A noncompete Anaplan’s parent company signed looked airtight on paper — but the state’s highest court ruled on Tuesday that it never bound the employee at all.
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court held in Anaplan Parent, LP and Anaplan, Inc. v. Timothy Brennan that a noncompete bearing a parent company’s signature, but not the actual employer’s, fails the Massachusetts Noncompetition Agreement Act’s demand that the agreement be “signed by both the employer and employee.” Holland & Knight, whose labor and employment group followed the case from the trial court through oral argument, reported the decision on November 17, 2026.
So a document worth real equity — limited partnership interests in Anaplan Parent LP, exchanged for restrictive covenants — collapsed on a single missing signature line. The SJC affirmed the Superior Court’s denial of a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction, clearing Brennan to work for a competitor he planned to join after leaving the Anaplan subsidiary in 2025.
“[W]e conclude that it does not,” the court wrote, answering its own framing of whether a parent’s signature satisfies the statute. The ruling turns on a mechanical letter count most employers never think to audit: whose name sits at the bottom.
A Parent Company Is Not an Employer
Timothy Brennan worked for Anaplan Inc., a subsidiary. Through three equity incentive agreements, he received partnership interests in Anaplan Parent LP — the parent — in exchange for covenants including the noncompete. The parent signed each agreement and named the subsidiary as a third-party beneficiary. The subsidiary never signed.
That structure is common in private companies, where equity lives at the holding-company level while the job does not. The SJC read the MNAA’s definitions and concluded that “an ’employer’ under the [Act] is, at a minimum, an entity for which an individual performs any service” — and that “a parent is not ordinarily the employer of its subsidiary’s employees.”
Brennan performed services only for the subsidiary, and the parent never claimed to be his joint employer. According to the record the court described, the parent did not hire or fire him, did not supervise him, did not set or pay his salary, and did not maintain his employment records.
The parent argued instead that its “active role” in the subsidiary — a joint-venture theory — should let it enforce the covenant. The court countered that “the record does not support that the parent entered into a joint venture with the subsidiary as pertains to Brennan.”
Then came the sentence that will follow corporate lawyers back to their filing cabinets: “Having taken advantage of the benefits of this separateness, they may not disavow that form when it is to their advantage,” the SJC wrote of the parent and subsidiary.
The Companies’ Fallback Fails Too
The companies tried one more route: if the parent was not Brennan’s employer, then the noncompete sat “outside of an employment relationship” — a category the MNAA explicitly excludes — so the statute’s signature rule would not bind them. The court disagreed.
A noncompete “does not fall ‘outside’ the employment relationship simply because the employer failed to sign the agreement,” the SJC said, stressing that the agreements themselves acknowledged Brennan entered the covenants “[i]n connection with his employment with” the subsidiary.
The court also noted the agreements ran to the subsidiary’s benefit: the noncompete protected it, it was named as a third-party beneficiary, and Brennan traded his promise for equity — consideration flowing from the employment relationship.
Under the MNAA’s definition, that made the agreement one “arising out of an … employment relationship,” squarely inside the statute. The missing signature, in other words, could not be explained away by pretending the law never applied.
Why the gap between the two signatures mattered
The statute demands strict compliance, and this case shows what that means: every minimum requirement must be met, or the covenant is void. Equity awards drafted at the parent level — with the employing entity listed only as a beneficiary — are now unenforceable in Massachusetts courts on their face.
What Employers Reviewing Award Agreements Must Fix
The practical fallout is immediate for any company with Massachusetts employees whose restrictive covenants live in parent-level award agreements. Holland & Knight’s alert, published with the ruling, laid out the corrective steps:
- Confirm the employing entity — not the parent — is a signatory to every noncompete covering a Massachusetts employee.
- If a new agreement must be signed mid-employment, comply with the MNAA’s requirements for those: consideration that is fair and reasonable independent of continued employment, and notice at least 10 business days before the agreement takes effect.
- Consider tools outside the MNAA’s reach — nonsolicitation agreements covering clients and employees, plus nondisclosure and confidentiality agreements — which remain enforceable and protect trade secrets, confidential information and client goodwill.
None of that restores the covenant Anaplan lost. Brennan walks to his competitor, and the equity he accepted came with a restriction the court refuses to enforce.
For employers who assumed a signature is a signature, the SJC offered a plain lesson in corporate form: the company that employs the worker must put its own name on the page.