In a column for The Daily Northwestern, student critic Eliza Martin argues this week that the Grammy nominations are “fundamentally an imperfect system,” caught between rewarding chart dominance and rewarding genuinely innovative work — and she is not expecting to be happy with the results.
Martin laid out that case in “Record Scratch,” her music column for The Daily Northwestern, and expanded on it in a Wednesday conversation with Ivy Frater and Josie Belfer on the outlet’s opinion podcast, Who Asked You. The nominations had just dropped when the three sat down, and the internet, as Belfer put it, was already treating them as “the source of some discussion and maybe even some drama.”
Here’s why a campus podcast matters to the wider conversation: the Grammy debate Martin is having is one that has drawn ongoing discussion and criticism in recent years.
Grammys criticized for chart vs. critical bias, Martin names snubs and picks
- Martin argues the Grammys oscillate between chart hits and critical darlings, and get attacked either way.
- She calls out snubs to Harry Styles and Noah Kahan, and says Taylor Swift’s latest album didn’t meet the bar.
- Her picks for recognition: Phoebe Bridgers, Slayyyter, Rosalía and Raye.
Popularity or acclaim, never both
Martin’s core argument, as she told Frater and Belfer, is that there is “no real way” to decide which song, artist or album was the best of a given year, because the question is too subjective. What the Grammys can control is which yardstick they reach for, and she says they keep switching between them.
“With the Grammys, they go back and forth from picking albums or artists that were the most popular and really dominated the charts, versus picking more critically acclaimed, innovative work,” Martin said on the podcast. “And either way, they get a lot of criticism for it.”
She pointed to two cases that prove her point from opposite directions. Taylor Swift winning Album of the Year over Kendrick Lamar drew backlash because, in her view, his album was the more politically innovative work. Then Jon Batiste won the same category, and the reaction she heard was simpler: “I have no idea who this is.”
“There’s no real winning,” Martin said, “and I am to expect that I’ll be frustrated with at least some of the results.”
The snubs she can’t get over
Martin told the podcast she was surprised Harry Styles wasn’t nominated at all, given that his last album, “Harry’s House,” won Album of the Year in 2023. She was equally surprised that Noah Kahan missed the Album of the Year field for “The Great Divide.”
She thinks there was room for at least one of them. “Taylor Swift’s album was terrible this year, but that’s just my personal take,” Martin said — the kind of line that would get a critic in trouble anywhere, delivered with the shrug of someone who knows it’s an opinion column and owns it.
| Case the column cites | What happened | Martin’s read |
|---|---|---|
| Taylor Swift over Kendrick Lamar | Swift won Album of the Year | Lamar’s album was more politically groundbreaking |
| Jon Batiste | Won Album of the Year | Many listeners didn’t know who he was |
| Harry Styles | Won for “Harry’s House” in 2023; no nomination this cycle | The snub surprised her |
| Noah Kahan | “The Great Divide” missed Album of the Year | Also a surprising snub |
Why Swift keeps showing up
Frater, a self-described former big Taylor Swift fan who says she did not like the most recent albums, put the uncomfortable question directly: is Swift nominated because she’s Taylor Swift? Will she ever release an album that isn’t?
Martin’s answer is more careful than her “terrible” verdict. The album may have disappointed her, she said, but it did have real commercial success, and Swift’s huge fanbase “will listen to and defend anything she puts out.” That, in her view, lets the Grammys keep arguing the nomination is valid.
“I personally just did not think this album was to the standard of being considered for Album of the Year when she’s already won that several times before,” Martin said.
Who deserves the nod, in her telling
Her ideal winner, per the column, is Phoebe Bridgers — but she handicaps the odds honestly. Bridgers “hasn’t had enough time,” Martin said, and her music “isn’t really fit for chart-topping success” or built to appeal to all audiences.
Belfer brought one more name into the room: the Swiftologist, an online Swift commentator who, she noted, is “actually sometimes very critical” of the new album. Martin said her own reference points are more old-school — she checks reviews at Rolling Stone and Pitchfork before writing her own Liner Notes reviews for The Daily, and picks up picks from fellow DJs on the college station where she volunteers.
Martin is a Medill sophomore at Northwestern and the author of “Record Scratch,” her music column for The Daily Northwestern. She also hosts a radio show on the college station where she volunteers. Her connection to one of the artists at the center of the Grammy debate runs deep: Harry Styles has been her most streamed artist on Spotify every year since 2022, the year his album “Harry’s House” was released.
The Grammys won’t announce winners until the ceremony, and the backlash cycle will run on schedule between now and then. Martin, for one, has already set her expectations: “I am to expect that I’ll be frustrated with at least some of the results.”