Trump Pardons Pete Rose Posthumously, Blasts MLB Hall of Fame Exclusion

President Donald Trump announced on Thursday that he has given the late Pete Rose a “Complete and Total Pardon,” two years after the baseball legend’s death, while accusing Major League Baseball of treating Rose “terribly” over his exclusion from the Hall of Fame.

The pardon, revealed in a Truth Social post from Air Force One as Trump flew home from a trip to Asia, applies only to Rose’s federal conviction. The all-time hits leader pleaded guilty in 1990 to filing false income tax returns and served five months in a federal prison camp in Marion, Illinois, between August 1990 and January 1991. Rose was never criminally charged for the gambling that got him banned from baseball.

It remains unclear what practical effect the pardon will have. Rose was released from prison in 1991, and as CBS News points out, pardons do not apply to the Baseball Hall of Fame, which operates under its own eligibility rules. Rose’s path to Cooperstown runs through the Classic Baseball Era Committee, where he becomes eligible in December 2027, with induction possible as early as 2028.

“Rose was treated terribly by Major League Baseball in not allowing him to go into the Baseball Hall of Fame. Politics, I guess!”

So wrote Trump, who also compared Rose’s case to that of Roger Clemens, the 354-game winner who has also failed to gain induction. Trump inflated one number along the way — he called Rose’s 4,256 hits “a record… in a Season” when they were in fact a career total collected across 24 seasons.

Trump Pardons Pete Rose Posthumously, Blasts MLB Hall of Fame Exclusion
Photo: cbsnews.com

Rose’s records versus his ban

The on-field case has never been in dispute. Rose racked up a record 4,256 hits over more than two decades, most of them with the Cincinnati Reds, and won three World Series before later managing the Reds.

The ban stems from revelations that he bet on games, including some involving his own team, and he agreed to a lifetime ban from MLB in 1989. Rose always maintained he never bet against the Reds.

That distinction is the one Trump keeps drawing. At a White House event with UFC CEO Dana White earlier this month, Trump conceded Rose “shouldn’t have gambled” but argued the ban no longer fits an era of widespread legal sports betting. “He was gambling on his own team, Dana. He wasn’t gambling against. That’s different,” Trump said.

President Grants Pardon to Baseball Legend Pete Rose — Truth Social

Rose made four bids for reinstatement. His petitions in 2015 and 2022 were rejected, while former Commissioner Bud Selig in 1997 and current Commissioner Rob Manfred in 2020 simply did not respond, according to CBS News.

The White House weighing on Cooperstown

Trump’s lobbying pre-dates both his terms in office. In late 2015, he wrote that Rose was owed a place in the Hall: “He’s paid the price. So ridiculous — let him in!” The pressure campaign continued into his presidency.

Manfred met with Trump in early 2025, and less than a month later the commissioner lifted the ban on Rose, ruling that his lifetime ban ended with his death in September 2024. Manfred acknowledged the president’s influence on the decision and said Rose came up in their conversation, “but I’m not going beyond that.”

Trump telegraphed his intention to pardon Rose in early 2025, saying he would sign one “over the next few weeks.” That promise took nearly two years to land, and comes amid a broader pattern: this spring, Trump dismissed a soldier’s Polymarket betting case by saying it was “like Pete Rose betting on his own team.”

Pete Rose: key dates and figures  
Career hits (all-time MLB record) 4,256
MLB ban agreed 1989
Ban lifted by Manfred 2025
Classic Baseball Era Committee eligibility December 2027

Where the Hall of Fame decision actually sits

The pardon changes Rose’s legal record, not his legacy ledger. Under Hall of Fame rules, the Classic Baseball Era Committee — which considers long-retired figures — is the only route, and Rose will not appear on the standard ballot. A committee vote in December 2027 is the next substantive step, and anything before then is political pressure rather than procedural change.

Trump Pardons Pete Rose Posthumously, Blasts MLB Hall of Fame Exclusion
Photo: edition.cnn.com

The precedent matters for other banned names, too. Manfred’s 2025 decision also reinstated other deceased players who had been on the permanently ineligible list, widening the pool from which era committees can draw.

Major League Baseball, the organization whose commissioner holds Rose’s fate in his hands, is the oldest major professional sports league in the United States and Canada.

Its two founding leagues, the National League (formed in 1876) and the American League (1900), fought a bitter contract war in 1901 before the National Agreement of 1903 ended the poaching of players between them; they remained legally separate entities until merging into a single organization led by the commissioner of baseball in 2000.

The office itself was born of scandal. After the Black Sox conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series, baseball replaced its weak National Commission with a commissioner wielding near-unlimited authority over the sport — the same authority under which Rose accepted his lifetime ban in 1989. Today MLB comprises 30 teams and drew 71.4 million spectators in 2025, the highest total season attendance of any sports league in the world.

The mask-off moment from the White House is the framing of the ban itself as a political act — “Politics, I guess!” — directed at both MLB and Cooperstown. Now the sport’s gatekeepers must answer that charge when the committee convenes in December 2027.

Photo of author

Sport Desk

Sport Desk at Archyde.

Westminster and Kensington & Chelsea Bike Hangar Fees to Exceed Car Permit Costs in 2027