Sargassum howeanum, a seaweed unseen since 1935, has turned up in vast underwater forests near Lord Howe Island at depths of 20–38 metres, The Conversation reported — and the find suggests deep, cooler water may act as potential refuges for seaweed, particularly as climate change warms the world’s oceans.
That is the headline. The quieter story underneath is about the instrumentation: baited remote underwater video systems, deployed on routine marine-park monitoring, accidentally solved a nine-decade-old botanical mystery. The Conversation’s report describes how cameras sent to film fish on the island’s shelf instead captured a seafloor transformed.
A tangle from 1935, a forest in 2022
Botanist A.H.S. Lucas collected large adult specimens of the caramel-coloured seaweed near Lord Howe Island — a World Heritage-listed site about 600 kilometres off Australia’s eastern coast — in 1935, and named it Sargassum howeanum. For the next 90 years, scientists found only small, immature plants in the shallow waters around the island. The adults were, apparently, nowhere.
In 2022, a team monitoring marine parks around the island deployed baited remote underwater video systems across shelf habitats 20–50 metres down. These camera rigs are standard kit for estimating fish abundance in sensitive environments, and they are non-invasive by design.
After the first day of surveys, the researchers reviewed their footage and noticed the once-bare seafloor at a routinely monitored site was blanketed in tall seaweed. Dense forests kept appearing at other sites, The Conversation reported.
Specimens that became entangled in the camera gear were sent to algal expert Gerald Kraft, who identified two species: Sargassum spinuligerum and Sargassum howeanum. The S. howeanum plants were adults up to 72 centimetres long, carrying receptacles — the finger-like structures used for reproduction.
The mystery of where the adults lived was solved. Lucas, the researchers suggest, likely collected his originals at similar depths using a deepwater dredge, a metal frame towed along the seafloor; he never recorded where or how he collected them.
Twenty-two times more forest, on camera
The scale of the change is the figure that matters. Combining survey footage from 2009, 2013, 2017 and 2022, the team found the area covered by Sargassum forests had grown 22 times between 2009 and 2022. The surveys sit at depths of 20–50 metres, and the confirmed forests run from 20 to 38 metres down — a band that satellite and surface monitoring simply does not see.
That blind spot is the technical point worth dwelling on. Surface-temperature datasets, the same ones feeding most climate-impact models for coastal ecosystems, showed sea surface temperatures at Lord Howe Island rising about 0.2°C per decade since 1985.
Yet satellite data indicates waters at 20–50 metres were cooler in the lead-up to 2022 than in earlier survey years. The layer where the seaweed thrives and the layer we routinely measure are not the same layer.
The researchers do not yet know what drove the 22-fold expansion. Cooler deep water is their leading hypothesis, and they flag it as provisional. The finding is a reminder that environmental baselines built on shallow surveys can misrepresent what an ecosystem is actually doing below the photic sweet spot — an instrumentation gap, not just an ecological one.
Why refuges matter when forests collapse
Context makes the discovery urgent rather than merely curious. Seaweed forests are shrinking fast worldwide: kelp forests have declined by 95% in regions including Tasmania and Northern California, driven mainly by marine heatwaves and ocean warming, with growing populations of seaweed-eating sea urchins compounding the losses. Seaweed forests support reef fish, seadragons and abalone, and pull roughly 56 million tonnes of carbon from the atmosphere each year.
Against that backdrop, the Lord Howe Island forests look like what ecologists call a depth refugium: deeper habitat, less exposed to rising temperatures and to tropical herbivorous fish moving poleward and overgrazing shallower ecosystems.
The researchers are careful with the claim — their observations are preliminary, they say, and more research is needed to confirm the refuge function. The Conversation’s report is explicit that confirmation requires long-term monitoring programs, which they argue are urgently needed as extreme weather intensifies.
There is an engineering lesson embedded here for anyone building environmental sensing systems. The entire discovery came from existing, routinely deployed BRUVS hardware — baited cameras, no new sensors, no exotic platform.
The gap was not capability but depth coverage: monitoring programs had simply never prioritized the 20–50 metre band. The 2022 entangled specimen that cracked the case was, in effect, a bycatch of a fish survey. Cheap, persistent, depth-stratified camera networks would have surfaced this pattern years earlier.
What is still unknown
Several questions remain open, and the sources flag each one. What caused the expansion between 2009 and 2022 is unconfirmed. Whether the deep forests actually function as climate refuges is untested. And whether the trend holds as surface warming pushes down through the water column is exactly what the researchers say long-term monitoring must now determine.
The island itself has a curiously layered history. Lieutenant Henry Lidgbird Ball sighted it on 17 February 1788 while en route to found a penal settlement on Norfolk Island, and it was permanently settled from 1834. Now home to fewer than 500 people, much of the island remains untouched forest, and the surrounding waters sit within the Lord Howe Island Marine Park.
UNESCO lists the group — which includes the uninhabited volcanic spire of Ball’s Pyramid, about 23 kilometres to the southeast — as a World Heritage Site, placing the seaweed’s rediscovered deepwater habitat in one of the world’s most protected marine settings.
The monitoring programs the team calls for are the actionable item: they let scientists track ecosystem conditions worldwide, The Conversation notes, and in this case they may solve the occasional environmental mystery.