Secret Audits Find Cable Failures at Three More Lisbon Funiculars after Glória Disaster

LISBON — Four secret safety audits found the cable failures that killed 16 people aboard Lisbon’s Elevador da Glória on Sept. 3, 2025, were present, in some form, at three more of the city’s historic funiculars.

The reports, commissioned by Carris itself, stayed hidden for more than a year — until a TVI/CNN Portugal investigation forced them into the open on Wednesday.

The audits, carried out by the engineering and equipment-safety specialist CATIM between Oct. 24 and Nov. 25, 2025, examined the Glória, Lavra and Bica funiculars and the Santa Justa lift. None of the four passed cable inspection without reservations, CNN Portugal reported. At three of them, the findings raised concerns serious enough that, in the words now circulating through Lisbon’s political class, the Glória tragedy could have happened elsewhere.

The documents identify inadequate traction cables, severe corrosion, degraded structures and deficient maintenance procedures. Some of the failures were known years before the disaster — and, according to the auditors, corroded structures in at least one case were stripped and repainted without the underlying corrosion ever being treated.

“This is the most worrying report I have ever had in my hands,” said Ricardo Moreira, a Left Bloc member of parliament.

The cable problem drew the sharpest warning from an engineer. "Very serious.”

Lavra: Carris crews refused to run the tests

The harshest finding concerns the Lavra funicular. When CATIM technicians prepared to run functional tests, it was Carris’s own maintenance staff who told them the conditions to move the car safely were not in place. The auditors wrote that there was “insufficient confidence in the state of the system.” Start-and-stop, braking, power-failure and cable-fault tests were never performed.

image name
Photo: RTP

The problems predate the disaster. An ISQ report from 2023, cited by CATIM, had already found “indications capable of compromising the integrity” of Lavra’s traction cable. The funicular uses the same type of cable as the Glória and kept running until the day of the tragedy, RTP reported.

“That means the Lavra funicular should not have operated from 2023 onward, and it was kept running,” Moreira said, according to CNN Portugal.

Pedro Bogas, who sat on Carris’s board of directors in 2023, told Exclusivo the information never reached the administration. He said such reports were requested by the technical maintenance services, which were responsible for deciding and executing any repairs.

CATIM’s bottom line on Lavra is blunt: “The installation does not meet the safety conditions to enter operation.” Beyond the cable, auditors found corrosion, cracks and supports with a substantial or total loss of load-bearing section, plus non-conformities in the trambolho — the assembly connecting the cable to the car. “Some of the irregularities identified are the ones that render the equipment completely unusable,” Neves said.

Corrosion found in 2022 painted over

At the Bica funicular, the paper trail stretches back even further. Severe corrosion on the track’s support structure was identified in 2022. Three years later, the CATIM report described the degradation as persisting — with evidence in some zones that structures had been stripped and painted “without the corrosion having been treated.”

Carlos Gaivoto, an engineer who worked for decades at Carris and reviewed the reports for Exclusivo, was direct, according to SIC Notícias. “Those corrosive aspects aren’t a matter of cleaning and painting over — they may even warrant replacement and reconstruction,” he told CNN Portugal.

The cable documentation also failed. One certificate referenced European standard EN 12385-4, while a later document cited EN 12385-8, the standard CATIM considers correct for this type of installation. The auditors concluded the paperwork was insufficient to demonstrate full compliance, and inspection found signs of cable untwisting near the connection to the vehicle. CATIM’s verdict: the Bica needs “significant and urgent interventions.”

Secret Audits Find Cable Failures at Three More Lisbon Funiculars after Glória Disaster
Photo: Jornal de Notícias

Redundant safety systems passed testing

Santa Justa, the city’s iron vertical lift, presents a different picture. The audit found non-conformities — including the same cable-standard mismatch — but concluded the installation was globally compliant, with exceptions noted. Its redundant safety systems passed testing.

“In the case of the Santa Justa lift, if the cable failed, the parachute system would work,” Neves explained. He added that while several items “merit correction, it does not have the gravity of the others. Let’s be clear.”

Wrong cable installed with forbidden device

The Glória audit carries inherent limits: the inspection came after the derailment, when the funicular was destroyed. “It is not possible to conclude on the compliance of the entirety of the installation,” the report says. But the pre-accident documentation speaks.

Certificates for the last two cables installed, in 2022 and 2024, referenced EN 12385-4 — the standard CATIM deemed unsuitable — and stated the cables should not be used with an untwisting device. The Glória was equipped with one. RTP reports the auditors also found no evidence of any magnetic-inductive test on the cable after the 2024 installation, and that all four funiculars carried cables without certification for carrying passengers.

Mayor confronted over hidden audit reports

The political fallout landed on Mayor Carlos Moedas within hours. Confronted by Exclusivo with the existence and contents of the audits, the mayor’s office reversed a position it had given hours earlier and released the documents. The governing PSD/CDS-PP/IL coalition then handed them to opposition councilors on Wednesday.

The opposition says the concealment was deliberate. Lisbon’s Left Bloc demanded Moedas’s resignation on Wednesday, accusing him of hiding the reports and lying, SIC Notícias reported. The party notes that on Dec. 3, 2025, the city hall said publicly the CATIM audit was “under way” — when all four reports were already finished.

The bloc says its councilors had requested the documents repeatedly, in writing and in council meetings, without result. It also disputes the mayor’s earlier claims: that he had contacted “all the families” of the victims, that maintenance had risen 30%, and that a municipal victims’ fund was being created. According to the bloc, the fund “was never created.”

Carlos moedas luis manuel neves lusa
Photo: AbrilAbril

“Political responsibility is when the politician knows and does not act,” the bloc recalled, quoting Moedas himself. The party is demanding an extraordinary council meeting, referral of the reports to the Public Prosecutor’s Office and the GPIAAF aviation-and-rail accident bureau, full publication of the technical documentation, and an urgent hearing of the mayor at the Municipal Assembly.

The Socialists, per Jornal de Notícias, say they were told in May 2026 by deputy mayor Gonçalo Reis that no report existed, and again in June, when Carris’s board and Reis told opposition councilors the audits had only been requested that year.

“It was a lie. We now know that in May and June of this year, Carris already had these reports,” the socialist councilors said in a statement. At Wednesday’s private council meeting — held without Moedas — Reis said he had no knowledge of the reports at those dates, then later acknowledged learning of them while refusing to say when, JN reported.

The Portuguese Communist Party’s councilor, João Ferreira, has filed a formal request demanding to know when the mayor learned of the reports and what measures followed, AbrilAbril reported. The party’s labor commission at Carris had warned in a 2023 letter about “deficient maintenance of vehicles” and company “negligence in matters of hygiene and safety.”

Moedas’s office and Carris’s board, led by Rui Lopo, did not respond to Lusa’s questions as of Wednesday, JN reported. One bright note in the file: the Graça funicular, audited alongside the others, received a globally favorable assessment, according to Diário do Distrito, and CATIM noted Santa Justa’s 12-cable system offers high redundancy.

All four historic elevators remain closed since September 2025. The Public Prosecutor’s Office is still investigating the Glória derailment — and now has four more documents to read.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

First Criticism Hits Renovated Estadio Metropolitano Ahead of Copa Sudamericana Final

Earth Remains Habitable for Billions of Years Without Life, Simulation Shows