Sen. John Cornyn Blocks Trump Judicial Nominee Over Texas Residency Dispute

Sen. John Cornyn on Wednesday blocked President Donald Trump’s last-minute pick for a federal judgeship, refusing to return the “blue slip” that lets the Senate Judiciary Committee consider T. Elliot Gaiser, CNN reported.

The reason: the nominee isn’t a Texan.

Cornyn, the departing Texas senator, told CNN he withheld the customary home-state sign-off because the White House reached outside the state to fill the seat. Gaiser, who leads the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel, was nominated earlier this month as Republicans race to confirm Trump’s judicial picks before Democrats take over the Senate and the process stalls.

“I just refuse to be jammed by a non-Texan who has no trial experience, who hasn’t been vetted,” Cornyn told CNN. He said he offered the White House an alternative and hopes it takes the deal, because “I don’t want the seat to go vacant either.” Cornyn has previously suggested former DOJ prosecutor Steve Fahey for the nomination.

Because of Cornyn’s hold, Gaiser never appeared at Wednesday’s Judiciary Committee hearing, where seven other nominees sat for three hours of grilling. The episode lands at a volatile moment: a lame-duck confirmation sprint, a blue-slip custom suddenly enforced by a senator from the president’s own party, and a nominee whose legal writings on lethal force have already drawn national attention.

Sen. John Cornyn Blocks Trump Judicial Nominee Over Texas Residency Dispute
Photo: edition.cnn.com

Cornyn wields blue slip against Gaiser

The blue slip is a piece of paper, but in judicial nominations it functions as a veto. By Senate custom, a home-state senator’s refusal to return the slip blocks a Judiciary Committee hearing for a district court nominee. Cornyn exercised that power against his own party’s White House in an interview with CNN, a striking breach for a senator who has spent decades inside the institution’s machinery.

His objection cuts on two grounds: residency and résumé. Gaiser is not from Texas, and Cornyn told CNN he lacks trial experience and hasn’t been vetted. The senator’s preferred fix, Steve Fahey, is a former DOJ prosecutor.

Whether the White House swaps nominees in the weeks left on the clock remains the open question; Cornyn said only that he hopes it takes advantage of the alternative, and the Justice Department did not respond when CNN sought comment on the Gaiser nomination.

Seven nominees, three hours, one silence

The hearing itself gave Democrats their last, best chance to press Trump’s judicial slate before power changes hands. Philip Aubart, nominated for the US District Judge for the Middle District of North Carolina, was among those pressed on whether he could rule against the administration that picked him.

Nominees were repeatedly questioned on the 2020 presidential election results and their willingness to rule against the Trump administration, CNN reported. The pattern reflects a Democratic strategy: force on-the-record answers, or force a visible refusal, in the final hours before the committee changes hands.

Sen. John Cornyn Blocks Trump Judicial Nominee Over Texas Residency Dispute
Photo: ktvz.com

The nominee at the center of bigger fights

Gaiser’s day job made him a controversial choice long before Cornyn’s blue slip. As head of the Office of Legal Counsel, he has issued several opinions in recent months that sparked controversy, CNN reported.

In early October, CNN reported that a classified legal opinion from the Trump administration justified lethal strikes against a long list of cartels and suspected drug traffickers, arguing the strikes were authorized because the targets posed a threat to Americans.

Gaiser told select members of Congress that the administration can continue those lethal strikes without congressional approval, and that the strikes did not trigger the requirements of the war powers law because they did not meet the definition of “hostilities,” according to CNN’s reporting.

A man who signed off on that legal theory was, until Wednesday, on a glide path to a lifetime seat — with the clock, not the merits, as the main obstacle.

His official profile at the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel lists him as the head of the office, the post from which those opinions issued.

Democrats gain Senate, Trump picks stall

The math is unforgiving. Democrats take over the Senate, and with it the power to stall confirmations, meaning any Trump judicial pick not confirmed by year’s end likely waits indefinitely. Cornyn holds the power: without his blue slip, Gaiser goes nowhere. With it, the seat could be filled before the gavel changes hands.

That leaves the White House with three options — swap in Fahey, fight Cornyn, or let the Texas seat sit vacant into the next Congress. Cornyn says he doesn’t want the vacancy. Whether the president’s team values the seat more than the specific nominee will decide this fight, and it has to decide fast.

“And so, we provided the White House an alternative, and I’m hoping they take advantage of it,” Cornyn told CNN. “Because I don’t want the seat to go vacant either.”

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Pennsylvania Unvaccinated Resident Dies Amid Measles Resurgence