Renting and Investing Can Outperform Buying in SA, BusinessTech Reports

Buying a home in South Africa often fails to outperform renting when the savings from lower monthly costs are consistently invested. According to BusinessTech, tenants who remain disciplined with their capital can end up millions of rand wealthier than homeowners over a decade, depending on property market trajectories and interest rates.

Jonathan Kohler, the founder and CEO of Landsdowne Property Group, notes that the financial wisdom of purchasing a property is not universal. “Just because you can afford to buy a property does not necessarily mean you should,” he told BusinessTech. Kohler himself rented for much of his career in Johannesburg, only choosing to purchase a home after a recent reassessment of market opportunities.

Is renting a better wealth-building strategy?

The financial benefit of renting depends on the difference between monthly ownership expenses and rental costs, alongside the performance of invested capital. When a tenant invests the money that would otherwise cover a deposit, transfer costs, and higher monthly bond repayments, they can accumulate significant wealth. BusinessTech reported that in Johannesburg’s Bryanston suburb, a tenant could be approximately R1.6 million better off after ten years by renting and investing rather than buying a R4.5 million home.

In Cape Town, the calculation shifts due to stronger price growth, yet buying remains a complex decision. A three-bedroom home in Claremont priced at R5.5 million requires higher upfront capital and monthly outlays compared to renting. BusinessTech calculated that a tenant could be R1.1 million better off after a decade, assuming 3% annual property appreciation for a homeowner.

Factor Bryanston (Johannesburg) Claremont (Cape Town)
Purchase Price R4,500,000 R5,500,000
Initial Monthly Savings ~R11,050 ~R15,170
10-Year Financial Advantage Renting by ~R1,600,000 Renting by ~R1,100,000
Break-Even Annual Growth ~5.6% ~4.4%

The success of the rental strategy relies entirely on the tenant’s ability to avoid spending the monthly savings. Kohler cautioned that homeowners often view bond repayments as a form of forced savings, which provides a level of stability and security that renting does not. “The decision should come down to the cost of ownership compared with rent, expected property appreciation and the discipline to invest the difference,” Kohler said.

His track record includes closing complex transactions, such as deals that required a decade of persistent follow-up, and identifying undervalued assets like an auction property that generated 18 months of rental income before the deposit was ultimately refunded.

Kohler also learned a critical lesson on capital allocation after holding a corporate office for ten years only to sell it at the original purchase price, an experience that sharpened his focus on assets that genuinely appreciate.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Lord of the Rings: Hunt for Gollum Wraps Filming; Wood Returns