Surgeon Calls for Criminal Investigation into Aberdeen Hospital After 19 Avoidable Surgical Deaths

A whistleblower surgeon is calling for a police investigation into Aberdeen Royal Infirmary after an expert review confirmed at least 19 patients died from avoidable surgical complications between 2015 and 2021, while the health board’s death rate in liver and pancreatic surgery ran as high as 18% — roughly six times the national average of 2-3%.

The call came from Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant at the hospital, who told the Guardian he had repeatedly raised concerns about the liver and pancreatic surgery unit from 2021 onwards and believed dozens of patients may have died unnecessarily there. He is asking Police Scotland to investigate corporate homicide at the hospital, alleging that senior officials at NHS Grampian — the health board that runs it — failed to act quickly enough.

What makes the disclosure explosive is the gap between what was known and what was done. NHS Grampian commissioned an expert review in 2022, and it confirmed Habib’s allegations. Yet the unit kept operating. Only in March 2026, after a further external expert told hospital executives that its “persistent high mortality in complex surgery is a red-flag indicator of systemic failure”, was liver and pancreatic surgery shut down.

Surgeon Calls for Criminal Investigation into Aberdeen Hospital After 19 Avoidable Surgical Deaths
Photo: aol.co.uk

“In every other death at the hands of the state, families would be entitled to understand the circumstances of their loved ones’ death. [They] deserve to know how and why their loved one died,” Habib said.

Liver and Pancreatic Surgery Death Rate Far Exceeds Benchmark

  • Liver and pancreatic surgery — known clinically as hepatobiliary and pancreatic surgery — is among the highest-risk specialities in medicine, but a death rate of 18% sits far above the 2-3% national benchmark for such operations.
  • The unit at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary has now been closed, and the health board is under external review, so patients currently face no continuing exposure from this specific service.
  • Families who lost relatives after surgery there between 2015 and 2021 may still not know whether those deaths were reviewed; the duty of candour process, which obliges the NHS to tell patients and families directly when care failures are found, is what NHS Grampian says it is following.

Six Times the Benchmark: What the 2022 Review Found

The review was carried out by two external experts — surgery professors at Edinburgh and Leeds universities — and concluded that the death rate at Aberdeen between 2017 and 2020 ran as high as 18% within liver and pancreatic surgery, against a national average of 2-3% for that speciality, depending on the patient’s condition. The report, described as internal, was published on Thursday by Habib’s solicitor, Aamer Anwar.

Based on those 2022 fatality calculations, Habib said dozens of patients may have died unnecessarily. He also flagged four further patients who died during or after surgery after the expert report was completed.

Aberdeen Hospital: Surgeon Demands Police Probe After 19 Deaths — Buzz Blitz News

The contrast between the two figures is the clinical heart of the story. In complex hepatobiliary surgery, mortality of 2-3% reflects the inherent danger of operating on the liver, pancreas and biliary tract — organs with dense blood supply and high complication risk. An 18% rate, sustained across three years, is what the March 2026 external expert called a red-flag indicator of systemic failure rather than surgical risk alone.

Measure Aberdeen Royal Infirmary National average
Death rate, liver and pancreatic surgery (2017-2020) Up to 18% 2-3%
Confirmed deaths from serious adverse events (2015-2021) At least 19 —

Holyrood Divides Over a Criminal Inquiry

The findings were debated at Holyrood on Thursday. John Swinney, Scotland’s first minister, said Habib’s disclosures were “of the gravest concern” and that the NHS had legal duties to give patients the best possible care and to investigate safety allegations quickly.

But he rebuffed demands from Michael Marra, the Scottish Labour leader, for a criminal investigation into “systemic failures” at NHS Grampian, arguing that recent demands for leadership change and urgent reforms should produce the necessary improvements.

Call for police to investigate scottish hospital after
Photo: khanlist.com

“The families of the 19 people who died deserve answers and deserve justice,” Marra said at first minister’s questions.

Anwar, the solicitor, went further than the first minister was prepared to go. He said the lord advocate, Ruth Charteris KC, should instruct her lawyers and Police Scotland to launch a criminal investigation, and that ministers should immediately place NHS Grampian into special measures.

“While the Grampian leadership was busy burying evidence behind complex medical jargon, they also failed to explain to bereaved families that their loved ones had died after the wrong operation,” Anwar said.

