The Public Universal Friend, an American preacher born in Rhode Island on November 29, 1752, announced after surviving a severe fever in October 1776 that the person born into the Quaker family had died and a genderless spirit sent by God had taken over the body.
The Friend founded the Society of Universal Friends and led followers to Jerusalem, New York, Gayety reported.
Here’s why this story keeps resurfacing: nearly 250 years later, the Friend’s life reads like a script Hollywood hasn’t fully claimed yet. A preacher who refused the name Jemima Wilkinson, dressed in vests, neckties and skirts, and answered “I am that I am” when asked whether they were a man or a woman?
That’s a period drama waiting for a green light. And with the Friend’s birthday landing on November 29, queer history audiences are searching for the story all over again.
Scholars Debate Friend's Gender Identity Framing
- The Friend claimed a genderless divine spirit took over the body after a 1776 fever, according to Gayety’s account sourced to American Ancestors.
- The Society of Universal Friends opposed slavery and gave unmarried women leadership roles through its “Faithful Sisterhood,” the Providence Public Library says.
- Scholars still disagree on how to frame the Friend’s gender today — nonbinary is one comparison, but it wasn’t a label the Friend used.
Historian Scott Larson’s research, summarized by JSTOR Daily, captures the claim at the heart of it: the Spirit “took full possession of the Body it now animates.” Larson and the Providence Public Library spell it “Publick.” Followers also called the Friend “Comforter” or “P.U.F.,” Mental Floss reports.
From Quaker Meeting to Pulpit
The Friend was born the eighth of 12 children in Cumberland, Rhode Island, per New York Historical’s life story, and lost their mother at age eight. In the early 1770s, the Providence Public Library says, the future Friend attended New Light Baptist meetings during the Great Awakening — a religious movement built on impassioned preaching and new ways of worshipping.

Then came October 1776. A severe, possibly typhus fever swept the community, American Ancestors reports. The Friend survived and announced the earlier self had died. The family’s Quaker Meeting didn’t buy the story and dismissed them from the community, according to Women & the American Story, New York Historical’s project.
The Friend’s Life, Year by Year
What follows is a life the sources lay out with unusual precision — from a Rhode Island birth to a New York frontier town named Jerusalem.
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| Nov. 29, 1752 | Born in Cumberland, Rhode Island, into a Quaker household |
| Early 1770s | Attends New Light Baptist meetings during the Great Awakening |
| October 1776 | Survives a fever; announces the earlier self has died |
| 1778 | Judge William Potter of Rhode Island joins the followers |
| 1790 | The Society leaves Rhode Island for New York; the Friend settles in Jerusalem |
| July 1, 1819 | The Friend dies in Jerusalem, New York |
But the math of the movement tells a bigger story. In 1778, Judge William Potter joined the Society. The Friend often persuaded slaveholding members to free the people they held, Mental Floss reports.
Jerusalem, New York, and the Fight That Followed
Crowds turned out for the Friend’s preaching across New England and Pennsylvania — supporters, gawkers and critics alike, New York Historical says. Some came for salvation. Others, per that account, came to see the so-called spiritual being who was neither male nor female, while critics called the Friend a dangerous fanatic.
By 1790, the Society had bought land in upstate New York and moved to Jerusalem, near present-day Penn Yan in what’s now Yates County. The community strained under disputes over land and belief. Some followers left. Former members even tried to have the Friend prosecuted for blasphemy — and failed, with the Friend invited to preach in court, Mental Floss’s history describes.
The pronoun question, meanwhile, was settled by faith. Followers avoided gendered pronouns for the Friend as a matter of religious conviction, per Larson’s research summarized by JSTOR Daily. Gayety uses “the Friend.” Modern writers often use singular “they.”
After 1819: Death, Dismissal and a Reclaiming
The Friend died in Jerusalem on July 1, 1819. Followers said the Friend had “left time,” New York Historical says. The body was first placed in a vault, later moved to an unmarked grave, American Ancestors reports. Without the Friend, the Society faded and ceased to exist by the mid-19th century, according to historian Paul B. Moyer’s publisher.
The key point: 19th-century historians mostly dismissed the Friend as a fraud, interpreted the clothing and gender claims as mental illness and refused to use the Friend's chosen name, New York Historical reports. Today’s framing is more careful. Larson emphasizes that followers believed the Friend was a divine spirit, not a human person. Neither interpretation gives us the Friend’s own answer in today’s vocabulary.
Where the Story Lives On
The Providence Public Library’s community archive includes digitized documents and identifies an 1816 portrait by John Mathies held in the Yates collection. NPR’s Throughline devoted a 2020 episode to the Friend. Paul B. Moyer’s 2015 biography remains the standard book-length account.
The Society of Universal Friends, whose theology stayed close to that of the Quakers, stressed free will and sexual abstinence alongside its opposition to slavery.
In the 1790s its members acquired land in Western New York and formed the town of Jerusalem near Penn Yan, one of the first American settlements founded by a religious group led by a woman — or, in this case, by a preacher who claimed no gender at all. The Society did not long outlive its founder: it ceased to exist by the 1860s.
The open question is the one the Friend answered two centuries ago and historians still can’t: what did the Friend actually believe about their own gender? Asked whether the Friend was a man or a woman, the reply was simply, “I am that I am.”