Trump, Xi, Putin Agree to Nuclear Dialogue, Ease Putin Isolation at APEC Meeting

“We have a special responsibility,” President Donald Trump told Chinese leader Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin on Thursday, Nov. 19, as the three men sat around a circular table in Shenzhen.

The occasion was a trilateral summit on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum, where the leaders of the world’s three largest nuclear powers agreed to a dialogue on reducing the risks and proliferation of nuclear weapons.

The words were warm. The results, so far, are only words. As The Christian Science Monitor reported from Shenzhen, the declaration commits the three governments to a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and proliferation, and to reforming the United Nations to strengthen its impact on global security.

It made no mention of Ukraine, where the war Mr. Putin ordered in 2022 grinds on, and it offered no details on the energy pledges that could ease sanctions on Russian oil.

Historic FIRST: Trump, Putin and Xi meet for nuclear talks — Fox News

What the summit did deliver, unmistakably, was an ending to Mr. Putin’s long international isolation. Mr. Trump called him “my friend.” Mr. Xi seated him beside himself, at the Kylin Villa in the foothills above Shenzhen, and let him speak second, before the American president. For a leader still wanted by the International Criminal Court, the choreography itself was the prize.

“Putin got … a dose of respect from the Chinese and American leaders,” Sergey Markov, a political analyst and former Kremlin advisor, told The Christian Science Monitor.

What the declaration actually says

The Declaration toward Peace released after the meeting rests on two pillars. The first is nuclear: the three leaders agreed that, as the world’s biggest nuclear powers, they are “uniquely positioned” to discuss arms reductions, in Mr. Trump’s framing. The second is institutional: a pledge to reform the United Nations and give the body greater weight on global security.

That second pillar tracks a project Mr. Xi has been pushing with mounting urgency. Under his “global governance initiative,” Beijing wants to “democratize” the international system and enlarge the voice of Global South countries, where Chinese influence runs deep. The trilateral gave that vision, symbolically at least, the endorsement of the other two superpowers.

Two further agreements landed in Mr. Putin’s column. The leaders pledged to “increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products” and stabilize energy flows, though no details were provided, and The Christian Science Monitor notes this could mean an easing of U.S. sanctions targeting Russian oil exports.

They also warned the International Criminal Court not to “abuse their jurisdiction,” stressing the “immunities of state officials.” Mr. Trump had called the court a “rogue” organization on Thursday.

Where the three leaders diverge

For all the pageantry, the summit papers over real friction. Mr. Putin used his platform to insist Russia be treated as a peer, saying Russia, China and the United States “can make a significant contribution to strengthening global security” only if cooperation rests on “mutual respect and equality.”

That is a demand aimed squarely at Washington, and it sits awkwardly beside the war in Ukraine, which Mr. Putin has so far shown little willingness to negotiate an end to.

Trump pushes nuclear arms control in HIGH-Stakes Xi, Putin meeting — Fox News

Mr. Trump, for his part, said he discussed Ukraine at length with both counterparts and that all three want it to end. Europeans, pointedly excluded from the table, bristled.

On the same day, leaders of Ukraine, France, the U.K. and other countries gathered in Berlin for a “coalition of the willing” summit on security, a gathering whose atmosphere clashed sharply with the Shenzhen images of Messrs. Trump and Putin hob-knobbing at APEC.

Mr. Xi came away with perhaps the quietest but largest win: his closest ally restored to the company of superpowers, and a Beijing-centric revision of world order advanced in front of the world’s cameras. “The seeds sown at the summit today will surely take root, sprout, bloom and bear fruit,” Mr. Xi said in a statement released by China’s Foreign Ministry.

Trump, Xi and Putin meeting on nuclear risks delivers no breakthroughs — Associated Press

The skepticism worth hearing

“This is a good start,” says Lyle Goldstein, who directs the China Initiative at Brown University, adding that the symbolism of the meeting itself lowers tensions, sending a top-down message to the nations’ militaries to rein it in at the brink.

But Dr. Goldstein’s follow-up question is the one hanging over the whole enterprise: “Will there be follow-up? Or will we retreat back to a world of hot rivalry?”

Trump, Xi and Putin plan an unprecedented 3-way meeting: Ukraine, Iran, nuclear weapons on agenda — CBS Chicago

That question has extra weight because of Mr. Trump’s weakened position at home. His party’s sweeping defeat in this month’s midterm elections, which voters used to reject his strongman tendencies, weakened his position heading into the summit and may complicate his ability to translate its goals into policy on his return. Mr. Xi and Mr. Putin face no such constraint.

Mr. Trump, meanwhile, relished the stage. “Xi and I have formed an outstanding personal relationship,” he told reporters. “It’s gotten closer and closer.”

What happens after Shenzhen

The open questions are the story now. Whether the nuclear dialogue produces talks, whether the U.N. reform pledge becomes anything more than language, and whether the energy understanding loosens sanctions on Russian oil, none of that is settled, and the sources give no timeline. The Iran war continues to simmer, and Ukraine’s fighting continues without a mention in the peace declaration.

Shenzhen was a fitting stage for such a staging of power. Its economy now outstrips those of neighboring Hong Kong and Guangzhou, and it hosts the Shenzhen Stock Exchange and some of the world’s largest technology firms, including Huawei and Tencent, earning it the nickname “China’s Silicon Valley.”

That a city built on manufacturing and trade should host the first-ever trilateral meeting of the leaders of the United States, China, and Russia underscores how central Shenzhen has become to the global economy the three men were addressing.

What is certain is the message the meeting sent: three men who command the earth’s biggest militaries, sitting at one table, declaring a special obligation to safeguard peace. Whether the militaries below them got the memo, and whether the declaration outlives the photo opportunity, will be tested long before the three leaders share a room again.

Earlier coverage: Trump, Xi, Putin Meet at APEC Summit; Issue Joint Statement on Nuclear Risk, UN, ICC

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Jockey Premium Outlet Opens in Lima with 75 Brands and 50-70% Discounts