Queens DA Sues to Dismantle Prosecutorial Watchdog Commission

Queens District Attorney Melinda Katz has initiated a legal battle to dismantle the New York State Commission on Prosecutorial Conduct, filing a lawsuit on Nov. 6 that seeks to strip the state’s only independent watchdog of its authority to investigate attorney misconduct.

The filing, which was briefly unsealed on Monday, challenges the commission’s constitutional legitimacy and its power to scrutinize case files from closed investigations, the Queens Daily Eagle reported.

The conflict centers on subpoenas issued by the commission this past summer regarding the wrongful convictions of George Bell, Rohan Bolt, and Gary Johnson. These three men spent a combined 72 years in prison for a 1996 double murder they did not commit—a case that eventually unraveled after the Queens District Attorney’s own Conviction Integrity Unit identified evidence that prosecutors suppressed exculpatory material.

At the heart of the litigation is the argument that the commission represents an unconstitutional encroachment on the New York State Appellate Division’s exclusive jurisdiction over attorney discipline. “intrudes upon the constitutionally protected exclusive jurisdiction of the Appellate Division over matters of attorney discipline,” the Queens District Attorney's office, represented by the law firm Greenberg Traurig, contends

This legal theory mirrors a successful 2020 challenge that previously sidelined the commission. In that instance, Acting Albany Supreme Court Justice David Weinstein ruled that the original 2018 statute creating the body violated the separation of powers by establishing a parallel disciplinary structure. While Albany lawmakers overhauled the law in 2021 to address these constitutional concerns, the current lawsuit argues those reforms were insufficient to protect the judiciary’s traditional oversight role.

Beyond the constitutional question, the lawsuit disputes the commission’s reach into the past. Katz’s office maintains that the 2021 legislation only authorizes investigations into sitting prosecutors, not those who have since left office. The commission, however, has rejected this narrow interpretation, asserting that its mandate to deter misconduct remains vital regardless of an individual’s current employment status.

In an Oct. 15 letter addressed to the District Attorney’s counsel, Ross Firsenbaum, an attorney representing the commission, dismissed the demand to withdraw the subpoenas. “The legislature created the CPC to identify, remedy, and deter prosecutorial misconduct—a need that does not end when a prosecutor leaves office,” Firsenbaum wrote.

The Bell, Bolt, and Johnson case makes this standoff urgent. Following a citywide manhunt ordered by then-Rudy Giuliani, the three men were convicted and sentenced to near-life terms. The case was only reopened years later, revealing that prosecutors had withheld evidence pointing toward other suspects.

While the commission has only issued one formal ruling since its inception—the censure of former Monroe County District Attorney Sandra Doorley for attempting to use her position to avoid a speeding ticket—it has recently ramped up its investigative activity.

The Queens District Attorney’s office has asked the court to quash the subpoenas and declare the commission’s enabling legislation unconstitutional. As the litigation proceeds, the commission has declined to comment on the filing, and the records at the center of the dispute remain under seal.

Photo of author

James Carter Senior News Editor

Senior Editor, News James is an award-winning investigative reporter known for real-time coverage of global events. His leadership ensures Archyde.com’s news desk is fast, reliable, and always committed to the truth.

13 U.S. Congenital Measles Cases Reported in 2025

Howie Mandel to Host New The Joker’s Wild Game Show