South African shopping malls are undergoing a structural shift as major grocery retailers lose the right to enforce exclusive lease agreements.
By 31 December 2026, all existing exclusivity clauses held by Shoprite (JSE: SHP), Pick n Pay (JSE: PIK), and SPAR (JSE: SPP) must be terminated to stimulate market competition.
Strategic Shifts for Retail Landlords
- Existing exclusive lease agreements must be fully terminated by 31 December 2026.
- New exclusive contracts are strictly prohibited starting 1 January 2027.
- Landlords are currently reconfiguring tenant mixes to accommodate multiple grocery operators in high-foot-traffic centers.
The regulatory directive follows the Competition Commission’s 2019 Grocery Retail Market Inquiry, which determined that long-term exclusivity clauses created significant barriers to entry for smaller, independent, and historically disadvantaged retailers.
As reported by newsday.co.za, the Competition Tribunal confirmed legally binding consent agreements with the three major chains to phase out these protections. Shoprite was the first to formalize its agreement in October 2020, followed by Pick n Pay in June 2021, and SPAR in 2023.
“It affects all landlords with grocery exclusivity clauses, though many wanted them scrapped anyway,” Competition Commission spokesperson Siyabulela Makunga confirmed to businesstech.co.za. While major players are impacted, retailers like Woolworths (JSE: WHL) and Food Lover’s Market are unaffected, as they did not utilize such restrictive lease provisions.
Market Realignment and Competition Dynamics
The removal of these clauses is intended to diversify price points and product offerings within individual shopping centers. Gavin Jones, head of retail asset management at Growthpoint, said that larger centers are already preparing to host secondary or tertiary supermarket brands.
“The change has created opportunities to introduce a second or third supermarket into larger centres,” Jones told supermarket.co.za. He added that pairing mainstream grocers with value-focused brands like Boxer, a subsidiary of Shoprite, will likely serve distinct customer segments.
The following timeline outlines the progression of the regulatory intervention:
| Date | Key Regulatory Development |
|---|---|
| December 2019 | Competition Commission publishes Grocery Retail Market Inquiry findings. |
| October 2020 | Competition Tribunal confirms Shoprite’s consent agreement. |
| June 2021 | Competition Tribunal confirms Pick n Pay’s consent agreement. |
| 2023 | Competition Tribunal confirms SPAR’s consent agreement. |
| 31 December 2026 | Deadline for termination of all existing exclusivity arrangements. |
| 1 January 2027 | Effective date for the prohibition of new exclusive lease agreements. |
Constraints on Retail Expansion
Despite the regulatory shift, market analysts suggest that the physical environment will not change overnight. The availability of floor space and the commercial viability of specific locations remain the primary determinants for new store openings. Landlords are currently working through the transition by renewing leases without the restrictive clauses that previously shielded incumbent retailers from direct competition.
The impact on competition is expected to be most pronounced in regional malls where square footage allows for multiple, competing grocery anchors. For investors, the focus remains on how these retailers adjust their operational strategies to defend market share in a more crowded environment. The Competition Commission maintains that the current trajectory is necessary to increase innovation and lower costs for consumers by fostering a more accessible retail environment.
“The availability of suitable retail space, the size of individual centres, and the commercial decisions of landlords and retailers will continue to determine where additional grocery stores open,” Jones told newsday.co.za. The industry now looks toward the 31 December 2026 deadline as the definitive point of transition for the South African retail property sector.
Founded in 1979, Shoprite has grown to become Africa’s largest supermarket retailer and the largest private sector employer in South Africa, with a workforce exceeding 174,400 people. The organization operates a diverse portfolio of brands, including the Checkers supermarket chain and the USave low-income stores. As of June 2026, the group maintained a network of 3,710 stores across 8 African countries, serving 36.5 million Xtra Savings rewards customers.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.