Regional Hospital Mullingar Apologises for Failings in Care of Girl (2) Who Died Less Than 24 Hours After Admission

Twenty-four members of the Trimble family filled a High Court courtroom on Wednesday to hear a hospital apologise for the death of a two-year-old girl. Among them was a great-grandmother who travelled from Manchester.

Regional Hospital Mullingar offered an unreserved apology to Sarah and Richard Trimble of Kinnegad, Co Westmeath, over the death of their daughter Willow, who died on December 16, 2023, less than 24 hours after she was brought to the hospital’s emergency department with a fever and a dangerously high heart rate. The apology came as the family settled an action against the Health Service Executive.

The court heard that Willow would have survived if she had been transferred to Children’s Health Ireland at Crumlin in Dublin in time. An autopsy found she died of myocarditis — an inflammation of the heart — and a very high heart rate, caused by RSV, a common viral illness that is rarely fatal.

Hospital manager Margaret Kelleher read the apology to the court.

“On behalf of Regional Hospital Mullingar I offer my sincere and unreserved apology for the failures in the care provided to Willow during her time in our hospital. We deeply regret that the standards of care she and your family were entitled to expect was not delivered.”

Kelleher said she recognised that no apology could undo what happened or lessen the family’s grief, but wanted the Trimbles assured that lessons from Willow’s care had been carefully considered, with the aim of preventing a similar tragedy.

Willow’s parents, Sarah and Richard Trimble, from Kinnegad in Co Westmeath
Photo: The Irish Times

Nine and a half hours for an ECG

The timeline set out in court was stark. Willow’s GP referred her to Mullingar on the afternoon of December 15, 2023, after a runny nose, cough and fever had not improved in 10 days despite antibiotics. She was admitted at 1.30pm.

For her entire time in the emergency department, her heart rate was abnormally and dangerously high, senior counsel Sara Antoniotti, instructed by solicitor Rachael Liston, told the court. Yet an ECG was not carried out until 11pm — nine and a half hours after admission.

There was further concern that abnormalities in the reading came from adult leads being used on a toddler’s heart, and more delay followed while child-sized leads were found. The results went to the paediatric cardiology team in Dublin, which advised medicine — but Willow’s response to it was misinterpreted.

Had her true heart rate been appreciated, Antoniotti said, she would have been transferred to Crumlin. Instead she stayed in Mullingar, where her condition collapsed shortly before 5am. She died just before 7am.

A review of the case identified systems failures, the court heard, including a delay in escalating Willow to senior-level care, and problems with transfer procedures and specialist anaesthetic support.

The Irish Times added one detail about how the case moved: the hospital’s letter admitting liability arrived only two weeks before mediation began earlier this month. Liability was admitted before mediation took place, counsel said. Mr Justice Paul Coffey approved the division of the €35,000 statutory mental distress solatium payment.

‘Shattered into a million pieces’

Outside the Four Courts, Sarah Trimble described the day her daughter died.

“December 16th 2023 was the day our lives were shattered into a million pieces. We walked into Mullingar Hospital with our beautiful baby girl Willow and less than 24 hours later we left without her.”

She said the grief and pain would stay with the family for the rest of their lives.

“I will never get to bring her shopping for her communion dress, Richie will never get to walk her down the aisle and the boys will never get to be the protective older brothers if she ever got into trouble.”

Willow was a healthy child with no underlying conditions, the court heard. She had two older brothers, aged 11 and 12. The younger one was very close to his sister, and her death hit him hard — he feared he was the one who gave her the cold that led to her dying.

Willow had already been predeceased by two siblings: a girl who died at six months, and a boy who lived only hours after his birth.

The family welcomed the admission of liability and the apology, Sarah Trimble said, but nothing brings Willow back.

“So we can only hope that lessons have been learned and changes have been made so that no other family has to experience what we have.”

Justice Coffey called it a very sad and tragic case, noting that the effect on the family could be seen in the 24 members who came to court. He extended his deepest sympathies to Willow’s parents, her brothers and the extended family.

The last word went to her mother, speaking directly to the child the hospital failed.

“Willow we love you, we miss you and we think about you every day. You will forever be a part of our family and your memory will live on through us.”

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

King’s College London Study Maps 116,000 Gut Viruses, Links Phageome to Microbiome Health