The Game Awards declined to nominate the live-action Street Fighter film for Best Adaptation even though it grossed roughly $100 million worldwide, selecting Mortal Kombat II, Fallout season two, Cyberpunk: Edgerunners II, and The Super Mario Galaxy Movie instead, according to Moyens.
The omission came despite the film’s star-studded cast and a marketing campaign that had positioned it as a contender, according to Moyens. Gizmodo notes the audience just didn’t show up.
Eligibility was not the issue. Cyberpunk: Edgerunners II premiered a week later than Street Fighter and still made the cut, while the yet-unreleased Grand Theft Auto VI earned multiple nominations in other categories, Gizmodo reports. The outlet notes the official cutoff date falls later this week.
The five nominees represent a cross-section of streaming series and theatrical releases that voters judged to have stronger audience reach, fidelity to source material, or cultural footprint. The Super Mario Galaxy Movie “was a massive hit and far more people saw it than Street Fighter,” Gizmodo writes.
Resident Evil “actually did something cool with the material, giving audiences a fresh story filled with the tropes and feeling of the game,” and Mortal Kombat II “delivered on the gore and glory expectations of its core audience and leaned into a built-in fanbase.”
Moyens observes that The Super Mario Galaxy Movie moved numbers and captured family audiences, Resident Evil reinvented itself in ways critics and active fans rewarded, and Mortal Kombat II was a hit for the core audience.
Geoff Keighley, born in 1978 in Toronto, created a game-review site as a teenager and wrote nomination copy for the first televised game-awards show, Cybermania ’94, through family connections to IMAX.
After studying business at USC and writing deep-dive development pieces for GameSpot — including access to Valve and Epic Games — he hosted GameTrailers TV and fronted live events for E3, Gamescom and the Spike Video Game Awards before launching The Game Awards in 2014.
Geoff Keighley’s ceremony weighs platform performance, critical reception, and community conversation alongside artistic merit, Moyens observes, making the exclusion a deliberate judgment rather than a calendar oversight. Moyens writes that The Game Awards are curated by people who watch platform performance, critical reaction, and community conversation; Keighley’s ceremony is as much about industry signaling as celebration.
Moyens has sat across from writers and showrunners who treat adaptation as a negotiation: game fans bring expectations, studios bring budgets, and platforms such as Netflix, Prime Video, and Warner Bros. bring distribution muscle. Moyens adds that io9 and Kotaku have already analyzed the list, and streaming metrics tracked by platforms and sites like Box Office Mojo will be cited in meetings.