Voters in Clay and Charles Mix counties rejected half-percent sales taxes meant to lower homeowners’ property taxes in special elections on Tuesday.
That makes the new option 0-for-4 when it reaches South Dakota county voters, News From The States reported. Brown and Codington counties voted the taxes down on Nov. 3. At least seven of the state’s 66 counties, meanwhile, have adopted one without a public vote or a referendum.
“My plan to cut property taxes empowers South Dakotans to choose what works best for their county,” Rhoden said. “And people in different counties will make different choices — that’s why we left all options open to refer and initiate these measures.”
The votes land in the first year state law has allowed counties to levy their own sales taxes, and the results split the state in two: everywhere the question has gone to a ballot, it has lost. Everywhere commissions have decided alone, it has passed.
Seven votes decide Charles Mix
Charles Mix County came down to the wire. Unofficial returns showed 656 votes against the tax and 649 in favor — a margin of seven votes, News From The States reported. KELOLAND reported the unofficial tally, including provisional ballots, was posted at 11 a.m. Wednesday.
Clay County, home to county seat Vermillion, was never close. Nearly 58% of voters opposed the tax there, and KELOLAND put the raw margin at 357 votes. In Charles Mix, where Lake Andes is the county seat, 50.2% opposed it.

Turnout was thin in both places. The counties’ auditors reported 27.5% turnout in Clay and 22.5% in Charles Mix, according to News From The States.
The elections happened this week rather than on Nov. 3 because the general election ballots were already printed by the time petitioners turned in signatures to force the referendums, News From The States reported.
One question hangs over Charles Mix: whether the seven-vote margin triggers a recount. The county auditor did not return a message from South Dakota Searchlight seeking an answer. Commissioners are scheduled to canvass the results at their Thursday meeting.
Four ballots, four rejections
The tax’s ballot-box record is now unblemished only in the losing sense. Under Senate Bill 96, passed in this year’s legislative session, counties may levy up to a half-percent sales tax — the first time in state history they have held that authority — with the proceeds credited against owner-occupied property tax bills.
Statewide relief is coming regardless. Lawmakers and Rhoden also directed proceeds from next year’s state sales tax increase, from 4.2% to 4.5%, toward lowering homeowners’ property taxes across South Dakota.

| County | Election day | Voted against | Reported turnout |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brown | Nov. 3 | 56% | not reported |
| Clay | Tuesday | nearly 58% | 27.5% |
| Charles Mix | Tuesday | 50.2% | 22.5% |
The Brown and Codington rejections on Nov. 3 set the pattern, the Black Hills Pioneer reported. Brown County commissioners chose to put the tax on the ballot; Codington County residents gathered petition signatures to force theirs. Unofficial results from the Secretary of State’s Office showed 56% opposition in Brown and 60% in Codington.
Where commissions skipped the vote
News From The States counts at least seven counties that adopted the tax without sending it to voters or facing a referendum: Custer, Hughes, Lawrence, Lincoln, Meade, Pennington and Fall River. KELOLAND’s list runs six, leaving out Hughes — a discrepancy between the two outlets’ counts.
Minnehaha, the state’s most populous county, has not proposed adopting the tax, KELOLAND reported. Under Codified Law 10-52B-10, counties may establish or adjust their rates on Jan. 1 or July 1 of each year, with the money applied as a credit on owner-occupied property tax bills.
‘Voting with their pocketbook’
Shelly Alvine, a Codington County resident who helped lead the petition drive there, called the result a “nice outcome” and told the Black Hills Pioneer voters were voting with their pocketbook as inflation strains household budgets. She called the rejection “decisive.”

Her sharpest point was about who pays and who benefits. Renters would not have seen lower property tax bills while paying higher sales taxes, she told the Black Hills Pioneer.
Alvine said that if you could look a person in the eye and ask them for $50 to pay for your property tax, that’s what you’re asking them to do with this sales tax.
Alvine added that she thinks the results should give other counties reason to pause before pursuing their own sales taxes. Alvine said that she thinks that’s a good reason for the Legislature, before passing off their decisions on South Dakotans and the counties, to look for other ways to make property tax relief more equitable.
Whether the Charles Mix margin survives the official canvass — and whether a recount follows — should become clear when commissioners meet Thursday.