Heart disease accounts for a quarter of all deaths in the UK, yet a study published this week in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology reveals that standard dietary advice regarding saturated fat and cholesterol may only apply to a minority of women.
The research, highlighted in this week’s newsletter from The i Paper, re-examines the cornerstone of healthy eating advice across nearly all countries. For decades, public health guidelines have said that saturated fat drives up low-density lipoprotein—often known as bad cholesterol—which builds fatty plaques in arteries and leads to cardiovascular events.
However, Clare Wilson reported in The i Paper that this correlation between dietary saturated fat and heart attacks fails to hold for three-quarters of women. Researchers analysed data from the Women’s Health Initiative, a massive US study that began in the 1990s, by sequencing the genes of about 20,000 participants to categorize their genetic predisposition to high cholesterol.
For the one-quarter of women with a high genetic predisposition, the standard medical advice proved accurate: eating more saturated fat correlated with an increased incidence of heart attacks. Yet for the remaining three-quarters with low or medium genetic predisposition, researchers found no correlation between saturated fat intake and cardiovascular events.

Explains Shift from Dietary Cholesterol to Saturated Fat
Medical understanding of cholesterol has evolved significantly since the 1960s, when health authorities began warning the public to avoid foods high in cholesterol such as eggs, red meat, and shellfish. Physicians now understand that dietary cholesterol is not a toxin; the body uses it as a vital building block for cell membranes and hormones, and the liver simply manufactures more cholesterol if dietary intake drops.
Instead, medical consensus points to saturated fat as the primary dietary trigger for the liver to produce excess low-density lipoprotein particles. These particles form the fatty plaques that narrow blood vessels over years. When unstable plaques rupture, they cause blood clots that restrict blood flow to the brain or heart.
Despite these established mechanisms, the new findings suggest that blanket dietary restrictions on saturated fat might be overly dogmatic, at least for women. Dr. Shoa Clarke, a cardiologist at Stanford Medicine and lead researcher of the study, urged caution regarding immediate lifestyle changes.
“For one, this is the first time an analysis like this has been done – the genetic equations were only developed in 2021,” Dr. Clarke told i Newspaper, adding that the results require confirmation in independent cohorts and that similar large-scale genetic studies have not yet been conducted in men.

In Plain English: The Clinical Takeaway
- Low-density lipoprotein (LDL): Often termed “bad cholesterol,” these fatty particles transport lipids through the bloodstream and promote dangerous arterial plaque accumulation when present in excess.
- Genetic predisposition: Inherited variations in DNA that influence how an individual’s metabolism processes dietary fats and regulates blood lipid levels.
- Plaque inflammation: A critical pathological process where arterial blockages become unstable and prone to rupturing, which triggers acute blood clots leading to heart attacks and strokes.
Experts also emphasize that saturated fat carries health implications independent of cardiac risk. Red meat and full-fat dairy products remain calorific, meaning excess consumption can cause weight gain, negatively impact liver health, and elevate the risk of developing type 2 diabetes. “There are other negative health effects of red meats, even independent of the saturated fat,” Dr. Clarke told i Newspaper.
Advises Medical Consultation Before Dietary Changes
Individuals looking to modify their dietary intake or evaluate their cardiovascular risk factors should consult a qualified physician or registered cardiologist before making significant changes to their nutrition.
The Journal of the American College of Cardiology, founded in 1983, serves as the flagship publication of the American College of Cardiology and maintains a family of eight specialty journals spanning imaging, interventions, heart failure, and electrophysiology. According to Journal Citation Reports, it recorded a 2024 impact factor of 22.3, placing it among the most frequently cited titles in cardiovascular medicine.
Ongoing medical investigations increasingly focus on plaque inflammation—the danger of deposits bursting rather than merely clogging blood vessels like limescale—with specialists exploring targeted therapies including off-label anti-inflammatory treatments.
References
- The study was published in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology.
- AI-powered Thermal Imaging Tool May Predict Diabetic Foot Ulcer Healing – Hospital + Healthcare
- Hackers Target Blood Plasma Cold Storage in Cyberattack, Alarms Prevent Loss
- ChatGPT Assisted Teen in Tumbler Ridge Attack, Mother Jones Reports (world-today-news.com)
- Study Finds Retatrutide Reduces Knee Pain (time.news)