Texas Says Execution Went as Planned; Witness Describes Screams and Tremendous Distress

“We feel that all of our processes and procedures were followed and that it was carried out as planned,” said Amanda Hernandez, a spokesperson for the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, defending the execution of 70-year-old Reinaldo Dennes on Thursday in Huntsville.

Rev. Jeff Hood, Dennes‘ spiritual adviser, described a radically different scene. With his hand on Dennes’ shoulder inside the death chamber, Hood said he felt like he was holding a bucking bronco as the inmate screamed in pain, pleaded for relief, and shouted that the procedure was not working.

“Twice he said, ‘It’s not working. It’s not working. It’s not going how it’s supposed to go. This isn’t right.’ Those types of words kept coming,” Hood told the Associated Press. He called what he witnessed torture.

The clash between the state’s account and the witness’s testimony marks the ninth execution in Texas this year and arrives amid intensifying scrutiny of lethal injection protocols nationwide. In September, Tennessee called off the execution of Christa Pike after two doses of pentobarbital failed to enter her bloodstream correctly, a case Hernandez suggested may have influenced Dennes’ behavior.

Texas Says Execution Went as Planned; Witness Describes Screams and Tremendous Distress
Photo: nine.com.au

Timeline reveals a prolonged struggle for IV access

Dennes was strapped to the gurney at 6:04 p.m. Initial attempts to place IV lines in his hands and arms failed, Hernandez said.

An IV was finally established in the left side of his neck at 6:20 p.m., followed by a second line in his left foot at 6:38 p.m., PBS reported. Witnesses entered the chamber before Dennes began his final statement at 6:52 p.m. The drugs started flowing less than a minute later.

Almost immediately, Dennes exclaimed: “The pain! Go! Go!” He uttered an expletive and implored “the father” to “take this pain.” He subsequently shouted: “My right leg is killing me!” and described it as a cramp.

After another profanity, he grunted, then said, “I don’t think this is normal. Take me, father. Don’t let me suffer like this. C’mon.” The drugs were stopped at 7:07 p.m., and he was declared dead a minute later — slightly more than an hour after he was restrained, CNN reported.

Texas Says Execution Went as Planned; Witness Describes Screams and Tremendous Distress
Photo: edition.cnn.com

State questions inmate’s credibility, cites prior complaints

Hernandez said the state plans no additional inquiry into Dennes’ claims of extreme pain. She said there were reasons to suspect he was exaggerating, noting he complained even before the lethal drugs were given and grumbled about pain in a leg that did not have an IV line.

“It makes you wonder” if the high-profile Pike case has influenced death row inmates to act out, Hernandez said. “They watch the news. He was aware of the other executions.”

Dr. Paul Wax, executive director of the American College of Medical Toxicology, said he could not think of any reason why an injection of pentobarbital into the left foot or left side of the neck would cause pain in the right leg.

Michael Graczyk, the Associated Press reporter who attended the execution, said witnesses could not see when the drug started to be administered; Dennes’ foot was covered by a sheet, and the IV in his neck was not visible from their position.

Pattern of IV difficulties spans multiple states

Texas is not alone in struggling to establish venous access. In May, Tennessee called off the lethal injection of Tony Carruthers after failing for over an hour to establish an IV line. Idaho, in 2024, tried eight times to establish a line to execute Thomas Creech before stopping, Nine News Australia reported. Republican Gov. Brad Little subsequently signed a law making a firing squad the primary method of execution in Idaho.

The Texas Department of Criminal Justice, which operates the nation’s largest prison system, traces its roots to an 1848 legislative act establishing a state penitentiary in Huntsville. The modern agency was created in 1989, consolidating three predecessor agencies under a nine-member board appointed by the governor.

A 1979 federal ruling in Ruiz v. Estelle found prison conditions unconstitutional, triggering sweeping reforms and a construction boom that nearly doubled the inmate population by the mid-1990s.

Dale Baich, an Arizona lawyer who has represented death row inmates and witnessed 17 U.S. executions, said the latest Texas lethal injection raises concerns. “Calling a prisoner’s screams an act is not a medical finding. It is an accusation, and the state should be required to produce evidence to support it,” Baich said.

Hood, the spiritual adviser, called assertions that Dennes was faking pain “disgusting.” “We have heard them say repeatedly since last night that this was not botched. That is absolutely, unbelievably absurd,” he said. Hernandez said the lethal drugs had not passed their expiration date, though she did not know the date.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Carriers and Retailers Launch Early Black Friday iPhone Deals with Up to $1,200 Off