Tarriela Refutes Zheng Zhihua’s Claim of Illegal Occupation of Ayungin Shoal

Manila Dialogue erupts into a pointed exchange over Ayungin Shoal, with a Philippine Coast Guard official directly refuting a Chinese academic’s territorial claim.

The confrontation shows the escalating tensions in the South China Sea, where a small Philippine outpost sits at the center of a brewing storm. Rear Adm. Jay Tarriela, spokesperson for the West Philippine Sea, confronted Zheng Zhihua of Shanghai Jiaotong University after Zheng stated China believes the Philippines has illegally occupied the shoal for more than 27 years and has shown restraint by only using water cannons.

“China think[s] the Philippines has occupied Second Thomas Shoal, [a] Chinese territory for more than 27 years. And China only use[s] water cannon[s] as a bigger power,” Zheng said at the forum.

RAdm. Jay Tarriela at Chinese academic nagkainitan sa isyu ng Ayungin Shoal — ABS-CBN News

Tarriela rejected the assertion immediately, stating the shoal lies within the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone. “I would just like to correct you in saying that China does not have any territorial jurisdiction whatsoever in Second Thomas Shoal,” he said. “The last time I checked, Second Thomas Shoal only has a distance of 125 nautical miles from the Philippines and it is in our exclusive economic zone.”

The Manila Showdown

The heated exchange on Monday was a microcosm of the broader geopolitical struggle playing out in the disputed waters. Zheng’s argument, which framed China’s use of water cannons as a measured response to Philippine “occupation,” was met with a swift and firm rebuttal from Tarriela, who grounded his counter-claim in geography and international law.

Tarriela Refutes Zheng Zhihua's Claim of Illegal Occupation of Ayungin Shoal
Photo: ABS-CBN

Zheng pushed back further, questioning the Philippines’ selective use of its EEZ claims to assert sovereignty over the shoal. This legalistic back-and-forth highlighted the fundamental disagreement at the heart of the dispute: one side’s claim of historic sovereignty versus the other’s claim of maritime rights under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).

The vessel at the center of this dispute is the BRP Sierra Madre, a World War II-era warship deliberately grounded in 1999 to serve as a military outpost. A small detachment of Philippine Marines is stationed aboard the rusting hulk, which has become a powerful symbol of the nation’s resolve to maintain its presence in the area.

Heated exchange between Tarriela, Chinese rep over claim PH 'illegally occupying Ayungin Shoal' — ABS-CBN News

Beijing has consistently demanded the removal of the Sierra Madre, leading to frequent and tense confrontations during Philippine resupply missions. The Chinese Coast Guard and its maritime militia regularly use water cannons and blocking maneuvers to impede these voyages, actions that are central to Zheng’s argument of Chinese restraint.

A Precarious Peace and the Future at Stake

While the dialogue in Manila was marked by sharp rhetoric, National Security Adviser Eduardo Oban Jr. offered a more strategic perspective on the Philippines’ unique challenge. He said that the nation’s duty is not merely to preserve peace, but to ensure that this peace does not “surrender the future we seek to secure.”

“Our responsibility is not only to preserve peace in the South China Sea, but to ensure that the peace we preserve does not surrender the future we seek to secure,” Oban, who also chairs the National Task Force for the West Philippine Sea (NTF-WPS), said during the Manila Dialogue.

He warned that failure to respond to coercion encourages further encroachments, while responses that ignore the risk of escalation can invite wider confrontation.

Tarriela pumalag sa Chinese professor na sinabing sa China ang Ayungin Shoal — ABS-CBN News

Oban’s remarks, reported by the Philippine News Agency, framed the dilemma perfectly. A region can remain formally at peace, he noted, even as intimidation becomes routine. This "coercive peace" is the delicate balance Manila must maintain, a reality where the defense of sovereign rights must not become an "invitation to conflict."

This strategic balancing act requires looking beyond immediate crises. Oban urged a focus on the horizon of 2031, a timeframe long enough to move beyond daily confrontations but close enough to demand concrete decisions and measurable results. The path forward, he said, is not a single solution but a complex web of actions: diplomacy, defense, economic resilience, technology, international law, and security partnerships working in concert.

Invalidating China's Nine-Dash Line

Legal and historical context provides the bedrock for the Philippines’ position. In 2016, an arbitral tribunal in The Hague issued a landmark ruling that invalidated China’s nine-dash line and its historic claims to most of the South China Sea. The tribunal specifically ruled that Second Thomas Shoal, or Ayungin Shoal, is a low-tide elevation within the Philippines’ 200-nautical-mile EEZ and continental shelf.

The ruling is a cornerstone of Manila’s international legal strategy, yet it has not been accepted by Beijing, which refuses to recognize the tribunal’s jurisdiction.

This legal stalemate has created a de facto reality on the water. The Philippines maintains its presence on the Sierra Madre, a physical assertion of its rights under international law. China, meanwhile, asserts its own claims through a persistent, aggressive presence of its own coast guard and militia vessels, creating a constant low-level conflict that risks spiraling into a wider confrontation.

The situation remains a critical test of the international rules-based order. The Manila Dialogue, intended as a forum for advancing a free, open, and rules-based maritime order, instead revealed just how far apart the two sides remain. For now, the standoff at Ayungin Shoal continues, a lonely outpost in a vast and turbulent sea.

Photo of author

Alexandra Hartman Editor-in-Chief

Editor-in-Chief Prize-winning journalist with over 20 years of international news experience. Alexandra leads the editorial team, ensuring every story meets the highest standards of accuracy and journalistic integrity.

Hans Isaac Engaged to Former Miss Universe Malaysia Francisca Luhong

A Study of Over 830,000 Patients Published on November 6, 2026