Study Finds Dropped Degree Rules Yield $4,600 Gain

Workers without four-year college degrees hired into jobs that dropped degree requirements earn approximately $4,600 more annually than comparable peers in roles that never required a degree, according to a study published in Nature Human Behaviour.

The research examines the impact of human resources interventions aimed at skills-based hiring. Investigators from the University of Kentucky, the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology analyzed online job postings from Lightcast and U.S. Census Bureau employment records covering approximately 446,500 job starts between 2011 and 2021.

Over the decade examined in the data, employers reduced the share of postings requiring a degree by more than 10 percent. Workers without four-year degrees who secured these newly opened roles earned 12 log points more than matched workers taking jobs that had never demanded a degree.

The authors report this difference as a coefficient of 0.124 with a 95 percent confidence interval of 0.042 to 0.206, which translates to roughly US$4,600 per year. This earnings premium persisted for at least five years after the job switch.

The data also indicate a shift in who fills these positions. Workers hired after employers dropped degree requirements were more likely to be Black, Hispanic, or women compared to the workers they replaced. Removing degree requirements reduces labor costs for firms, giving employers an operational incentive to edit their job listings beyond social mobility goals.

Despite the wage gains and demographic shifts observed in the study, the Science reporting notes a substantial gap between editing a job posting and altering actual recruitment outcomes.

“Matching job postings to 446,500 job starts in U.S. administrative data from 2011 to 2021, we show that employers reduced the share of postings requiring a degree by more than 10%,” wrote Thomas Lyttelton, Dylan K. Nelson, and Nathan Wilmers in their paper.

Most organizations that dropped degree requirements from their listings did not hire non-college workers into the affected positions at scale. Across firms that decredentialed, non-college hiring rose by only 1.2 percentage points, with a 95 percent confidence interval of 0.5 to 2.0 percentage points.

Study Finds Dropped Degree Rules Yield $4,600 Gain
Photo: scienmag.com

“Employers also benefit, as removing degree requirements reduces labor costs,” wrote Lyttelton, Nelson, and Wilmers. “Yet most employers that drop requirements do not hire non-college workers (non-college hiring rises 1.2 percentage points; 95% confidence interval, (0.5, 2.0)). Decredentialing is a promising tool for social mobility, but only when employers follow through.”

The requirements set by human resources professionals greatly influence professional opportunities for different demographic segments. When prominent employers remove bachelor’s degree requirements from job descriptions, applicants who lack four-year degrees encounter opportunities that yield substantial financial gains compared to roles where such credentials were never mandated. This practice places greater emphasis on applicant capabilities and practical experiences rather than strict academic backgrounds.

The University of Kentucky, founded in 1865 as the Agricultural and Mechanical College of Kentucky under the Morrill Land-Grant Act, serves as the state’s largest public research university with 35,952 students enrolled in fall 2024. Classified among institutions with very high research activity, it spent $476.5 million on research and development in 2022.

Researchers analyzed administrative data to determine whether modifying qualification criteria altered hiring volumes or starting compensation figures. The investigation tracked employment records across multiple sectors to evaluate the long-term trajectory of individuals securing these revised positions.

The findings indicate that while editing job listings can serve as a valuable mechanism for economic advancement, the failure of many corporations to actually recruit non-college applicants into the modified roles dampens broader optimism about the scale of reform.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Grand Theft Auto VI Generated 3.790 Billion Dollars on Its Opening Day