The Watchdog’s Count Doesn’t Match the Whistleblower’s

A report published last week by Healthcare Improvement Scotland, the NHS watchdog, found “very serious shortcomings with NHS Grampian’s leadership”, including failing to be transparent and accurate in its accounts of its actions, and identified “persistent, serious concerns about safety, quality, clinical governance and leadership”.

But that review identified only one patient death due to a serious adverse event — a figure at odds with the 19 deaths confirmed in the 2022 expert review, and the basis on which Habib and Anwar question whether the full extent of the crisis is being covered up.

Surgeon calls for corporate homicide probe over avoidable deaths at NHS Grampian — STV News

Last week, too, the Scottish health secretary, Angela Constance, told MSPs there were extremely serious systemic problems with mismanagement and underperformance at the board, which faces being placed into special measures if its reforms are not delivered quickly or effectively enough. The crisis has already shut paediatric surgery at Gray’s hospital and forced the replacement of the board’s chairperson and medical director.

Habib said he had repeatedly contacted the police, Scottish government ministers and Scotland’s independent whistleblowing officer, but was fobbed off or told the cases he raised were time-barred.

What the Health Board and Government Say

Laura Skaife-Knight, NHS Grampian’s chief executive, said a thorough investigation had already taken place, with some elements ongoing, and that where reviews identify issues around patient care, “the appropriate duty of candour processes are followed”. She added that if consideration of new evidence identifies further individuals who should be contacted, the board will do so, and that “patient safety remains our highest priority”.

A Scottish government spokesperson said ministers recognised the courage shown by the whistleblower, had repeatedly raised Habib’s concerns with Healthcare Improvement Scotland and NHS Grampian, and noted the board is now subject to “a very significant level of intervention and an unprecedented level of support”. Any criminal investigation, the spokesperson said, is a matter for Police Scotland — which has been approached for comment.

Patients Should Ask Board About Case Reviews

For patients in the Grampian region, the relevant questions are practical. Anyone who underwent liver or pancreatic surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary between 2015 and 2021, or who has a relative who died after such surgery there, may wish to ask the board directly whether their case was covered by the reviews and by duty of candour disclosure — the legal process requiring the NHS to communicate openly with patients and families when care falls short.

Patients referred for complex hepatobiliary surgery elsewhere in Scotland can ask their surgical team for the unit’s published outcomes and about centralisation of high-risk surgery, which the NHS uses to concentrate such operations in higher-volume centres. Anyone experiencing post-operative symptoms such as fever, worsening abdominal pain, jaundice or wound discharge should seek urgent medical attention regardless of where surgery took place.

The Question Still Open

The dispute now turns on two numbers that cannot both describe the same hospital: one death confirmed by the watchdog, 19 confirmed by the experts the board itself commissioned.

Swinney has declined a criminal inquiry and staked his position on leadership change and reform; Anwar has referred the matter to the lord advocate and Police Scotland. Police Scotland has been approached for comment and has not yet said whether it will investigate.

Aberdeen Royal Infirmary is the largest hospital in the Grampian area, a teaching hospital offering tertiary care for a population of over 600,000 across the north-east of Scotland. Its origins lie in a facility established at Woolmanhill in 1739, and it moved to its current Foresterhill site under the Aberdeen Joint Hospitals Scheme devised by the Scottish doctor Matthew Hay.

The hospital was officially opened by the Duke and Duchess of York on 23 September 1936 — King Edward VIII had been due to perform the ceremony but cancelled the visit and went instead to Ballater railway station to meet the American socialite Wallis Simpson off her train.

It joined the National Health Service in 1948, and in the 1980s a team led by the English physicist John Mallard built the world’s first whole-body MRI scanner there, used for diagnostic imaging between 1980 and 1983.

References

  • Expert review of liver and pancreatic surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, commissioned by NHS Grampian, 2022 (published November 2025 by Aamer Anwar, solicitor)
  • Scottish Parliament, first minister’s questions and health secretary statement, November 2025

Disclaimer: This article is journalistic coverage of an ongoing public health matter and is not medical advice. Allegations of corporate homicide remain untested in any court. For personal health concerns, consult a qualified clinician.

Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

9 Things to Know About Growing Up With Priest Brothers

ORF Ends 22-Year Collaboration With Director Axel Hoffmann Via Email