On Sunday in Manila, Southeast Asian leaders and Chinese officials failed to finalize a long-negotiated code of conduct for the South China Sea, leaving key territorial disagreements unresolved.
Negotiators have reached a tentative agreement on roughly 80 percent of the draft text, but officials in the Philippines say divisions persist over whether the final maritime pact will be legally binding.
“There is no conclusion yet,” Theresa Lazaro told reporters at the ASEAN summit on Sunday, pointing out that various crucial matters remain unsettled, such as whether the code will carry legal weight.
“The ASEAN countries plus China have also different views on how things are,” Lazaro told reporters.
The Association of Southeast Asian Nations and Beijing have spent more than two decades working on the maritime code. Having assumed this year’s leadership of the 11-member bloc, the Philippines had previously committed to accelerating the negotiations and securing an agreement before the conclusion of the current year.
Lazaro said that she still hopes the negotiations could conclude under Singapore’s auspices when the city-state takes over as chair next year.
Regional governments want the framework to reflect international law, a standard that some member states accuse China of ignoring. China maintains that its actions have been lawful and professional.
Beijing claims sovereignty over the vast majority of the South China Sea, which overlaps with the maritime exclusive economic zones belonging to Vietnam, Brunei, Malaysia, Indonesia, and the Philippines. A functional code is essential to keeping tensions from escalating and managing maritime encounters.
Beijing refuses to recognize a 2016 international arbitration court ruling which concluded that its expansive territorial claims lack any legal foundation under global law.
Bilateral friction between Beijing and Manila has faced off in a series of maritime confrontations in recent years. Manila claims that Chinese vessels have continually carried out hostile acts within its maritime economic zone, such as engaging in risky navigation, deploying water cannons, and hindering logistics operations. China accuses the Philippines of intruding on its territory.
Tensions escalated after Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr took office in 2022, preceded by months of harsh words between the two countries over the sea ahead of this weekend’s meetings.
In a separate decision at the summit, ASEAN leaders extended a ban on Myanmar’s leader attending the bloc’s annual summits, citing the country’s failure to comply with a 2021 peace plan.