Record Low Major Party Vote, Second-Lowest Turnout Amid Democratic Crisis

Experts describe a “hollowing out” of the political centre driven by negative campaigning, social media algorithms and a global crisis of democratic confidence.

Voter turnout is on track to be the second lowest on record, according to RNZ reporting cited by 1News. Preliminary results show National and Labour tied at 29 percent each, their lowest combined share under MMP, while minor parties gained ground.

Why did voters stay home?

Many voters told RNZ they felt uncertain about who to support or whether to vote at all. One West Aucklander said choosing between parties was like “picking which shit food to eat” and ultimately did not vote. Another Aucklander cited “empty promises” that “just don’t happen,” 1News reported.

Photo: The Spinoff

What do the numbers show?

The Post NZ reported that just 62 percent of voters gave their party vote to National or Labour, the lowest “purple vote” in MMP history. Neither major party reached a third of the party vote, though Labour and National still won three-quarters of electorate votes. National’s 41 percent of the electorate vote gave it more seats than any other party despite fewer party votes than Labour.

Is this a local or global trend?

International relations expert Reuben Steff, associate professor at Mendel University, told RNZ New Zealand is following a global crisis of confidence in democracy. He pointed to growing distrust in political institutions, populist sentiment, media distrust, disinformation and declining civic skills. “Citizens are feeling increasingly isolated and alienated. It is not an exaggeration to say that the political system now arguably faces a legitimacy crisis,” Steff told RNZ.

Voter turnout second lowest in NZ history | Now You Know — The Spinoff

How has the “attention economy” changed politics?

Former chief science advisor Sir Peter Gluckman told RNZ the MMP system was not designed for the social media age. “Extreme parties grab more of the attention economy,” which works on single statements that are not nuanced.

University of Auckland professor Neal Curtis said algorithms maximise engagement by amplifying scandal and outrage, creating an environment dominated by conflict and clickbait. Curtis warned RNZ that even publicly funded media face pressure to chase engagement rather than create a different information environment.

Were the campaigns more negative than usual?

The Listener’s political columnist Danyl McLauchlan told RNZ both major parties ran predominantly negative campaigns. “They understand New Zealand politics primarily in terms of opposing each other.”

Can the system address long-term problems?

Gluckman said the “muddled” result makes it very difficult to make hard decisions on the political economy, the position of Māori, health and education. “Those ‘hard questions’ shouldn’t be caught in the ‘pendulum of three-year cycles’,” he told RNZ. “We do need some long-term thinking desperately in New Zealand.”

Caretaker conventions govern during extended interregnum

The Spinoff noted the country is currently operating under caretaker conventions, with Auckland Wayne Brown remarking after a trip to China that “democracy has had its day.” Belgium went 541 days without a government in 2010–11; a similar interregnum in New Zealand would last until 2028.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Gardaí Arrest Man, 20s, After Armed Cork Hijacking