Five employees of the Hôpital du Valais will win an extra week of paid vacation next year in a lottery open only to staff who get the flu shot, a move that has already drawn criticism from unions and politicians this week.
The draw is tied to a vaccination campaign that opened Monday and runs through December 23.
Le Nouvelliste reported on Wednesday that the hospital launched the raffle to push vaccination rates among its staff, which management considers too low. Employees who have a medical contraindication to the vaccine can also enter, the hospital’s communications service said. The prizes are five additional weeks of paid leave for 2027, one for each winner.
The campaign covers all staff of the public institution and follows the recommendations of the Federal Office of Public Health, blue News reported. medinside detailed the split of the prizes: three winners will come from the Centre hospitalier du Valais romand, one from Haut-Valais, and one from the Institut central des hôpitaux, the Centre de services or the Direction générale.
Not everyone is playing along. Employees contacted by Le Nouvelliste described the lottery as “pitiful” and “scandalous,” and the SSP (Syndicat des services publics) Valais said the decision to get vaccinated must remain a free choice, according to Lematin.
“We consider it would be more adequate, more effective and more humane to grant additional resources or extra vacation days to employees worn out by their work and their schedules,” said Natalie D’aoust-Ribordy, SSP union secretary in Valais, in remarks to Le Nouvelliste cited by medinside.
Romano Amacker, president of the UDC in Haut-Valais, also rejected the idea. The lottery amounts to “unacceptable pressure” on employees, he told the Walliser Bote, adding that vaccination must remain a personal choice. The SCIV union, Le Nouvelliste reported, sees “a somewhat demagogic side to offering a gift for an effort that comes down to a personal choice.”
The stakes behind the raffle are numbers. The hospital says flu vaccination among its staff, as across Swiss health care institutions, sits below the 60 percent it considers desirable to limit the spread of the virus. Only 12 percent of its professionals were vaccinated in 2024, Le Nouvelliste reported, against 24 percent nationally that year.
The CHUV in Lausanne, which has offered free vaccination since November 2 under the cantonal campaign, also uses posters only. Its rate reached 30 percent last year, up from 22 percent in the two previous years.

| Institution | Flu vaccination rate | Period | Incentive |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hôpital du Valais | 12 percent | 2024 | Vacation lottery |
| Swiss health professionals (national) | 24 percent | 2024 | — |
| Geneva University Hospitals | About 30 percent | Last year | Poster campaign only |
| CHUV, Lausanne | 30 percent | Last year | Poster campaign only |
| Hospital’s target | 60 percent | — | — |
The communications service told Le Nouvelliste that “the draw takes nothing away from anyone” and instead “values a gesture of prevention.” It said it understands the legitimate debate the initiative has triggered.
The hospital has also signaled it will not treat the raffle as a fixed policy. Facing the criticism, it plans a review after the campaign ends, 20 Minutes reported, taking into account staff reactions and how the vaccination rate evolves. The draw itself cannot happen before the campaign closes on December 23.
The initiative appears isolated in Switzerland, 20 Minutes noted. Neither Geneva nor Lausanne has adopted anything comparable, leaving the Valais hospital’s experiment as the first test of whether a week of vacation can move a rate stuck at 12 percent.