Testosterone replacement therapy can be a legitimate treatment for men with a diagnosed deficiency, but it is not risk-free, and it is not a substitute for a diagnosis.
A report published by UC San Diego Health dismantles four myths now circulating widely online about “optimizing” low testosterone.
The report lands amid a boom in virtual testosterone clinics that promise a diagnosis and a prescription within days or even hours, often on the strength of a single lab value and a short questionnaire. UC San Diego Health reported that this model skips the step that matters most: identifying why testosterone is low before replacing it.
A pituitary tumor, for example, can cause low testosterone, and simply replacing the hormone without investigating can leave an underlying brain tumor unchecked, the report warned. A specialist is also more likely to catch symptoms driven by something other than hormones altogether.
The consequence of skipping that workup is not theoretical. Even appropriately prescribed testosterone therapy requires ongoing monitoring, UC San Diego Health reported, for side effects that range from infertility to blood clots — and unsupervised online vendors typically offer neither bloodwork nor a conversation about the tradeoffs.
Interest in hormone is not a diagnosis
- Interest in a hormone is not a diagnosis. Only testing can establish whether therapy is necessary and safe.
- Testosterone therapy shuts down the body’s own production — including sperm production, sometimes to zero.
- Same-day online prescriptions skip the bloodwork and fertility conversations that legitimate programs require.
What “optimizing” actually does to the body
The second myth the report tackles is the idea that TRT is essentially risk-free when framed as “optimization.” UC San Diego Health listed what even properly prescribed therapy can do: suppress natural sperm production, sometimes to zero, causing infertility — a particular concern for men in their 20s and 30s who may want children later.
It can also raise red blood cell counts, a condition called erythrocytosis, which increases the risk of blood clots, stroke, or pulmonary embolism.
Testosterone therapy can shrink the testicles by suppressing the body’s own hormone signaling, and it can affect the prostate — which is why PSA monitoring is required, since testosterone can accelerate the growth of undetected cancer. The body’s own production shuts down on therapy, creating dependency.
“None of these are hypothetical footnotes,” UC San Diego Health reported — they are the reason legitimate programs require diagnosis, follow-up blood work, and a conversation about fertility goals before the first dose.
“When I have patients asking about TRT, I always spend time to ask about medical concerns and discuss both potential side effects and future family planning before I even begin the testing,” said Hsieh.
“If a patient’s concerns confirm a potential hormonal deficiency, there are a number of tests, including a simple blood test that can establish if TRT is necessary and if it can be safely prescribed. Skipping these essential discussions and testing is not optimization, it is unnecessary risk.”
The specialist gap men don’t see
The report’s sharpest contrast is with women’s care. Women are generally routed toward a gynecologist starting in adolescence or their early 20s and see one regularly for decades. Men have no equivalent expectation with urology — and, UC San Diego Health reported, the data shows it.
| Survey finding | Group | Share |
|---|---|---|
| No primary care provider | Adults ages 18–29 | 45% |
| No primary care provider | Adults ages 30–49 | 28% |
| Avoid going to the doctor | Men overall | 60% |
One national survey cited in the report found that 45% of adults ages 18–29 and 28% of adults ages 30–49 do not have a primary care provider, let alone a specialist relationship. A widely cited recent survey found 60% of men say they avoid going to the doctor altogether.
Broader research on men’s health care use, as reported by UC San Diego Health, has found men consistently make fewer primary care visits than women across every adult age group under 65.
That gap matters for testosterone specifically. Building a relationship with a urologist earlier — in your 20s or 30s, before there’s a crisis — means there is already a baseline on record, an established relationship for fertility or sexual health questions, and a specialist who knows your history looking out for your overall health.
“Women grow up with the expectation of an annual visit with an OB-GYN. Men mostly don’t have an equivalent, so a lot of them don’t know what a urologist does and don’t think of seeing one until something is already wrong,” Hsieh told UC San Diego Health.
“I’d love for more men to think of a urologist as a long-term relationship started when you’re young — someone you have a relationship with before you need one, not after.”
Why a same-day prescription misses the cause
The third myth — that a specialist is unnecessary to prescribe testosterone — is where the virtual clinic model draws the report’s clearest caution. A diagnosis and prescription within days or even hours, based on one lab value and a questionnaire, does not identify the cause of low testosterone before the prescription is written.
Because low testosterone can be a symptom rather than the disease, replacing the hormone without investigating can mask something more serious. The report also said that a specialist is more likely to consistently manage the therapy’s side effects — including fertility impacts — rather than just refilling a prescription.
Men planning children should discuss fertility preservation
Men in their 20s and 30s who may want children later should discuss fertility preservation before starting therapy, since treatment can suppress sperm production, sometimes to zero. Anyone considering testosterone should not source it through unsupervised online vendors, which typically provide no bloodwork or personalized risk discussion.
Prostate monitoring through PSA testing is required during treatment because testosterone can accelerate growth of undetected cancer. Anyone with symptoms of low testosterone should begin with a physician who specializes in male hormonal health, not a supplement stack or a same-day online prescription.
The bottom line from UC San Diego
Testosterone therapy is a real, valuable treatment for men who actually need it, the report concluded — prescribed and monitored by someone trained to manage both the benefits and the risks. The cultural moment has done a service by making it more common for men to talk about their health. But interest in a hormone is not the same as a diagnosis, and there is no substitute for a professional evaluation.
Consult a qualified physician about any hormone therapy decision.