University of Bath Study Finds Essential Genes Do Not Mutate Less Than Others

University of Bath researchers have found no evidence that essential genes mutate less often than other genes, directly challenging a hypothesis first proposed in 1972 and recently revived in scientific debate.

Dr. Sofia Radrizzani and Professor Laurence D. Hurst published their analysis on November 12 in PLOS Biology, using the largest dataset of spontaneous mutations assembled to date. The study examined roughly 3,600 mutations in E. coli and 4,600 in baker’s yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) drawn from mutation-accumulation experiments designed to minimize natural selection’s filtering effect.

Hypothesis and the “Ghost Mutations” Problem

The idea that organisms protect their most vital genes from mutation dates to a 1972 proposal by biologist Edward Cox. It resurfaced in 2022 when a team led by J. Grey Monroe at the Max Planck Institute reported lower mutation rates in functionally important regions of the thale cress genome. Hurst and colleagues reanalyzed that data in 2023, identifying sequencing errors that undermined the findings, though Monroe’s team maintained their conclusions.

Hurst argues that earlier observations of fewer mutations in essential genes reflect a sampling artifact. Natural selection rapidly removes organisms carrying harmful mutations in critical genes before researchers can detect them.

“We’d expect natural selection to rapidly remove mutations when they occur in more important genes, because these mutations are more likely to be harmful to the organism. This can create the illusion that important genes have fewer mutations when, in reality, some mutations have simply disappeared before we have a chance to analyze them – what you can think of as ‘ghost mutations,'” Hurst said.

Testing with Minimal Selection

To bypass that bias, Radrizzani and Hurst used mutation-accumulation lines — populations propagated under minimal selective pressure so that mutations, including deleterious ones, persist long enough to be catalogued. Three independent checks found no evidence that selection had substantially skewed the data. “This looks like the largest and cleanest sample of mutations assembled to date,” Radrizzani said.

The team measured gene importance three ways: whether deleting the gene kills the cell, how much protein the gene produces, and how strongly natural selection has acted on the gene over evolutionary time. None predicted mutation rate.

Lamarck and Darwin Models for Mutations and Evolution

“Analyze the data any which way and we found nothing. In neither species did these key genes have a lower mutation rate,” Hurst said. Radrizzani added: “We found that genes producing more abundant proteins don’t have lower mutation rates. Nor does the way genes evolve over thousands of years predict how frequently they mutate.”

What Affects Mutation Rates

The study did confirm known structural influences. In yeast, genes replicated later during DNA copying accumulated mutations more frequently than early-replicated genes.

University of Bath Study Finds Essential Genes Do Not Mutate Less Than Others
Photo: ScienceAlert

“While we see known causes of variation in mutation rates, we found no evidence for the effects that have been proposed as a challenge to the conventional model. None predicted which genes would have high or low mutation rates, and there are certainly no grounds for a shift in paradigm,” Hurst said.

“The claim that mutation is slower for important genes is a triumph of hype over substance,” Radrizzani said. “It’s a really old suggestion and is reinvented in various forms routinely.”

The University of Bath, which received its royal charter in 1966, traces its origins to the Bristol Trade School founded in 1856. In the 2021 Research Excellence Framework, 40% of its submitted research activity was classified as world-leading, the highest possible rating.

Important genes not protected from rando
Photo: UA.NEWS

The paper, titled “The importance of genes does not predict their mutation rate,” was authored by Sofia Radrizzani and Laurence D. Hurst and published on November 12 in PLOS Biology. Dr. Radrizzani co-wrote the new paper as part of her PhD. The study analyzed data from experiments designed to record mutations while minimizing the influence of natural selection.

These experiments, known as mutation accumulation studies, allowed researchers to examine genetic changes in E. coli and yeast. Once again, the results failed to support the idea that more important genes receive special protection. Although mutations do not occur at identical rates everywhere in the genome, the evidence from bacteria and yeast offers no indication that evolution systematically protects its most important genes by reducing how often they mutate.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

UWA Men’s Soccer Defeats Tuskegee 7-1