Supreme Court Takes Up Goldman Sachs Case on Arbitration and Bankruptcy Stay

The Supreme Court added a major dispute to its oral argument docket for the 2026-27 term, agreeing to decide whether bankruptcy courts can override the Federal Arbitration Act. The case involves allegations that Goldman Sachs Bank continued debt collection efforts against debtors who had filed for bankruptcy.

Supreme Court Takes Up Arbitration Dispute

The legal battle stems from a filing by Rhea Brown and Gregory Maze, who listed credit card debts with Goldman Sachs Bank after filing for bankruptcy three years ago, scotusblog.com reported. According to the debtors, the bank repeatedly attempted to collect payments by email and telephone despite receiving multiple notices of the bankruptcy.

The two debtors initiated an adversary proceeding by filing a separate lawsuit within their broader bankruptcy case. They argued that the bank willfully violated the automatic stay, which halts all collection efforts against prebankruptcy debts.

Lower Courts Block Arbitration Request

Pointing to an arbitration clause in the credit card agreements, Goldman Sachs asked the bankruptcy court to put the adversary proceeding on hold and force the debtors into arbitration. The bankruptcy court denied that request, a decision subsequently upheld by the federal district court and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit, scotusblog.com reported.

A divided three-judge panel of the 4th Circuit ruled that requiring Brown and Maze to arbitrate their claim “would interfere and conflict with the strong and established policies and purposes of the Bankruptcy Code.”

Large financial institutions should have procedures in place to stop collection activity immediately upon a bankruptcy filing, Credit Slips reported.

Practical Stakes for Consumer Credit

Goldman Sachs petitioned the Supreme Court to review the case, arguing that the 4th Circuit’s ruling sharply conflicted with a decision from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit, scotusblog.com reported.

The bank warned the justices that “[t]he practical stakes of these issues are enormous” because arbitration clauses are ubiquitous in consumer credit agreements, and the 4th Circuit decision “imperils the enforceability of arbitration agreements in many of them.”

Following consideration at four consecutive conferences, the justices granted the petition for review. The case will likely receive oral arguments next year, with a final decision expected by late June or early July.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Kylie Jenner Relists Holmby Hills Estate for $38.495M, TMZ Says