Nearly a dozen bullets went through a closed apartment door on Cushing Avenue in Dorchester in February — and now the two Boston police officers who fired them face indictments.
A Suffolk County grand jury charged Officers Rudy Lewis and Jairo Polanco with assault with a dangerous weapon for the Valentine’s Day shooting, according to their attorneys.
The Boston Globe first reported the indictments Tuesday. No one was struck by gunfire, and authorities said at the time that no one had been shot. It marks the second time in recent months that Suffolk District Attorney Kevin Hayden’s office has brought charges against a Boston officer in a shooting case.
The officers’ lawyers say the woman inside the apartment pulled a knife. She told WBZ-TV she was unarmed. That gap — one door, two irreconcilable accounts — is now the heart of a criminal case.
What the attorneys say happened
Ken Anderson, who represents Polanco, told The Boston Globe the officers had good reason to believe the woman who came to the door was in danger. When she answered it, he said, she told police she couldn’t open it “because a man inside is going to kill her if she does.” Then, he said, she brandished the knife.

“They were there to help this woman and she ends up pulling a knife on them,” Anderson said. “I just don’t see how this somehow corresponds to a crime.”
He called the push for indictments “a deeply misguided decision made by armchair Monday morning quarterback prosecutors who don’t care about the safety of police officers.”
Lewis’s attorney, Ben Megrian, was blunter. “What people need to know is that a woman jabbed a knife toward my client’s face in close range,” he said in a written statement. “My client repeatedly ordered the woman to drop the knife. She refused.”
“The DA’s office seems to believe officers need to get stabbed in the face before they are allowed to react.”
According to WHDH, Anderson said that once the woman was subdued, and her knife was taken, they had to consider if there was an armed man nearby. Polanco, a five-year veteran, then did a sweep of the apartment looking for the other man, Anderson told the station.
The woman’s account
The 25-year-old mother, who spoke to WBZ’s I-Team weeks after the shooting, said she was home alone when officers fired through her door. She said she had no weapon, that police tased her, and that bullets entered the bedroom where her 5-year-old son sleeps. She was taken to the hospital and was not arrested.
“I thought I was going to die,” she told WBZ. “I feel a little bit sad because what if my son was here? He would have been dead.”
According to a Feb. 14 Boston police incident report cited by WBZ, officers were responding to calls about screaming inside the apartment. WBZ reported the charges as assault and battery with a dangerous weapon and gave the second officer’s name as Jaciro Polcano; The Boston Globe and WHDH both identify him as Jairo Polanco.
The police union weighed in fast. Larry Calderone, president of the Boston Police Patrolmen’s Association, said someone at the home “brandished a knife, and the officers were in fear for their lives.” In a statement Tuesday evening, he said union leadership is “severely disappointed in the DA’s decision to indict our police officers for doing their jobs.”
How the case unfolded
Authorities have released few details about what happened. WHDH reported that at the time of the incident, police said the woman involved was arrested and she then underwent a mental health evaluation; WBZ reported she was taken to the hospital and was not arrested. Messages seeking comment were left Tuesday for the Boston Police Department and Suffolk District Attorney Kevin Hayden.
Megrian also raised a procedural complaint to WBZ: “We are deeply concerned about the integrity of this investigation when the public and the media are learning about it before the charges have been unsealed.”
The indictments land amid a broader shift at the Suffolk DA’s office. In March, Officer Nicholas O’Malley was charged with manslaughter after fatally shooting Stephenson King, 39, on March 11 as King allegedly tried to flee a traffic stop in a stolen car.
Prosecutors contend O’Malley had no justification for firing at a moving vehicle. In that case, charges were filed before a grand jury convened; O’Malley was later indicted and has pleaded not guilty.
Messages seeking comment were left Tuesday for the Boston Police Department and for District Attorney Hayden, The Boston Globe reported.