SG4, an alliance of the four Malaysian states governed by Parti Islam SeMalaysia, pitched a plan to pool their economies and resources at a packed Kuala Lumpur forum this week, pressing Putrajaya for fiscal autonomy.
The Business and Economic Forum, themed “Four States, One Economic Vision,” filled a hall at the Kuala Lumpur Convention Centre with government representatives, economists, industry leaders and diplomats, FULCRUM reported. SG4 groups the PAS-governed states of Kedah, Kelantan and Terengganu with Perlis, where PAS governs in coalition with Bersatu. The bloc is two years old.
The four states sit atop roughly 70 per cent of Malaysia’s inferred rare earth element reserves. Seventy per cent of Malaysia’s REE inferred reserves reportedly lie within the four states’ perimeters.
SG4 advisor Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamed, in prepared remarks read on his behalf, called the four states “a sleeping giant”.
A giant with empty pockets
The four states hold 5.7 million people across 38,000 square kilometres, and each showcased its industrial bases at the forum — petrochemicals, manufacturing, semiconductors, agro-industry, tourism and logistics. SG4’s pitch links industrial development to green energy, logistics and workforce preparation across all four.
Putrajaya collects almost all income, corporate and sales taxes, leaving the states only land, forestry, water and tourism revenues. State borrowing requires federal approval, so SG4 would not be able to self-finance large-scale infrastructure or green energy grids.
Terengganu Chief Minister Dr Ahmad Samsuri Mokhtar, in his opening address, suggested a major framework such as a federal-state fiscal and development equalisation formula, under which a portion of taxes generated by states but collected by Putrajaya would be returned to the respective states. Stronger states, he argued, would “develop more productive activities and contribute to more national growth”.
Referring to the 2019 Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences winner Abhijit Banerjee, he argued that the genuine gauges of public welfare are secure jobs, reachable healthcare, the calibre of schooling and how wealth is spread — rather than GDP figures by themselves. Whether a PAS-led government would cater to different economic, geographical, culture and religious beliefs and come to fruition, FULCRUM’s reporting notes, remains to be tested.
| SG4 element | Detail | Federal control |
|---|---|---|
| States | Kedah, Kelantan, Terengganu, Perlis | Constitution, fiscal and regulatory power in Putrajaya |
| Scope | 5.7 million people, 38,000 sq km | National industrial roadmaps |
| Revenue sharing | Each of the SG4 states owns 25% of the company; REE revenue split equally | State borrowing needs federal approval |
The rare earth bottleneck
The states control land, natural resources and exploratory mining licenses for REE extraction. Putrajaya controls export and import licenses, environmental regulation and national industrial roadmaps — a split that could stalemate what could potentially be the largest revenue source for SG4.
Under fresh guidelines, the federal government has loosened its prohibition on sending unprocessed REE overseas, allowing up to 100 metric tonnes to be shipped out for research and development, or alternatively on condition that a processing facility within Malaysia is established over a three-year period. The states were not consulted on this prior to its announcement, FULCRUM reported, citing an interview with Terengganu Strategic and Integrity Institute on 28 October 2026.
Potentially, these REE deposits could become a major income stream for SG4, as the elements are used in fields ranging from clean energy applications and consumer electronics to military hardware such as precision-guided missiles and radar.
Dr Ahmad Samsuri also suggested the Marang Terminal. Constructed to export processed silica, the private Terengganu facility also serves to bolster revenue streams from state royalties and government-linked company equity holdings.
A constitution written for cooperation
SG4 wants autonomy over lucrative resources and more independent economic policymaking; constitutional, fiscal and regulatory control resides in Putrajaya. Rather than being left to the federal government’s political calculations, states should be at liberty to choose which infrastructure development projects to pursue.
The 1956 Reid Commission that drafted Malaya’s independence constitution said that close co-operation between the States and the Federation would “promote the interests of all concerned and be of great benefit to the nation”. Unfortunately, the Commission stopped short of specifying such co-operation in the Constitution.
“Cooperation between federal and state government” was essential, said Dr Ahmad Samsuri Mokhtar — and should PAS become part of the federal government after the 16th General Election, such cooperation would be strengthened within the federation.”
FULCRUM concludes that SG4’s proposals could lay the groundwork for more decentralised federalism in Malaysia, which Putrajaya could consider incorporating immediately — especially since there is no certainty that any one coalition will win.
In the period before GE16, Putrajaya and SG4 could start building a formal resource revenue-sharing arrangement and decentralised economic policymaking that go beyond the platforms now on offer, failing which the “sleeping giant” will remain in slumber, constrained by Malaysia’s highly centralised federation.