss of meaning at work, lack of recognition, and work overload are “motifs of malaise at work that lead to a degradation of mental health,” he told Sud Ouest.

What Prevention Would Actually Look Like

Nguyen’s prescriptions run on two tracks. The first begins before working life: schools staffed with nurses and psychologists, detection of serious family or personal situations, and decent educational conditions — a foundation, he argues, that would send young people into working life better equipped.

The second track sits inside companies. He calls for substantive action plans, manager training, psychological support, legal advice, and effective social services — including help for employees facing debt, divorce, financial fragility, or bereavement. Systematic monitoring should exist to flag complex situations and harassment, he told Sud Ouest.

These are not new ideas, he conceded. The distress behind the longest absences — concentrated among young workers, women, and non-executive employees — has been documented for years, and preventive measures “have not been put in place, which is regrettable.”

The ‘Complaisance’ Question

Nguyen's position, as the exchange makes clear, is that this concern is being used to justify caps while the documented driver of the increase — psychological distress affecting one in two employees — goes untreated. The comparison matters: a 12 percent rise in indemnified absences over five years is the figure policy is chasing, while the distress level his barometer records is described as historic.

How France Compares Internationally

Empreinte Humaine’s barometers run on large population panels in France, Canada, and several other countries, according to the firm’s description in the interview. That cross-national base is what allows Nguyen to call the current French distress level a historic peak rather than a local fluctuation.

The policy divergence is equally geographic: Quebec, where his co-founder Brun teaches management at Université Laval, has seen its approaches to preventing psychosocial risks studied through the firm’s barometers in Canada, while France is moving toward numerical caps on absences — two systems responding to the same post-Covid trend in opposite directions.

Indicator Figure Period / Source
Increase in indemnified sick leave, France +12% 2019–2024, cited in Sud Ouest interview
Groups most affected by the longest absences Young employees, women, non-executives Empreinte Humaine, per Sud Ouest

On funding transparency: the barometer Nguyen cites was produced by his own consultancy with Ipsos-BVA, an independent polling partnership he describes as grounded in rigorous scientific studies on large panels.

Where This Goes Next

Nguyen’s argument sets up the coming French debate: whether absence statistics fall under caps, or whether the causes — distress at historic levels — get the prevention infrastructure he says has been missing since before Covid. For context, the rise he documents unfolded over five years, 2019 to 2024, with long absences growing fastest. “It is essential to question the causes of this multiplication: psychological distress,” Nguyen told Sud Ouest.

References

  • Sud Ouest — interview with Christophe Nguyen, occupational psychologist: “Arrêts de travail : ‘Plafonner les arrêts maladie, c’est se limiter à une vision…’”
  • Empreinte Humaine / Ipsos-BVA — 16th barometer on psychological distress at work
  • Empreinte Humaine / Jean-Pierre Brun, Université Laval (Quebec) — research program on quality of life at work and psychosocial risk prevention

Medical disclaimer: This article is journalistic reporting and is not medical advice. Consult a qualified health professional for any personal health concern.

Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

DPPA: UN Teams Work Haiti, IGAD, Cyprus, Central Asia Files

Cardiologists Warn Holiday Dishes Pack Sodium, Fat, Sugar; Offer Swaps