Sakurai: Kirby Air Riders Isn’t a “Fake Mario Kart,” Innovation Is a “Giant Ice Wall”

Masahiro Sakurai is challenging the industry to look beyond familiar formulas, warning that true creative innovation requires overcoming a “giant ice wall” of player expectations and design conventions.

The veteran designer, who received an excellence award at the Japan Game Awards 2026, explained that the struggle to introduce novel mechanics is often hampered by players who reject changes when they do not find the experience they expected.

In an interview with Denfaminicogamer, Sakurai addressed the long-standing perception that Kirby Air Riders is a “fake Mario Kart,” a label he attributes to players approaching the title with the wrong expectations, according to Nintendo Everything.

“For example, people may have the question of ‘In Kirby Air Riders, why do I push a button to stop?’, but people who understand the game know that the aim here is the ‘push’ action, and from there things like drifting, etc. But before arriving at that understanding, people can get turned off by ‘something feels off.’” — Masahiro Sakurai

Sakurai said that while he has consistently sought to introduce original ideas into his work—citing Super Smash Bros., Meteos, and Kid Icarus: Uprising as examples—innovation carries significant risk, according to Nintenderos. According to Nintenderos, he emphasized that developing a new mechanic is only the first step; a creator must also convince their team, the publisher, and the players of the concept’s value.

He argued that communicating a game’s unique virtues is as essential as the design process itself. He also said that if a work offers exactly the same experience as another, the best choice is to play the original title. Furthermore, he suggested that games like Danganronpa and Taiyō no Shippo serve as examples of projects whose originality deserves recognition from their earliest development stages.

Kirby air riders fake mario kart
Photo: nintendoeverything.com

Sakurai highlighted that games have recently become more complex in terms of volume and control schemes, often adhering to established standards where players expect specific buttons for shooting or different types of attacks.

He questioned whether these norms can or should be changed, noting that the goal is not novelty for its own sake, but creating new ways to play by understanding the essence of fun. Regarding his own career, he remarked, “I’ve always thought that was difficult.”

Looking toward the future of the medium, Sakurai expressed concern regarding the rise of artificial intelligence. While he expects AI will increase the volume of available games, he warned that it will likely lead to a surge of unoriginal products that merely imitate existing mechanics.

Reflecting on his past projects, game designer Masahiro Sakurai cited titles such as Meteos in 2005 and Kid Icarus: Uprising in 2012 as examples of his consistent effort to introduce original ideas rather than relying on safe iterations.

Throughout his career, he approached innovation by recognizing that developing a novel mechanic is only the initial hurdle, noting that creators must actively guide players past the friction of unfamiliar control schemes to prove the underlying value of new gameplay concepts.

The discussion also touched on his 16-year tenure as chair of the Game Designers Awards. Sakurai revealed that he stepped down only after failing to find a successor willing to manage the logistical complexities of the role, which included coordinating jury decisions and publicly explaining the merits of selected titles.

It remains unknown who, if anyone, will eventually take over the leadership of the awards, or if the process will be fundamentally restructured in his absence.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

TNA Hall of Famer Gail Kim, Alisha Edwards to Host Dec. 7 Auction for Rebel