Texas claimed nine Rio Grande islands as state land in late October, setting off a diplomatic dispute over a border that Mexico considered settled by treaty more than 170 years ago.
Texas General Land Commissioner Dawn Buckingham announced that her office, after a request from U.S. Customs and Border Protection, had determined that the nine islands — roughly 66 acres in total — belonged to Texas. She said the “strategically located lands” would soon be “accessed, monitored, and protected” by state and federal authorities, as The Atlantic reported.
The announcement landed hard in Mexico City. President Claudia Sheinbaum addressed the claim at a press conference and suggested politics was behind it.
“They are in the midst of elections and are claiming that these islands are now part of Texas. But they are not.”
Why it matters now: the two countries had resolved river-border disputes for more than a century through the International Boundary and Water Commission. The last time Americans unilaterally claimed territory across the border, according to The Atlantic’s account, was in the 19th century. Now more than $1 million in freight crosses the border every minute.
A border that moved with the river
The islands exist because the Rio Grande moves. The 1848 Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo placed the border in “the middle of that river, following the deepest channel.” As the river shifted course, so did the line, periodically adding hundreds of acres to one country while eroding the other’s.
Those changes could take years to settle, but they were almost always handled amicably. The 1889 formation of the International Boundary Commission — later renamed the IBWC — gave both nations a standing mechanism for exactly this kind of problem. In the 1880s, the U.S. and Mexico had clashed over the ownership of 20-acre Beaver Island, just southeast of Roma, Texas; the commission was built to prevent a repeat.
Buckingham’s statement broke that pattern. The Atlantic characterized it as a unilateral land grab, and a Mexican official told the magazine that the old way of doing things had worked without interruption.
“The way we have resolved these issues over land has worked the same way for 137 years.”
Why the islands matter to Border Patrol
Several dozen islands dot the Rio Grande, and for years they have been a nuisance to U.S. agents. Smugglers and traffickers used them as waypoints.
On one island, fugitives from a Mexican prison who were armed took shelter; Mexican troops stormed a “narco camp” on a second; and a third was the site of a Border Patrol rescue of an 11-year-old girl from El Salvador. The land is covered in carrizo cane, which gave criminal spotters a hidden vantage point, and some used the islands to stash packages of cocaine.
Rudy Karisch, a former chief of the Border Patrol’s Rio Grande Valley sector, told The Atlantic his first instinct when he saw them was blunt: “Why can’t we dredge them out and get rid of them?” It has never been that simple.
Buckingham, a physician from Austin who took over the Texas General Land Office in 2023, said she received the CBP request in October 2025 to review 28 islands “whose ownership had not been definitively established.” She shared satellite imagery in late October that appeared to show nine of them north of the river’s midpoint. CBP declined to comment, and U.S. representatives on the IBWC declined as well, The Atlantic reported.
Buckingham’s announcement took Mexican members of the IBWC by surprise, one Mexican official told The Atlantic. U.S. representatives on the IBWC declined to comment. In her statement, Buckingham said that the islands would be open to law-enforcement agents for patrolling, inspection, and the removal of any illegal activity taking place there.
It’s unclear whether agents have already been dispatched. Should agents be deployed onto territory that does not formally belong to the United States, such a move might strengthen enforcement at the border, yet it could also run afoul of a treaty the two nations have honored for generations.
An unexpected claim
Here the story takes a turn. Buckingham went on to describe nine small, overgrown islands in the Rio Grande between the U.S. and Mexico, whose ownership, she wrote, had been “uncertain.”
After U.S. Customs and Border Protection reached out to her office, it concluded that Texas was the islands’ owner. Buckingham said that the strategically located lands would soon be accessed, monitored, and protected by state and federal authorities.
Mexican officials, still trying to manage the Trump administration’s periodic threats of an air strike, suddenly needed to address a question they thought had been settled before Abraham Lincoln took office: the borders of their own nation.
Puzzled diplomats turned to Mexico’s president, Claudia Sheinbaum, who took up the matter at a press conference and implied that the country to her nation’s north was engaging in political gamesmanship.
Washington stays quiet on the islands
The White House has not addressed the islands directly. Getting to the border islands from, say, Houston, you would need to drive south on U.S. 77 until you reach the Sarita checkpoint — a stretch of highway staffed by Border Patrol agents — which lies 85 miles above the Rio Grande.
At some point you would need to get through, or climb over, the border wall, which in many places stands hundreds of meters above the river. You would need to walk the arid no-man’s-land between the wall and the river. You would then need to take a short swim.
Mexican diplomats, meanwhile, are still weighing how to respond, as The Atlantic’s reporting makes plain. An ambassador stationed in Mexico City has voiced complaints about the numbers of people crossing the border while simultaneously touting the sealing of the border, most recently sharing on X a video of a calm stretch of the Rio Grande shot near the islands.
Buckingham, a Republican, is the first woman in Texas history to hold the Land Commissioner’s office, to which she was elected in November 2022 and sworn in on January 10, 2023. Before entering politics she worked as a surgeon, and she served six years as a state Senator representing a district stretching from the Austin suburbs to Abilene.
A seventh-generation Texan who grew up in League City before moving to Austin, she entered public office through local education boards, including a seat on the Lake Travis school board, before her 2016 Senate campaign, in which she cast herself as a political outsider and won a contentious Republican runoff with more than 60% of the vote.
What remains unknown is whether agents have already been dispatched to the islands, whether the federal government will back the claim, and how Mexico will answer.
The Atlantic reported that Buckingham’s announcement took Mexico’s IBWC members by surprise; neither CBP nor the U.S. section of the commission would comment. The question Mexico thought it had answered before Abraham Lincoln took office — the contours of its own nation — is open again.
Related reading
- Texas Supreme Court Sets Monday Deadline for Ericka Lomick Response
- Adhikari Credits PM for Metro Work; Modi Expected to Open Stretch Nov 21
- Putin Rules Out Ceasefire Talks With Ukraine After Kerch Bridge Strikes, Vows ‘Painful’ Response (world-today-journal.com)
- Tribunal Clears 450 McDonald’s Workers’ Claims, ‘Waiting for 18th Birthdays’ Culture Alleged (archyworldys.com)