Tarik Skubal’s projected $410 million deal looms over a 2026-27 MLB free agent class that Sports Illustrated forecasts will produce just six contracts of $100 million or more — down from an average of 7.4 per year over the previous five winters.
That scarcity is pushing front offices toward four undervalued names: Kris Bubic, Pete Fairbanks, Nathaniel Lowe and Patrick Sandoval.
The math behind this market is stark. SI’s Big Board, compiled by Will Laws and the report’s author, anticipates only 15 deals topping $50 million this offseason. The previous five classes produced 37 contracts of at least $100 million and 77 deals of $50 million or more, per the figures reported by Sports Illustrated. Only Skubal ($410 million) and Seiya Suzuki ($115 million) are projected to clear $105 million.
But the tape tells a different story than the class’s weak reputation. A thin market at the top doesn’t mean thin value at the middle — it means clubs with disciplined budgets can land impact production at non-luxury prices.
The downside case is already visible: Dustin May’s 4.82 ERA over the past two seasons still netted him a three-year, $52.5 million deal from the White Sox, SI reported, because scarcity inflates even middling arms.
Bubic, Fairbanks, Lowe offer fantasy value at low cost
- Bubic carries starter upside at reliever risk pricing — his 2.94 ERA across the last two injury-shortened seasons ranked 16th among pitchers with at least 170 innings, per SI, ahead of Nathan Eovaldi, Garrett Crochet and Chase Burns.
- Fairbanks is a classic buy-low reliever — his 123 Stuff+ ranked seventh among relievers with at least 40 innings in 2026, per SI, despite a 6.31 ERA in Miami.
- Lowe is the cheapest bounce-back bat on the board — his 74.4 mph average bat speed sits in the 77th percentile among all hitters.
Kris Bubic: elite per-inning, uncertain workload
Bubic, 29, finally broke through in 2025, posting a 2.48 ERA through 18 first-half starts to earn an All-Star nod before a rotator cuff injury ended his season. Elbow and shoulder trouble limited him to 55 innings across his Royals and Dodgers stints, though he finished healthy and pitched out of the bullpen for Los Angeles in the playoffs.
Here is what the analytics missed in the injury headline: the left-hander doesn’t overpower anyone — his fastball sits at 92 mph — but he neutralizes right-handed hitters with an elite changeup and attacks lefties with a sweeper generating whiffs at a 30% clip, SI reported.
On a per-inning basis, few starters on the open market match his ceiling. The open question is volume: whether his new club can expect a starter’s workload, or whether he settles into a multi-inning relief role.

Pete Fairbanks: the stuff never left
Fairbanks, 33, signed the sixth-biggest AAV for a reliever a year ago — $13 million on a one-year deal with the Marlins — then posted a 6.31 ERA in 46 appearances. His expanded cutter missed bats at a 34.9% whiff rate but got hit hard and he couldn’t command it, per SI.
The underlying profile argues for regression, in the good direction. His strikeout rate still sat at 31.1%, and his groundball rate collapsed to a bizarre 24.0% after a career mark of 45.5%. From 2020-25, Fairbanks put up a 2.87 ERA and 30.2% strikeout rate, and SI’s analysis argues a simplified plan that scraps the cutter should restore that pitcher.
Nathaniel Lowe: bat speed is back
Lowe, 31, was a model of durability from 2021-24, averaging 644 plate appearances and 2.7 fWAR per season with a 124 wRC+ — ninth among qualified first basemen, wedged between Pete Alonso (128) and Josh Naylor (117). Then production cratered in 2025 at .228/.307/.381, and he’s since cycled through four teams in two years.

The rebound evidence is in the batted-ball data. This season he added nearly two full ticks of bat speed to average 74.4 mph per swing, posting a .191 ISO — his best since becoming an everyday player — with a 107 wRC+ and 17 homers in 126 games, SI reported.
His zone swing-minus-chase rate dipped to 38.1% but stayed above the 35.0% league average. For a club with at-bats to spare at first base or DH, he profiles as a strong-side platoon piece at a price every team can afford.
Patrick Sandoval: same pitcher, two years later
Sandoval, 30, needed just over two years to return from 2024 Tommy John surgery, and the numbers say he came back essentially identical. Pre-surgery 2024: 5.08 ERA, 3.87 FIP in 79⅔ innings. His 2026 return: 5.12 ERA, 3.77 FIP in 70⅓ innings, with his changeup still generating a whiff rate just shy of 40%, per coverage citing SI’s report.
Across the three seasons before surgery, he logged a 3.53 ERA and 22.6% strikeout rate over 380⅓ innings. SI frames the realistic outcome as roughly 120 innings at an ERA in the low 4.00s on a modest one-year deal — solid production for a pitching-hungry club willing to trust its development infrastructure.
Where the market disagreement sits
The outlets covering this story diverge on scope. Yahoo Sports and Miami Sportswire extended the bargain framing to Trevor Rogers, noting the 29-year-old southpaw threw a career-high 169⅔ innings with 157 strikeouts in 2026, and citing former GM Jim Bowden’s forecast of a three-year deal near $64 million, with the Cubs, Padres and Astros flagged as fits.
SI’s own list of four does not include Rogers, whose projected price arguably takes him out of true bargain territory. That distinction matters: a bargain is a player the market undervalues, not merely one who costs less than a superstar.
| Player | Key 2026-27 indicator | Risk flag |
|---|---|---|
| Kris Bubic | 2.94 ERA over two seasons (16th among 170+ IP pitchers) | Rotator cuff; 55 IP in 2026 |
| Nathaniel Lowe | 74.4 mph avg bat speed (77th percentile) | .228/.307/.381 in 2025 |
The front-office logic ties back to the luxury tax and roster construction: with only six $100 million deals forecast league-wide, clubs outside the biggest spenders can compete for a wider slice of this class than in a normal market. The previous five winters saw 12 contracts of at least $200 million; aside from Skubal, no one in this class is expected to come close, per Yahoo Sports’ summary of the SI analysis.
The last five free agency classes produced 37 contracts of at least $100 million — an average of 7.4 per year — and this winter’s forecast sits well below it.
Fairbanks arrived in the majors the hard way: a ninth-round pick, 258th overall, by the Rangers in the 2015 draft out of the University of Missouri, he debuted for Texas in 2019 and was traded to the Rays for Nick Solak before that season ended.
His peak in Tampa included closing out Game 7 of the Championship Series against the Astros to send the Rays to the American League pennant, and a 2022 season in which he converted all eight of his save opportunities with a 1.13 ERA.
He was also part of a combined no-hit of the Cleveland Indians in 2021 — a feat that went unrecorded as an official no-hitter because it came in a seven-inning doubleheader game.
Disclaimer: The fantasy and market insights provided are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute financial or betting advice.