A network of researchers promoting “race realism” continues to publish methodologically flawed work in mainstream academic journals despite a scientific consensus that genetically distinct racial categories do not map onto human intelligence or behavior.
The persistence of this pseudo-scientific framework — rebranded from “race science” to “hereditarianism” and now “race realism” — is documented across reporting by The Conversation, Khanlist, and Briefly. These outlets trace the funding lineage from the 1930s Pioneer Fund through the journal Mankind Quarterly to a current entity, Polygenic Scores LLC.
The infrastructure of a pseudoscience
The Pioneer Fund, established by a U.S. textile magnate to fight desegregation, bankrolled Mankind Quarterly in the 1960s as a venue for research rejected by mainstream genetics and evolutionary biology journals.
When the Pioneer Fund was taken over by a current network of race scientists, its remaining funds were channeled into the Human Diversity Foundation, subsequently rebranded as Polygenic Scores LLC. This corporate continuity demonstrates an unbroken institutional commitment to a biological hierarchy of races regardless of scientific evidence.
Psychologist Andrew Winston, an expert in the history of race science in psychology, describes the field as a “community project… with its own networks, mentorships, journals, funding, conferences, heroes, origin myths, martyrs, defenders, and historiography.” The ecosystem functions as a parallel academic structure, complete with its own gatekeepers.

Genetics does not cluster by race
The core scientific claim — that genetic differences drive intelligence gaps between socially defined racial groups — collapsed decades ago. In the 1970s, evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin demonstrated that 85 percent of human genetic variation exists within populations, not between them. Modern genomics has only reinforced this: human genetic variation is clinal, correlating with geography and environment, not the discrete clusters required by racial taxonomy.
Traits like skin pigmentation, hair texture, or lactase persistence are adaptations to local environments — UV radiation, altitude, pastoralism — not markers of continental races. Genetic variants associated with light skin, for example, likely originated in Africa. The ability to digest milk appears in distinct populations across Europe, Africa, and Asia, contradicting far-right claims of an exclusively “Aryan” trait.
Peer review as a vulnerability
If the genetics is settled, how does this work keep appearing in mainstream journals? The answer lies in subfields where methodological standards for population genetics are lax. Evolutionary psychology and the intelligence-and-individual-differences corner of psychology have become primary vectors. Editors and reviewers embedded in the “community project” Winston identified reciprocally review one another’s papers, creating a citation cartel that mimics legitimacy.

Nathan Cofnas, a philosopher affiliated with this network, recently drew public attention for accusing the late sociologist Jason Arday of plagiarism. Less scrutinized were Cofnas’s links to researchers making claims about innate racial differences in intelligence, criminality, and sexuality. University affiliations provide the “mask of legitimacy” that allows methodologically flawed manuscripts to clear peer review in journals that should know better.
From journals to Davos
The pipeline from para-academic journals to political power is short. At the 2025 World Economic Forum in Davos, Donald Trump stated, “I always say these are low-IQ people,” referring to Somalis. Donald Trump Jr. made a parallel claim about Haitians in 2024. The Trump administration subsequently ended Temporary Protected Status for both Somali and Haitian migrants. These statements are not improvisations; they are the political weaponization of narratives laundered through academic publishing.
Misinformation strategies on social media amplify these claims, stripping away the hedging language of the original papers and presenting them as suppressed truth. The algorithmic architecture of platforms like X and Facebook optimizes for engagement, which favors inflammatory racial hierarchies over nuanced population genetics.
The open question
Journals in genetics and evolutionary biology effectively exclude this work through rigorous peer review. The failure is concentrated in psychology and social-science outlets where editors lack the genomic literacy to spot category errors — or where editors share the ideological priors of the authors.
Until those journals adopt the statistical-genetics standards of Nature Genetics or The American Journal of Human Genetics, the “community project” will keep publishing, and politicians will keep citing it.
Founded by textile heir Wickliffe Draper after a 1935 trip to Nazi Germany, the Pioneer Fund was incorporated on March 11, 1937 with a charter modeled on the Third Reich’s Lebensborn breeding program. Its founding director, Harry Laughlin, had praised the Nuremberg Laws and opposed Jewish refugee admission; the Fund’s first project distributed a Nazi eugenics film, Erbkrank, in U.S. churches and schools.
From 2002 until his death in 2012, the fund was headed by J. Philippe Rushton, succeeded by Richard Lynn; after Lynn’s death in 2023, its remaining activity shifted to the Human Diversity Foundation.
“Race scientists make extremely simplistic claims such as: ‘Black people have innately lower intelligence than white people, because selection pressures resulted in the evolution of higher intelligence in white people.’ No part of this claim can be scientifically supported; not from the point of view of genetics, evolutionary biology or psychology.”
The Polygenic Scores LLC filing in Wyoming lists an incorporation date of May 10, 2022.