Sentence Concurrence Petitions: Conditions, Procedure, and Case Law per Simonnet Avocat

Defendants facing separate prison terms for multiple offenses can file a request for sentence concurrence under art.

132-4 du code pénal, requiring proof of personal rehabilitation rather than just legal eligibility, according to Simonnet Avocat.

Filing Strategic Realities

  • A successful petition requires documenting behavioral changes, employment, and family stability since the initial ruling.
  • Under art. 132-2 du code pénal, offenses must occur before a definitive conviction for a prior act.
  • Appeals regarding correctional tribunal decisions must go to the chambre des appels correctionnels, as established by prior high court rulings.

When individuals receive separate sentences for offenses committed in concurrence, identical penalties accumulate up to the highest legal maximum. Valentin Simonnet, an attorney at the Paris Bar, notes that total or partial sentence merging is entirely optional and never granted by right, according to Maître Valentin Simonnet Avocat. A petition resting solely on the text of art. 132-4 du code pénal faces systematic rejection in court.

The core legal threshold requires demonstrating that an offense occurred before a definitive conviction was handed down for a prior matter, as outlined in art. 132-2 du code pénal. Furthermore, art. 132-5 dictates that only penalties of the same nature can be combined.

Applicants Must Prove Behavioral Changes and Stability

As established by Cass. crim., 11 juillet 2017, n° 16-85.676, the applicant must produce concrete evidence regarding behavioral changes, personality evolution, and material or familial stability. According to pb-avocat.com, working with legal representation helps ensure the precise chronology of facts and definitive convictions is established without omitting required supporting documentation like criminal records.

Submitting an incomplete request without verified judgments or a criminal record sheet exposes the petitioner to immediate dismissal. The court evaluates the applicant’s conduct since the initial sentencing in a private chamber hearing, where appearance is not automatically guaranteed unless explicitly requested by a detained individual.

Initial Sentencing Court Handles Procedural Disputes

Procedural disputes and execution incidents are handled by the court that delivered the initial sentence, or by the jurisdiction of the place of detention if the applicant is incarcerated. If a trial court explicitly rejects sentence merging during the initial judgment, submitting a subsequent request under article 710 is barred due to the authority of res judicata.

Appeals against tribunal rulings regarding these requests follow a strict ten-day window from the date of the ruling or its formal notification. Subsequent procedural changes, including the legislative renumbering introduced by ordinance n° 2025-1091, take effect toward the end of the decade.

Valentin Simonnet has been an avocat at the Paris Bar since 2018, with a practice focused entirely on litigation. He trained at international firms including Freshfields and Hogan Lovells and completed a full academic year at the UCL Faculty of Laws in London.

His firm represents international individuals, investors and businesses in business disputes, civil litigation and white-collar criminal matters in France, conducting all client communications in English while handling proceedings in French courts.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or legal advice.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

NIKKE: Goddess of Victory Launcher Malware Breaches Japanese City Government Network