URBANA, Ill. — Rebecca S. Gutierrez, a 50-year-old Charleston woman, was sentenced on November 16 to 27 months in federal prison for a wire fraud scheme that siphoned nearly $1 million from her former employer over five years, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Central District of Illinois.
The sentence will be followed by three years of supervised release. Gutierrez, who served as office manager at Hastings and Havlik Family Dentistry in Mattoon from 2019 to 2025, pleaded guilty in July to five counts of wire fraud.
The gap at the center of the case is stark: monthly transfers from the dental practice’s business account to Gutierrez’s personal accounts ranged from $3,000 to just over $41,000, prosecutors said at the sentencing hearing. That spread — sometimes a car payment, sometimes a house payment — is part of why the scheme ran undetected from June 2020 until her employment ended in 2025.
What kept it hidden, federal prosecutors said, was bookkeeping. Gutierrez made false accounting entries to conceal the transfers, allowing the theft to continue until the total reached $918,681.70.
Chief U.S. District Judge Colin S. Bruce said at the hearing that Gutierrez abused the position of trust she had been given, and that the consequence must be appropriate to deter others from this conduct, according to the Justice Department.
FBI Springfield Special Agent in Charge Ryan Presley said the trust employers place in those who manage their finances was repeatedly and deliberately violated in this case.
“Employers place tremendous trust in the individuals responsible for managing their finances, and in this case that trust was repeatedly and deliberately violated,” said FBI Springfield Special Agent in Charge Ryan Presley.
“The defendant concealed her theft for years through deceptive bookkeeping practices, allowing the scheme to continue until nearly $1 million had been stolen. When someone exploits a position of responsibility for personal gain, accountability is essential, and the FBI stands ready to assist victims in pursuing justice.”
Prosecutors laid out a pattern that began in June 2020, barely a year after Gutierrez took the office manager job. Electronic transfers moved from the practice’s business account to her personal accounts month after month, with amounts that varied widely — the $3,000 low end and the $41,000-plus high end bracket a five-year run that ended only when her employment did in 2025.
The statutory penalties Gutierrez faced on each wire fraud count were steep: up to 20 years in prison, a $250,000 fine and up to three years of supervised release per count, prosecutors noted. The 27-month sentence falls far below the maximum, though it comes with a financial reckoning attached.
Gutierrez has paid $500,000 in restitution toward the $918,681.70 she owes the victims, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office. That leaves a balance of more than $418,000 still outstanding.
The FBI’s Springfield Field Office and the Mattoon Police Department investigated the case. Assistant United States Attorneys William J. Lynch and Eugene Miller handled the prosecution.
For small employers, the case is a reminder of how long an internal theft can run when the person controlling the books is also the person moving the money — five years, in this instance, with the fraud ending only when the job did. Gutierrez now reports to the Bureau of Prisons, and the supervised release term that follows will carry the conditions Chief Judge Colin S. Bruce set on November 16, 2026.