The 31st UN Climate Summit, COP31, Teetered on the Brink of Total Collapse

The 31st UN climate summit, COP31, teetered on the brink of total collapse on Sunday, November 22, as delegates began departing the Turkish venue in Antalya before a final agreement could be reached.

Negotiations at the conference, which had already stretched more than 30 hours beyond its scheduled conclusion, ended in a stalemate. By Sunday, the atmosphere was defined by “deep distrust,“with observers noting that the summit had become an exercise in”eternal procrastination” by the European Union and other major powers.

Disputes over fossil fuel language

The EU also said that the inclusion of carbon capture and storage (CCUS) technologies instead of direct emission reductions “clashes with science.”

The situation was further complicated by the resistance of oil-producing nations, with Tuvalu’s climate minister, Maina Talia, remarking that it felt as though they were negotiating with the Saudis. Meanwhile, the draft agreement saw its point-count slashed from 144 to 80, with explicit demands for fossil fuel phase-outs stripped away. Even the goals for global electricity generation were weakened, shifting from a specific 35 percent target by 2035 to vague language regarding “global cooperation.”

fossil fuel phase-out
Photo: Proletären

John Verdieck warns COP31 risks erasing decades of progress

John Verdieck, head of international climate policy at The Nature Conservancy, warned that COP31 risked erasing decades of progress in a single night.

Over 100 fossil fuel organizations attend alongside 30 financing banks

The presence of fossil fuel industry lobbyists was a recurring point of contention. Over 100 organizations with ties to the fossil sector were present, and 30 participating banks were reported to have financed the industry with massive sums over the past five years.

Jonas Sjöstedt, a member of the European Parliament for the Left Party, said that while the richest one percent of Swedes have increased their emissions by 44 percent since 1990, those with the lowest incomes have successfully reduced theirs by 33 percent.

The event itself drew criticism for its opulence. Business Sweden hosted “climate karaoke” twice, and Time magazine held a dinner sponsored by luxury watchmaker Rolex. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s wife, Emine Erdoğan, hosted a high-level meeting for presidential spouses and inaugurated a “Zero Waste Museum” highlighting Turkey’s recycling journey from 13 to 37 percent.

Critics like Sky News analyst Tom Clarke questioned whether the conference serves any purpose at all, given the “self-important dignitaries” arriving by private jet to lecture on consumption.

Photo: Via TT

Delegations exit as negotiations face failure

The Swedish delegation, led by chief negotiator Mattias Frumerie and Climate Minister Romina Pourmokhtari (L), departed the venue as the summit entered its final hours. According to reports from Dagens Nyheter, the closing meeting appeared destined to end in a total fiasco, with multiple sources confirming that the EU was prepared to reject the draft agreement entirely.

The frustration was echoed by Michael Joseph, the environment minister of Antigua and Barbuda, who expressed deep disappointment and refused to accept the proposals in their current form. Meanwhile, BBC’s Mark Poynting said that while explicit fossil fuel language was removed, the text retained indirect references that the host nation, Turkey, hoped would serve as a sufficient compromise.

Diverging priorities in global climate action

Observers have noted a shift in these gatherings: Proletaren reports that far less time is now spent discussing actual ways to halt climate change than at landmark summits like Kyoto or Paris. The focus has moved to procedural gridlock, even as the Mitigation Work Programme — a key agenda item for emission reduction targets — nears expiration this year.

Photo: Dagens Arena

Critics also highlight a disconnect between climate rhetoric and domestic policy. Analysts from Dagens Arena said that while the richest populations must cut emissions 90 percent by 2030, their output has instead risen 44 percent since 1990. Addressing this inequality, tram driver Andreas Nyman suggested in a chronicle for Internationalen that unions could shift the focus away from infinite growth toward human needs by prioritizing shorter working hours over increased corporate profits.

Systemic uncertainty

Observers have questioned whether the current COP system remains functional. The EU has demanded a serious review of the COP process, arguing that repeatedly returning to summits to renegotiate previous commitments is a dead end.

As of Sunday, the prospect of the meeting ending in a total failure loomed, with the possibility that the summit might have to be reconvened in another city, similar to the UN biodiversity meeting in Colombia in 2024, which concluded in Rome months later.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Atomic Clocks Could Detect Quantum Superposition of Time, Study Proposes