Two more speeding fines from a section control in Lo-Reninge were thrown out on Tuesday because the cameras were financed by a private company — the third time a Flemish police court has ruled this way.
A police judge in Ypres annulled both fines, according to Nieuwsblad, after earlier victories for drivers in Meise and Lanaken.
The problem in all three cases: the section controls were outsourced to TaaS, a private player offering “Trajectcontrole-as-a-service” — a group that also includes Trafiroad of “Keizer van de Wegwijzer” Glen Janssens. The fine cameras are therefore not financed by the municipality, and the law does not allow that.
“De wet schrijft dwingend voor dat de financiering van dergelijke handhavingssystemen volledig in handen van de overheid moet liggen,” said Joachim Vanspeybrouck, the lawyer for the Lo-Reninge driver who won twice on Tuesday in the Ypres police court. “De wet is er net om winstbejag door privépartijen te voorkomen.”
Traffic expert Johan De Mol (UGent) points to the money involved. “Elke gemeente moet per boete 29 euro betalen aan TaaS,” he said, calling it a standard fee TaaS demands under its contracts. De Mol knows the issue from experience: he was caught by a section control in Meise and successfully went to the Vilvoorde police court last year.
About thirty Flemish municipalities rely on TaaS, according to De Mol, especially in Limburg and Vlaams-Brabant. “In België kennen we officieel geen precedentenrecht, maar de recente vonnissen kunnen wel als inspiratie dienen. En kunnen dus ook leiden tot dezelfde beslissingen door andere politierechters,” he said.
Traffic lawyer Ashley Bickx of Wanted Law in Sint-Niklaas expects the same outcome in future challenges. “Normaal gesproken zal de politierechter je volgen,” she said, though she warned that drivers must weigh the costs: someone with a 53-euro fine can end up in an expensive case if legal aid does not step in and lawyer’s fees must be paid personally.
Anyone who received a fine can check the official report themselves, she said: “Op elk proces-verbaal staat vermeld wie er instond voor de vaststelling. Vind je daarop een privéfirma, dan gaan de alarmbellen af.” The offence must also have been recorded by a named police officer — a computer system does not count.
Lo-Reninge is a small municipality and city in the province of West Flanders, comprising the towns of Lo, Noordschote, Pollinkhove and Reninge, with about 3,306 inhabitants across 62.94 km2. Its Old Town Hall of Lo, built between 1565 and 1566, and its belfry were inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 1999 as part of the Belfries of Belgium and France site.
Lo-Reninge mayor Lieve Castryck (Dynamisch) said she sees no breach of the law and is considering an appeal “indien nodig”.
“Toen we de infrastructuur lieten plaatsen, liet de wetgeving die er toen was ons toe om samen te werken met TaaS. Onze betrachting is altijd geweest om iets aan de verkeersveiligheid te doen. Aan een verdienmodel werd nooit gedacht. Maar als kleine stad konden we de kosten voor de plaatsing niet dragen. Uit cijfers zien we dat het de verkeersveiligheid bevordert,” she said.
Related reading