UN Talks on ‘Killer Robots’ End in Watered-Down Compromise, Delaying Binding Rules for Two Years

United Nations talks in Geneva collapsed into a watered-down compromise Saturday, leaving lethal autonomous weapons unregulated for at least two more years despite urgent warnings from the Red Cross and the Pope, NPR reported.

After a week of negotiations that stretched until 4:30 a.m. Saturday, 128 countries party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons agreed only to “elaborate” on possible regulations by 2028, dropping earlier demands for a legally binding treaty within twelve months. The mandate does not commit states to a binding instrument, Al Jazeera noted, after the United States, Russia, and Israel blocked the faster timeline backed by nearly 100 nations.

“There is a fundamental ethical concern with having what are essentially these life-and-death decisions determined by programming, determined by an algorithm. That’s not something that you can fix with better technology. That is a moral red line that we cannot cross.”

Georgia Hinds, legal adviser at the International Committee of the Red Cross, told NPR.

Nations agree to ‘elaborate’ on rules for AI-run ‘killer robots’ by 2028
Photo: Al Jazeera

Russia stalled proceedings from day one with procedural objections, while the United States countered with a proposal for a five-year window to discuss non-binding guidelines. “They’re just kicking the can down the road,” one frustrated delegate told NPR. The final text, hammered out in overnight sessions, replaced the word “negotiate” with “elaborate” at the insistence of major military powers, according to Swiss diplomat Julien Thöni, who chaired the conference.

The consensus trap

The Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons operates on consensus, giving any single state a de facto veto. That structural flaw has paralyzed the forum for over a decade. “This proposal looks designed to keep talks trapped in the dysfunctional consensus process for years to come,” said Magnus Lovold of the Lex International Fund, speaking to TRT World.

Frustrated diplomats acknowledged the deal was “better than nothing.” Brazil’s ambassador to the UN Conference on Disarmament, Frederico Meyer, put it bluntly: “We cannot leave the table with empty hands. (No deal) would be terrible for the world, terrible for the United Nations and terrible for human beings.”

Technology outraces diplomacy

While diplomats debated syntax, the battlefield has already moved on. In Sudan this year, 80% of civilian deaths were caused by drones, according to the UN. Ukraine, Gaza, and Sudan have seen semi-autonomous systems select and strike targets with minimal human oversight. The Future of Life Institute, citing deployments in active conflicts, warned that “slaughterbots are killing innocent civilians and proliferating to bad actors.”

Unlike nuclear weapons, autonomous systems are accessible. “There are autonomous weapons that are easy to purchase or even to create for all kinds of actors: individuals, nonstate actors, criminal groups,” said Anna Hehir, head of military AI governance at the Future of Life Institute, speaking to NPR and TRT World.

Ukrainian servicemen testing an unmanned ground vehicle in Zaporizhzhia region
Photo: TRT World
State Position Countries Stated Goal
Legally binding treaty ~100 nations (Austria, Brazil, Pakistan, others) New protocol to CCW within 1 year
Non-binding guidelines United States, Czechia Political declaration / voluntary code
Continue talks without goal Russia, Belarus, Israel, Poland, Japan Status quo / further discussion
Adopted compromise All 128 CCW states parties “Elaborate” options by 2028

The Stop Killer Robots coalition, representing over 300 organizations, called the outcome “watered down” and a “nothing burger.” Its executive director, Nicole van Rooijen, told AFP: “Delaying the creation of a legally binding instrument puts civilians and humanity at risk.” Human Rights Watch deputy director for arms Verity Coyle echoed that assessment: “It does not provide the urgent action needed to agree new rules, but the technology is racing ahead.”

The accountability vacuum

International humanitarian law requires a human commander to be accountable for every strike. “You cannot hold a machine accountable for a violation of the law,” Hinds told NPR. Yet as AI-driven targeting accelerates, the window for meaningful human judgment shrinks.

France 24, interviewing SIPRI researcher Vincent Boulanin, reported that states agree commanders remain responsible, but “the question is, how do the autonomous features affect their ability to see that their usage will be lawful.”

The Center for Strategic and International Studies documented that U.S. federal agencies awarded 2,255 AI-related contracts worth $4.1 billion between fiscal years 2019 and 2025, with the Department of Defense accounting for 83% of obligations.

UN Talks on 'Killer Robots' End in Watered-Down Compromise, Delaying Binding Rules for Two Years
Photo: Future of Life Institute

CCW determines which autonomous weapons to ban or regulate

The mandate tasks the CCW with determining which autonomous weapons can be banned under international humanitarian law and which can be permitted but regulated. Max Tegmark, chair of the Future of Life Institute, urged states frustrated by the process to “take the issue elsewhere, to an assembly where their voices will be heard.”

The International Committee of the Red Cross, founded in Geneva in 1863 after Henry Dunant witnessed the carnage at Solferino, is the guardian of the Geneva Conventions that underpin international humanitarian law. A three-time Nobel Peace Prize laureate (1917, 1944, 1963), it holds a unique mandate from states to protect victims of armed conflict and promote the legal frameworks now being tested by autonomous weapons.

“The CCW has not met the urgency the situation requires. Enough is enough,” Tegmark said in a statement published November 21.

Earlier coverage: UN 'Killer Robots' Talks Run Out of Time as Russia Blocks Consensus

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Ģērmane Secures First World Cup Top-10 of Season in Gurgl, Austria

Kospi, Nasdaq Drop Over 5%; Blind Users Post Heavy Losses